Update On Bleacher Report's QB Rankings

[redskinsfan]

I dont. If he did he would have kept him there.

You should've listened to Grant and Danny interview him initially on those rankings. He was defending them as being legit. Instead of being a man and admitting he screwed up (to the tune of upgrading Cuz from 25/40 on accuracy to 35/40, which represents a 25% increase in the most important category in Miller's ranking), he bashed his staff for the error.

 

[SoCalWizFan]

You guys are all so damn sensitive lol. You're pissed he's behind Romo, Cutler, and Bridgewater? When Romo's healthy he is better and the other 2 are very debatable. Its not like he's comparing him to freaking Matt Cassel. I think some of you dont realize how many different views there are on Cousins (and other QBs) from a lot of respected football people.

I am not really upset about these ratings since these type of evaluations from this type of site are laughable. However - I can totally understand Romo being placed above Cousins (for now - when healthy) & possibly even Cutler. But - Bridgewater? Seriously? I totally do not understand the fascination with this guy. He is a mediocre QB at best.

Look at his numbers - nothing really stands out. He also has major advantages that are not available to Cousins - not yet. He has arguably the best RB in the game & a very good line. He also gets to play with one of the better defenses in the NFL. I believe that this guy is highly overrated.

 

[ehb5]

I am not really upset about these ratings since these type of evaluations from this type of site are laughable. However - I can totally understand Romo being placed above Cousins (for now - when healthy) & possibly even Cutler. But - Bridgewater? Seriously? I totally do not understand the fascination with this guy. He is a mediocre QB at best.

Look at his numbers - nothing really stands out. He also has major advantages that are not available to Cousins - not yet. He has arguably the best RB in the game & a very good line. He also gets to play with one of the better defenses in the NFL. I believe that this guy is highly overrated.

Yea I kinda think Bridgewater is overrated too although to be fair I don't think he has much to throw to. But at least he's highly regarded by people around the league so it's not like kirk is being thrown in the trash here.

 

[gkekoa]

Who was better in 2015? Romo or KC?

That is where the problem is. There is no comparison for this single year.

 

[redskinsfan]

Who was better in 2015? Romo or KC?

That is where the problem is. There is no comparison for this single year.

No question: KC. KC was also better than Luck, though I'd take Luck right now over KC if there was a straight up trade for both.

 

[SoCalWizFan]

Yea I kinda think Bridgewater is overrated too although to be fair I don't think he has much to throw to. But at least he's highly regarded by people around the league so it's not like kirk is being thrown in the trash here.

Perhaps, but I am not just talking about stats. Every time I see this guy play I come away unimpressed. I just don't get the hype for this guy. He appears to be a game manager at best. Cousins upside is way, way more than for this guy.

 

[SoCalWizFan]

No question: KC. KC was also better than Luck, though I'd take Luck right now over KC if there was a straight up trade for both.

At least Luck according to most has a very bright future. The problem with Romo is that you can't exactly count on the guy & you don't know how many years he has left. I am not stating that Cousins is better than Romo - just saying that you have to factor in these type of things. If you simply went on past performance you would have to highly rate someone like Peyton Manning which would be a joke.

 

[redskinsfan]

At least Luck according to most has a very bright future. The problem with Romo is that you can't exactly count on the guy & you don't know how many years he has left. I am not stating that Cousins is better than Romo - just saying that you have to factor in these type of things. If you simply went on past performance you would have to highly rate someone like Peyton Manning which would be a joke.

But Cuz had a better 2015 than Luck. That was the point of Miller's bogus rankings. Cuz also had a better year than people like Bridgewater and Cutler.

 

[SoCalWizFan]

But Cuz had a better 2015 than Luck. That was the point of Miller's bogus rankings. Cuz also had a better year than people like Bridgewater and Cutler.

No - I am agreeing with you. Just stating - like some others - that you have to factor in things like 2015 performance, age & existing injuries if you are talking about the projections of these guys moving into 2016 (and not just ranking them on past performance). Oh well as previously mentioned who cares? Cousins could be ranked dead last as long as plays well moving forward.

 

[ehb5]

Perhaps, but I am not just talking about stats. Every time I see this guy play I come away unimpressed. I just don't get the hype for this guy. He appears to be a game manager at best. Cousins upside is way, way more than for this guy.

I agree. Again I don't think he's being asked to do much or given the opportunity but I'm not really convinced he can do it anyways. Never seems very accurate to me either especially downfield.