Whos the better QB- blind resume

[rmilia1]

QB1 vs QB2

Pass Yards- QB2 has 500 more pass yards than QB1

Rush yards- QB1 has 400 more rush yards than QB2

Toichdowns- QB1 has 6 more total TDs than QB2

Turnovers- QB2 has 11 less turnovers than QB1

Comp %- QB2 completes 4% more of his passes than QB1

QB rating- QB2 has a 3 pt higher QB rating than QB1

QBR- QB2 has a 1 pt higher QBR than QB1


Who ya got??

 

[Shane_O_Mac812]

I will always take Patrick Mahomes over Jalen Hurts anyday.

 

[Stakesarehigh]

2

 

[Fountain City Blues]

I will always take Patrick Mahomes over Jalen Hurts anyday.

Eyeballing it I am guessing one QB is Trevor Lawrence, without cheating.

 

[Clayton]

Whats their W/L record? I feel like I need that if we're talking turnovers and TDs as the difference

Some turnovers are way, way worse than others

 

[PDay8810]

all the above is the safe answer

(3) All the Above

 

[eaglesnut]

QB1 vs QB2

Pass Yards- QB2 has 500 more pass yards than QB1

Rush yards- QB1 has 400 more rush yards than QB2

Toichdowns- QB1 has 6 more total TDs than QB2

Turnovers- QB2 has 11 less turnovers than QB1

Comp %- QB2 completes 4% more of his passes than QB1

QB rating- QB2 has a 3 pt higher QB rating than QB1

QBR- QB2 has a 1 pt higher QBR than QB1


Who ya got??

11 less turnovers is a fucking lot. It equals about 3-4 wins.

The rest you can give or take. Really about the same, the passing yards are more important than the rushing yards from the QB. 4% is pretty significant. The 6 tds somewhat so.

 

[rmilia1]

Eyeballing it I am guessing one QB is Trevor Lawrence, without cheating.

Nope

 

[rmilia1]

I will always take Patrick Mahomes over Jalen Hurts anyday.

Lol nope

 

[rmilia1]

Whats their W/L record? I feel like I need that if we're talking turnovers and TDs as the difference

Some turnovers are way, way worse than others

If i give you that you'll know who they are though lol

QB2 has a higher win% this year and career

 

[eaglesnut]

I'm going to go QB2

The high completion percentage will lead to first downs and FGs for his own team while the turnovers will lead to FGs and Touchdowns going the other way for QB1. Makes up for the 6 TDs.

 

[Anointed One]

I"m going with QB 2... Less Turnovers with a higher completion %... 11 less TO's trump the 6 more TD's for QB 1...

 

[jarntt]

Is this for this year? So a partial season? if so are you sure the 11 more turnovers is accurate?

 

[Wazmankg]

The only stat that gives me pause is the TDs. Everything else points to QB2.

Are these stats for this year and have both started every game? Because I'm not even seeing any possibilities wrt the turnover difference of 11. No QB has > 13 picks or 3 lost fumbles and they are not the same guy.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

This smells like a Davis Mills thread

 

[rmilia1]

Is this for this year? So a partial season? if so are you sure the 11 more turnovers is accurate?

Yes and yes

 

[rmilia1]

The only stat that gives me pause is the TDs. Everything else points to QB2.

Are these stats for this year and have both started every game? Because I'm not even seeing any possibilities wrt the turnover difference of 11. No QB has > 13 picks or 3 lost fumbles and they are not the same guy.

Yes it's accurate

 

[rmilia1]

Ok im an idiot lol

Its 4 MORE turnovers not 11

11 is the total for QB1

Sorry yall

Feel free to change your vote

 

[Wazmankg]

Yes it's accurate

Are you sure the fumbles you counted for the TO stat were strictly fumbles lost?

 

[PnkPanther]