Where does your favorite player fall on the "20 Most Dominating" in the last 20 years?

[LambeauLegs]

There may be a bit of controversy here??

The Dominant 20


Peyton Manning has double the Dominance rating of Tom Brady

 

[Clayton]

Barry Bonds at only 17 is just ignorant unless they are penalizing him 13-14 spots because of cheating

 

[jarntt]

that's way too annoying to read. make me a list!!!

 

[Sharkonabicycle]

I like Usain Bolt because I'm a slow white person... so I envy the running speed. I can play a decent game of golf and pickup basketball so meh. Manning over Brady... eh.... I dunno, I feel Manning is too high on the list and football is difficult to quantify because of the surrounding team. Tennis and F1 racing are whatever.

 

[Sharkonabicycle]

And:

1) Tiger Woods (PGA)
2) Lebron James (NBA)
3) Peyton Manning (NFL)
4) Jimmie Johnson (NASCAR)
5) Roger Federer (Tennis)
6) Annika Sorenstam (LPGA)
7) Michael Schumacher (F1)
8) Floyd Mayweather (Boxing)
9) Marta (no idea either, female soccer)
10) Usain Bolt (Track/Field)
11) Lionel Messi (Soccer)
12) Serena Williams (Tennis)
13) Lauren Jackson (WNBA)
14) Christiano Renaldo (Soccer)
15) Novak Djokovic (Tennis)
16) Allyson Felix (Track/Field)
17) Barry Bonds (MLB)
18) Mike Trout (MLB)
19) Manny Pacquiao (Boxing)
20 Tom Brady (NFL)

 

[sonnyblack65]

And:

1) Tiger Woods (PGA)
2) Lebron James (NBA)
3) Peyton Manning (NFL)
4) Jimmie Johnson (NASCAR)
5) Roger Federer (Tennis)
6) Annika Sorenstam (LPGA)
7) Michael Schumacher (F1)
8) Floyd Mayweather (Boxing)
9) Marta (no idea either, female soccer)
10) Usain Bolt (Track/Field)
11) Lionel Messi (Soccer)
12) Serena Williams (Tennis)
13) Lauren Jackson (WNBA)
14) Christiano Renaldo (Soccer)
15) Novak Djokovic (Tennis)
16) Allyson Felix (Track/Field)
17) Barry Bonds (MLB)
18) Mike Trout (MLB)
19) Manny Pacquiao (Boxing)
20 Tom Brady (NFL)

I would have had #4, 6.13 and #16 higher

 

[LambeauLegs]

that's way too annoying to read. make me a list!!!

For this forum Peyton Manning #3 and Tom Brady #20

 

[Sharkonabicycle]

Erm, just so no confusion the list I posted above is off the site... but the site puts it in an annoying format you have to scroll and reveal through. So just put it here so it's easier to discuss.

 

[Sharkonabicycle]

that's way too annoying to read. make me a list!!!

I posted the full list.

 

[jarntt]

For this forum Peyton Manning #3 and Tom Brady #20

Seems about right

 

[Inquisitor95]

And:

1) Tiger Woods (PGA)
2) Lebron James (NBA)
3) Peyton Manning (NFL)
4) Jimmie Johnson (NASCAR)
5) Roger Federer (Tennis)
6) Annika Sorenstam (LPGA)
7) Michael Schumacher (F1)
8) Floyd Mayweather (Boxing)
9) Marta (no idea either, female soccer)
10) Usain Bolt (Track/Field)
11) Lionel Messi (Soccer)
12) Serena Williams (Tennis)
13) Lauren Jackson (WNBA)
14) Christiano Renaldo (Soccer)
15) Novak Djokovic (Tennis)
16) Allyson Felix (Track/Field)
17) Barry Bonds (MLB)
18) Mike Trout (MLB)
19) Manny Pacquiao (Boxing)
20 Tom Brady (NFL)

No Michael Jordan?



Edit: The last 20 years. Should be more than that.

 

[LetsGoPats]

For this forum Peyton Manning #3 and Tom Brady #20

Maybe this will bring Peyton fans some joy. But the Peyton/Brady debate ended in 2007 and, frankly, at this point it's not even close.

 

[chf]

I can see putting Ferrari or McLaren or whomever on the list... but a driver? Meh.

 

[Dude]

Your favorite players, ... that's very old-fashioned. I had a great collection of MLB cards in the 60-70s. Sold it for a tidy profit. Meh, it was probably like $500 bucks in the early 70s. That was a lot of cash. Today it is Fantasy pocket change for many people who know very little about American football.

 

[Dude]

.

 

[Shanemansj13]

I agree with #1 and 2, that’s about it lol

 

[Ricky Roma]

No Michael Phelps? I'd think the most decorated Olympian would get on there. Nice to see Michael Schumacher there.....along with Ayrton Senna, the two best drivers I've ever seen.

 

[broncosmitty]

Shaq, Shaun White, Kobe, Michael Phelps, Tim Duncan....


Mike Trout has no buissness being on the list.

 

[broncosmitty]

Kobayashi

 

[NinerSickness]

And:

1) Tiger Woods (PGA)
2) Lebron James (NBA)
3) Peyton Manning (NFL)
4) Jimmie Johnson (NASCAR)
5) Roger Federer (Tennis)
6) Annika Sorenstam (LPGA)
7) Michael Schumacher (F1)
8) Floyd Mayweather (Boxing)
9) Marta (no idea either, female soccer)
10) Usain Bolt (Track/Field)
11) Lionel Messi (Soccer)
12) Serena Williams (Tennis)
13) Lauren Jackson (WNBA)
14) Christiano Renaldo (Soccer)
15) Novak Djokovic (Tennis)
16) Allyson Felix (Track/Field)
17) Barry Bonds (MLB)
18) Mike Trout (MLB)
19) Manny Pacquiao (Boxing)
20 Tom Brady (NFL)

Roger Federer is more dominant than those top 4 people ahead of him.