Would you do this hypothetical trade?

[jeffro151]

Team A receives: Demaryius Thomas, Ameer Abdullah
Team B receives: TY Hilton

Team A: 1-4 record, averaging 83.14 ppg
Team B: 2-3 record, averaging 92.26 ppg

Team A roster:
Newton
Lamar Miller, Tevin Coleman, McCaffrey, Jonathan Stewart
Hilton, Hogan, Landry, Ginn, Lockett
Watson
(Lost OBJ, Edelman, & Greg Olsen to injury)

Team B roster:
Rodgers
Freeman, Kamara, Abdullah, Collins, Smallwood, McGuire
D. Thomas, Fitzgerald, Theilan, Pryor
Kelce, Njoku
(Lost Woodhead to injury)

 

[tlance]

If I am team B I would.

 

[TKOSpikes]

Prefer Hilton.

 

[femurov]

Call me a homer, but I have DT and TY just about even, especially since there is still no timetable on Luck coming back. Throw in a starting RB, albeit inconsistent but still, a starting RB, and I take team A, easily.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

I can see this trade working for both teams. Would rather be team B though.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Call me a homer, but I have DT and TY just about even, especially since there is still no timetable on Luck coming back. Throw in a starting RB, albeit inconsistent but still, a starting RB, and I take team A, easily.

Even without Luck, Hilton has been more productive by a fair margin this season then DT.

 

[femurov]

Even without Luck, Hilton has been more productive by a fair margin this season then DT.

Hence the homer disclaimer... I think DT's best games are ahead of him.

 

[TREFF]

Hence the homer disclaimer... I think DT's best games are ahead of him.

 

[TREFF]

I'd rather be team B in this deal...and that's with my former Husker Abdullah homer love factored in

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I really think DThomas is the better receiver... i think he is a top 5 receiver in football... problem is that his offense is not a high powered offense... they are too conservative, Siemen rarely gets 300 yards passing, very hard to expect Thomas to get to 100...

Colts, without Luck suck enough that they are always playing behind, and garbage time is great for the big play guy like Hilton... and then once Luck comes back then they are back to being a passing team....

 

[wildturkey]

If I'm Team B, hell yeah!

If I'm Team A, fuck it why not. You're pretty much done for anyway

 

[SteelersPride]

i think it is a deal helping both squads potentially

 

[SteelersPride]

however i value DT and hilton about the same esp in ppr, sooooo

 

[jeffro151]

I was team B in the trade, team A turned it down. I thought the trade worked well for both squads. I would have improved my WR talent wise, while team A would have gained some much needed depth. Oh well, I'll just let him keep on sucking.

 

[Trudem]

I could see both teams benefiting from this deal. However getting a starting RB back is huge. I think Abdullah is starting to find his groove in the offense and will get touches as long as they arent behind by alot.