2016 NFL Salary Cap Play-In 3 : Milk vs WLK

[Nosferatu]

MILK

OFFENSE
QB - Phillip Rivers - $16,500,000
RB - Chris Johnson - $1,500,000
RB - Latavius Murray - $701,550
WR - Josh Gordon - $817,016
WR - Michael Thomas - $930,722
WR - Tyreek Hill - $497,500
TE - Zach Ertz - $3,311,563
LT - Jermon Bushrod - $1,437,500
LG - Marshal Yanda - $4,010,220
C - Travis Frederick - $2,185,978
RG - Jahri Evans - $1,000,000
RT - Kyle Long - $7,614,054

DEFENSE
DE - Elvis Dummervil - $7,375,000
DT - Domata Peko - $3,725,000
DE - Leonard Williams - $4,234,288
OLB - James Harrison - $1,500,000
ILB - Bobby Wagner - $6,068,750
ILB - D'Qwell Jackson - $5,750,000
OLB - Tamba Hali - $3,802,083
CB - Deion Sanders - $30,000,000 - WILDCARD
CB - Johnathan Joseph - $7,000,000
CB - Robert Alford - $1,082,263
SS - Dashon Goldson - $1,468,750
FS - Earl Thomas - $9,900,000

VS

WLK

OFFENSE
QB - Marcus Mariota - $5,503,176
RB - Adrian Peterson - $12,000,000
3DB/WR - Theo Riddick - $1,785,250
WR - Dez Bryant - $13,000,000
WR - Terrelle Pryor - $1,671,000
WR - Taylor Gabriel - $600,000
TE - Delanie Walker - $6,267,708
LT - Terron Armstead - $3,075,359
LG - Justin Pugh - $2,655,513
C - Nick Mangold - $8,600,000
RG - Richie Incognito - $3,250,000
RT - Bryan Bulaga - $5,462,500

DEFENSE
DE - Michael Bennett - $7,000,000
DT - Nick Fairley - $1,510,000
DT - Geno Atkins - $9,600,000
DE - Chandler Jones - $7,799,000
OLB - Jordan Hicks - $706,183
MLB - Dont'a Hightower - $7,751,000
OLB - Jaime Collins - $917,864
CB - Richard Sherman - $14,769,000
CB - Ryan Logan - $1,811,813
CB - TJ Carrie - $616,741
SS - Donte Whitner - $458,824
FS - Harrison Smith - $7,278,000

 

[Nosferatu]

MILK - 2
WLK - 6

VOTED - WLK, Shane, Meebs, Femur, Nos, Ritz, UK, 500

 

[wlk3]

I think me and Milk have similar teams however mine is better... me

 

[Shanemansj13]

Wlk by a hair. I like the way his offense is set up. I do like Milks D a liittle better

 

[Mebert]

I have milk in a close one

 

[femurov]

WLK.

 

[wlk3]

I have milk in a close one

Not to sway you but Elvis at 3-4 DE is pretty bad even if I'd have kept Doug Free...

 

[Mebert]

Not to sway you but Elvis at 3-4 DE is pretty bad even if I'd have kept Doug Free...

That was not the best. swapping Hali and Dumerville would have been much better imo

 

[Nosferatu]

I have to lean WLK here

 

[Ritzarmy]

All most voted for Milk for once but just couldn't because of his offense. I feel he should have went with a FB instead of a 2nd RB and not a fan of his receivers. On defense I do like Milk's defense better of course lead by the stud Neon Deion. Even though WLK is saying Elvis is a bad 3-4 DE I still think overall Milk has a better D.

 

[Nosferatu]

All most voted for Milk for once but just couldn't because of his offense. I feel he should have went with a FB instead of a 2nd RB and not a fan of his receivers. On defense I do like Milk's defense better of course lead by the stud Neon Deion. Even though WLK is saying Elvis is a bad 3-4 DE I still think overall Milk has a better D.

So you are voting WLK?

 

[Ritzarmy]

So you are voting WLK?

Almost voted for Milk means I vote for WLK. I guess I technically didn't say it just like you didn't say you were voting for yourself. I am reconsidering my pick in your matchup now.

 

[Pack 500]

I think Milk's defense is the dominant unit in this matchup. I vote him

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Not to sway you but Elvis at 3-4 DE is pretty bad even if I'd have kept Doug Free...

thats funny... But i honestly think some of us a too strict on that whole 3-4,4-3 BS... to think one of the best DEs in this mock could not play out of position is BS... If we HAVE to draft consistent 3-4,4-3 players or LOSE then we might as well just make that a rule...

 

[MilkSpiller22]

All most voted for Milk for once but just couldn't because of his offense. I feel he should have went with a FB instead of a 2nd RB and not a fan of his receivers. On defense I do like Milk's defense better of course lead by the stud Neon Deion. Even though WLK is saying Elvis is a bad 3-4 DE I still think overall Milk has a better D.

I don't need a FB, i have an elite OL and the fastest player in football running the ball... then i have a 6'3 RB for short distance and clock draining if needed...

Sometimes a change of pace back is more important than a FB, and you know me, i am one of the biggest FB fans..

 

[femurov]

thats funny... But i honestly think some of us a too strict on that whole 3-4,4-3 BS... to think one of the best DEs in this mock could not play out of position is BS... If we HAVE to draft consistent 3-4,4-3 players or LOSE then we might as well just make that a rule...

While this may be true of some people we discuss, you are crazy if you think Dumervil.would be great as a 34 DE. He is listed at 6 foot 250, but I have heard he is smaller than that. Whenever he has played in a 34, he has played OLB (and done very well). You would have been much better off dropping him or one of the other OLBs for someone with the body to play that end position.

 

[UK Cowboy]

Elvis as a 5tech and Peko miscast as a 3-4 NT were big mistakes IMO

WLK

 

[Pack 500]

I honestly missed Elvis at 5-tech. This would have changed my vote lol.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

While this may be true of some people we discuss, you are crazy if you think Dumervil.would be great as a 34 DE. He is listed at 6 foot 250, but I have heard he is smaller than that. Whenever he has played in a 34, he has played OLB (and done very well). You would have been much better off dropping him or one of the other OLBs for someone with the body to play that end position.

I do agree... my biggest mistake this draft was after going for the 2 cheap 3-4 OLBs early i didn't go heavy on the 3-4 DL... so i do agree that that my DL isn't as good as it should be... My whole point though is that it seems like we harp on miscasts too much... I have a hard time believing that strong players would just flat out be terrible at a similar but different role..

 

[CitySushi]

Wlk