Is Baker Mayfield a Top 10 QB

[tlance]

There's no arguably about it. Hue's 3-36-1 record with the Browns is the worst by a coach with one team in league history.

He is saying Freddie is arguably the worst coach in NFL history.

And he isn’t even the worst coach the Browns have had in the last decade.

Freddie was pretty bad, but there is no case for him being “worst NFL coach of all time”.

 

[antone112]

I'd say definitely he might be, but maybe not.

If he plays well this week, I'd put him up there with those who could perhaps be considered.

 

[Sharkonabicycle]

did replying "ok" really imply I was blowing a gasket to you? FYI, pre 2020 I was not a big fan of Baker either. Having an adult in charge has helped him (on and off field) IMO.

You have a nice Sunday, as well.

Yes... it did....

DT you take me too seriously mah dude, LOL. All is good, and thanks for the Sunday wishes, hopefully the Hawks (and Browns *ahem as long as Mayfield plays terribly*) can win!

 

[dtgold88]

He is saying Freddie is arguably the worst coach in NFL history.

And he isn’t even the worst coach the Browns have had in the last decade.

Freddie was pretty bad, but there is no case for him being “worst NFL coach of all time”.

If you watched him "work" you could easily make a case. For sure the Browns worse coach. We were not interested in winning when Huie took over.

 

[dtgold88]

Yes... it did....

DT you take me too seriously mah dude, LOL. All is good, and thanks for the Sunday wishes, hopefully the Hawks (and Browns *ahem as long as Mayfield plays terribly*) can win!

Just find a Browns forum if the Browns win the game....I'm sure you will find any number of "fans" who will still offer reasons why Baker is no good.

wish I was kidding.

 

[Wamu]

He is saying Freddie is arguably the worst coach in NFL history.

And he isn’t even the worst coach the Browns have had in the last decade.

Freddie was pretty bad, but there is no case for him being “worst NFL coach of all time”.

Oh damn, my bad. I got my years mixed up. Don't know what I was thinking. Thanks for the correction.

 

[Sharkonabicycle]

Just find a Browns forum if the Browns win the game....I'm sure you will find any number of "fans" who will still offer reasons why Baker is no good.

wish I was kidding.

Well even Tom Brady was getting criticism for going with the Bucs... there's always 'those fans'. That said, I will continue to call your QB Baker Mayfraud... even if he wins 5 Superbowls... it's the principle at this point.

 

[dtgold88]

Well even Tom Brady was getting criticism for going with the Bucs... there's always 'those fans'. That said, I will continue to call your QB Baker Mayfraud... even if he wins 5 Superbowls... it's the principle at this point.

I hear ya. at least you are doing it somewhat tongue in cheek (I think?).

 

[Wamu]

Just find a Browns forum if the Browns win the game....I'm sure you will find any number of "fans" who will still offer reasons why Baker is no good.

wish I was kidding.

"fans" huh? Okay those are fighting words. Get ready for a knuckle sammich! I called him a jackass douchebag the moment the Browns drafted him. Called him a douchebag his rookie year. And said a few things about him his second year in the league.

But the combo of getting married and finally having a competent coach that actually knows what he's doing has seemingly taken some of the dumbfuckery outta him. Which is a good thing.

 

[Sharkonabicycle]

I hear ya. at least you are doing it somewhat tongue in cheek (I think?).

Eh ya think correctly...

I said Baker would be a massive bust... so far he's not been a massive bust... thus I'm a little pissed at my own opinion... I'll gladly admit I was wrong given a couple years but I'm not sold on Baker YET. Hence "Baker Mayfraud" lol (I mean it's just so fitting, c'mon!)

All said, I said Russell Wilson was a stupid pick as well. WOOPS. I've owned up to that several times on this board.

 

[tlance]

If you watched him "work" you could easily make a case. For sure the Browns worse coach. We were not interested in winning when Huie took over.

Not really man.

They underachieved by a good bit. Probably 3-4 games in 1 season.

That isn’t worst coach of all time resume. Plenty of coaches have done that.

 

[RememberTheKoy]

Cool....but Baker didn't use those O-line issues along with many others that game and balled out.

But his balled out best season wasn't any better than Wentz's 2019 season when he had all sorts of oline injuries and was throwing to practice squad WRs.

 

[RememberTheKoy]

Mayfield has won a playoff game.

Wentz hasn't.


What?

Wentz would have beat Seattle if he wasn't speared in the back of the head by Clowney and removed from the game.

 

[RememberTheKoy]

How about last season Baker got better but Wentz regressed.....again?

Bakers best season last year wasn't even better than Wentz's best 3.

How about Baker tossing an INT right now and then dislocating his arm?

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Wentz is solid Gold in the red zone (for the other team) 2 times near the endzone Zero points.
Goofiest INT I seen in a long time.

 

[Wamu]

Wentz would have beat Seattle if he wasn't speared in the back of the head by Clowney and removed from the game.

Coulda, woulda, shoulda but didn't. Excuses, it's all you got. And like I said in a different comment you're completely full of shit when you said CW has only missed two games due to injury. He missed 12 total games. So the Eagles sat the # 2 overall pick 10 times and he wasn't injured? Not a chance.

Hey did you see CW's red zone pick? It was classic. It'll be remember right up there with the butt fumble. Goal to go, shovel pass, no receiver around, throws it towards the backs of his o-linemen. Right into the hands of a waiting defender.

 

[Wamu]

Wentz is solid Gold in the red zone (for the other team) 2 times near the endzone Zero points.
Goofiest INT I seen in a long time.

That play is an instant classic.

 

[Wamu]

Bakers best season last year wasn't even better than Wentz's best 3.

How about Baker tossing an INT right now and then dislocating his arm?

Hoping for an injury? That's just ain't right. There's something wrong with you.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Bakers best season last year wasn't even better than Wentz's best 3.

How about Baker tossing an INT right now and then dislocating his arm?

then he leads his team to a touchdown.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

Wentz would have beat Seattle if he wasn't speared in the back of the head by Clowney and removed from the game.

Well, that part is wrong. Wentz calls Russell Wilson "Daddy" and always will. Even in 2017 when Wentz was the supposed MVP.