- Thread starter
- #261
knowyourenemy
Well-Known Member
Anyone picking McNabb over Rodgers is doing something wrong...
Nobody did that.
Anyone picking McNabb over Rodgers is doing something wrong...
Nobody did that.
LOL. Mcnabb was cited as having a better playoff record than Rodgers
That’s because McNabb does, in fact, have a higher playoff winning percentage than Rodgers.
I know.. And Jim Plunkett has more Superbowl wins than Rodgers too..
With his pitiful performance in the NFC Championship Game yesterday, he fell to 10-8 all-time in the playoffs. That’s a lower playoff winning percentage than Donovan McNabb.
So, what say you?
If this has already been mentioned my bad. So Rodgers is 10-8 all time in the playoffs with one ring. You don't think he's a top 20 QB right?
Then is Brett Favre a top 20 all time QB with one ring & a 13-11 all time playoff record? What about Marino? He was 8-10 in the playoffs. Peyton Manning? He was 14-13.
It would be nice if Rodgers could at least make it to another one. Then maybe his fanboys would have another leg to stand on.
Manning and Favre both have 140+ more touchdowns and 25,000 more yards. Marino played in a different era but also has way more touchdowns and yards as of right now.
As much as Peyton was labeled a choker, he appeared in 4 Super Bowls and went 2-2. Favre went to 2. Rodgers has only gone to 1. For being as talented as everyone says, this guy has somehow only managed to put together one Super Bowl run. It’s baffling...
Your argument is very weak. I suggest you engage your brain before you comment anymore.Manning and Favre both have 140+ more touchdowns and 25,000 more yards. Marino played in a different era but also has way more touchdowns and yards as of right now.
As much as Peyton was labeled a choker, he appeared in 4 Super Bowls and went 2-2. Favre went to 2. Rodgers has only gone to 1. For being as talented as everyone says, this guy has somehow only managed to put together one Super Bowl run. It’s baffling...
Yeah, the poll really backfired on the OP.It's unanimous, Rodgers is a top 20 QB...
So you think Plunkett is a top 20 QB. Most folks here would disagree with you.
Not at all. Just pointing out how his "stats" are better than Rodgers and McNabb if you look at SB wins..
It's unanimous, Rodgers is a top 20 QB...
You need to look at the whole picture and not just the part you want to. Your comment is laughable.Not at all. Just pointing out how his "stats" are better than Rodgers and McNabb if you look at SB wins..