They were getting pushed around and all those numbers mean nothing when you've faced poor teams all year. Not one of the teams you faced are a legitimate top 50 team. Most of them might not even be a top 100 team. Those stats are irrelevant due to your awful schedule.
Wait a minute... you said you go off stats. Guess not so much when they blow up in your face.
...and Wisconsins schedule is complete garbage. Don't back out of playing teams like UW and we'd both be ok in SOS.