Tony has all the length, etc you can want, but when it comes to making putts when they really matter...you probably wouldn't take either of those guys that were in the playoff, but Simpson made the ones that counted the most.
Finau is going to make a lot of money on tour, so we're going to see him in the majors, and big events, but doubtful he's ever going to join the ranks of Keopka, Justin Thomas, etc. winning multiple times on tour during a season.