TY HILTON or GARCON Full keeper?

[The Foot]

TY Hilton

or

Pierre Garcon

Who would u rather have?

 

[Clayton]

One has Andrew Luck and the other probably has Kirk Cousins. Hmmm

 

[SteelersPride]

hilton has more upside........but theres rumors nicks may beat him out for the wr2 spot...........and when he had a chance to shine with wayne out he didnt...........

im taking pierre

 

[TKOSpikes]

Flip a coin. It's a deal where I'd reject no matter what side I had. I think we can all agree that TYH is boom or bust and Garcon is more consistent with more targets per game... what side suits you better?

 

[TREFF]

I'm taking Hilton.. Once Wayne is gone, he'll be great. Garçon just is what he is, which is fine, but he'll only get older. . No real potential for better.

 

[averagejoe]

Before Reggie Wayne went down last year, he was about 100 yards ahead of Hilton. I think many FF owners undervalue Wayne - the guy can still catch.

As for Garcon, DJax could cut into his touches, but I think Garcon is undervalued as well.

i.e. Garcon

 

[SteelersPride]

I'm taking Hilton.. Once Wayne is gone, he'll be great. Garçon just is what he is, which is fine, but he'll only get older. . No real potential for better.

wayne was gone last year, and he became the focal point and flamed out

 

[Trudem]

I think the addition of DJax means garçon rarely sees double teams. I think his targets may go down but his production of yards and TDs increases.

 

[TREFF]

wayne was gone last year, and he became the focal point and flamed out

Wayne wasnt a stud without Harrison right away either (800+ and 7)
And I don't think I'd call 1000+ and 5, in his second year, flaming out. Be nice to see more TD's, but he's actually off to a better start to his career than Wayne was

 

[Jack_John_Mark]

One has Andrew Luck and the other probably has Kirk Cousins. Hmmm

Tell me you're not basing this off of preseason football where backup QBs play against 3rd string Defenses....

 

[wilwhite]

They're very, very close - except that Hilton is younger and Garcon gets hurt a lot. So that makes it easy.

(No way Cousins starts if RGIII stays healthy. On the other hand, can RGIII stay healthy?)

 

[SoShady]

Garcon by a mile for me.

 

[SteelersPride]

to me i dont like hiltons route tree, thats just me

 

[Xponentialchaos]

Hilton by a very slight margin.

 

[The Foot]

I took Garcon guys. Since I have RG3 and cussins I will have the hook up. Please he threw in Davis the OLB from CAR!

 

[The Foot]

As usual thanks for all the help guys, you are the best!

 

[jarntt]

wayne was gone last year, and he became the focal point and flamed out

Flamed out? He was a young kid that at the end of the year (Including 2 playoff games) averaged 10 catches and 160 yards over his last 3 games. I'm not sure I get that comment. Now, I'm not a keeper guy and don't know the specific rules of his league, so I'm not sure the answer to the question. In a regular league I draft Garcon first personally because of hte consistency, but wouldn't criticze someone at all for going Hilton. If you go out a year or two I think Hilton is the better fantasy player and really could be this year too.

 

[The Foot]

You have to remember too that not only does Indy have Wayne back and the NEW AND IMPROVED Nicks, but both Tight ends are healthy. That leaves a lot of BIG targets to take from Hilton thats why I did the trade. But you could be right in two to three years TY could be worth more.

 

[TREFF]

You have to remember too that not only does Indy have Wayne back and the NEW AND IMPROVED Nicks, but both Tight ends are healthy. That leaves a lot of BIG targets to take from Hilton thats why I did the trade. But you could be right in two to three years TY could be worth more.

Not that I disagree with the overall theory, but please do tell how Nicks is "NEW AND IMPROVED". Did he spend the off season at OSI, who had the technology and capability to make him better. .. stronger. .. faster?

 

[Chef99]

Not that I disagree with the overall theory, but please do tell how Nicks is "NEW AND IMPROVED". Did he spend the off season at OSI, who had the technology and capability to make him better. .. stronger. .. faster?

I read a comment on Yahoo that Nicks has slowed a bit due to his past leg injuries. Who really knows with guys like him until the season get under way?