Which side you want

[HaroldSeattle]

Appreciate the discussion from everyone, I haven't made any formal offers yet and by the looks of it, some say the 2nd has more value others the rookie + 3rd, so at least I feel like I have the right pieces in play for a fair trade

You trading for Smith or are you trading away Smith?

 

[SmokingMonkey]

You trading for Smith or are you trading away Smith?

I would be trading my future 2nd for Smith + future 3rd

 

[TREFF]

Appreciate the discussion from everyone, I haven't made any formal offers yet and by the looks of it, some say the 2nd has more value others the rookie + 3rd, so at least I feel like I have the right pieces in play for a fair trade

By all accounts, given the back and forth, or seems like a fair deal either way.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

made me think he wanted the future 2nd, then he went ahead and made the pick instead, lol

guess we'll see what the next guy is looking like

 

[averagejoe]

Appreciate the discussion from everyone

Either we have fantasy bordem? Or we have fantasy withdrawls to get 2 full pages out of your question.
Although Treff will say it was the poll.

 

[TREFF]

Either we have fantasy bordem? Or we have fantasy withdrawls to get 2 full pages out of your question.
Although Treff will say it was the poll.

F'n polls

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Well, this isn't going as planned, 4 owners in a row declined the future 2nd for two 3rds offer, and 4 owners in a row did not draft Brashard Smith, then the next guy took Dillon Gabriel

Guess no one else in this league is on the Smith + 3rd or future 2nd side of this deal

 

[TREFF]

Well, this isn't going as planned, 4 owners in a row declined the future 2nd for two 3rds offer, and 4 owners in a row did not draft Brashard Smith, then the next guy took Dillon Gabriel

Guess no one else in this league is on the Smith + 3rd or future 2nd side of this deal

Sounds like you might be good just to wait for him to fall to you

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Sounds like you might be good just to wait for him to fall to you

That only works when you don't trade all your picks away every season

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Well, this isn't going as planned, 4 owners in a row declined the future 2nd for two 3rds offer, and 4 owners in a row did not draft Brashard Smith, then the next guy took Dillon Gabriel

Guess no one else in this league is on the Smith + 3rd or future 2nd side of this deal

His ADP is 4.09 in rookie drafts so maybe you can trade for a 4th, spend less, and still land him.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

His ADP is 4.09 in rookie drafts so maybe you can trade for a 4th, spend less, and still land him.

That's pick 45 overall, pretty much where we're at in the draft now

 

[MilkSpiller22]

As the loudest pro smith guy here in this trade. I was assuming you owned smith. I do like the smith side better.

But if you own the second round pick here that pick is going to remain its value throughout the season if not get even more valuable. When you trade it now you are betting on yourself. Which is nice but also unnecessary.

I think keeping the second is a better for you.

I’m about to surprise all here. This is one of those if I owned either side I would not be making this trade on either side. Even though I like the smith side better.

 

[TREFF]

Well, this isn't going as planned, 4 owners in a row declined the future 2nd for two 3rds offer, and 4 owners in a row did not draft Brashard Smith, then the next guy took Dillon Gabriel

Guess no one else in this league is on the Smith + 3rd or future 2nd side of this deal

Id rather have B. Smith, or the future #2 than Gabriel.. even in a 32 team league.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Ended up sending a future 3rd for pick 4.01 (pick 49 overall) to draft Smith

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Ended up sending a future 3rd for pick 4.01 (pick 49 overall) to draft Smith

Well all those rejections worked out in your favor, nice.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Ended up sending a future 3rd for pick 4.01 (pick 49 overall) to draft Smith

Yup that seems like a win. You gave up nothing. And you got a potential future flex player.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Ended up sending a future 3rd for pick 4.01 (pick 49 overall) to draft Smith

this in fact is almost a BAD trade from the other side.... where did the other team pick Smith??

and are you giving up your third rounder( one that you predict to be a late rounder) or someone elses??

 

[SmokingMonkey]

this in fact is almost a BAD trade from the other side.... where did the other team pick Smith??

I was acquiring a pick to use on Smith in a current on-going 4-round dynasty draft

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I was acquiring a pick to use on Smith in a current on-going 4-round dynasty draft

oh.. i read it wrong... LOL...

then not a bad trade on their part... they actually got a third rounder for a 4th rounder...

still like it from your end... but i do admit, i misread the deal, so i dont like it AS MUCH....

 

[SmokingMonkey]

oh.. i read it wrong... LOL...

then not a bad trade on their part... they actually got a third rounder for a 4th rounder...

still like it from your end... but i do admit, i misread the deal, so i dont like it AS MUCH....

Late 3rd to 4.1.... moving back 5-6 spots to gain Smith after 40+ picks off the board, very low risk add on my end