Trade Offer

[Nosferatu]

So who do I drop?
Victor Cruz, Roddy White, Vincent Jackson, Michael Crabtree?

Which back should I pick up?
Ben Tate or Ryan Mathews?

 

[TKOSpikes]

I would surely try Foster and any WR not named Dez first, but I'd accept if that was declined. You can find depth RB in trade for one or two of your WR.

 

[TKOSpikes]

I'd try and trade two of those before dropping. Maybe a bye week hurting WR owner will take Crabby and Cruz for something.

 

[jarntt]

Love Bernard, but not even a question. The only thing you should make sure is that you don't answer so quickly that you make him rethink the offer. You still have 3 solid RBs and are getting a 1A WR for your team.

 

[Jim Rome is Flaming]

My RB's are
Arian Foster
Giovanni Bernard
DeMarco Murray
Matt Forte

My WR's are
Dez Bryant
Michael Crabtree
Vincent Jackson
Victor Cruz
Roddy White

I have been offered Demaryius Thomas for Giovani Bernard.

Question is do I need Thomas enough to weaken a pretty solid core of backs?

This has to be a 6 team league.

 

[Nosferatu]

This has to be a 6 team league.

8

Usually 10 but we lost 2 people this year late and didn't have time to replace them.

 

[Barilko]

I would offer Foster and Vj or Roddy and take back a respectable Rb with Demaryius. And as posted above no rush make em sweat a little you may get more

 

[Nosferatu]

I would offer Foster and Vj or Roddy and take back a respectable Rb with Demaryius. And as posted above no rush make em sweat a little you may get more

He doesnt have a respectable RB
Reggie Bush
Doug Martin
Matt Asiata
Knile Davis

 

[MilkSpiller22]

whose your QB?? do you start a TE??

 

[Nosferatu]

We do not start a TE, we use TE as a WR and my QB's are Matt Ryan and Tony Romo we have to carry two.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

We do not start a TE, we use TE as a WR and my QB's are Matt Ryan and Tony Romo we have to carry two.

Who does he have??

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Again, i think he is panicking about Thomas, i think you can get more!!! even if you have to give more!!!

 

[TKOSpikes]

What is he panicking about? He needs a RB, he's offering a WR. Both, back of the 1st rounders. What more do you think he'll give up?

 

[MilkSpiller22]

What is he panicking about? He needs a RB, he's offering a WR. Both, back of the 1st rounders. What more do you think he'll give up?

I just find it interesting that he is asking his bye player for another bye player... Either he doesnt realize that a stud WR can get him someone to play this week, or he is really high on Benard...

Not to mention D thomas hsa just not been that good so far this season, adn he has been banged up... And with emanuel sanders and Julius Thomas taking all the Yards adn TDs Thomas might just not be a number one WR, while Benard has shown what he is(even if you want to fear the Hill)...

and for nos, he is in no rush for this trade since if the other owner want Gio, then he can always wait until next week to make this trade...

 

[tlance]

I would definitely counter before accepting... Especially since the trade as is doesn't need to be decided upon until next week... That's why this trade makes no sense to me... why would he offer a bye player for a bye player now?? Makes me think he is panicking about Thomas... you can probably get more from him!!!

There are a lot of reasons to offer a bye player for a bye player. He clearly is not thinking about week 4 in this deal. This is about the long term.

Again, it does not matter if the guy's logic makes sense to you.

I would make this deal, but only if there is a decent RB available on waivers, or perhaps via another trade. Say Cruz for another solid RB.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

There are a lot of reasons to offer a bye player for a bye player. He clearly is not thinking about week 4 in this deal. This is about the long term.

Again, it does not matter if the guy's logic makes sense to you.

I would make this deal, but only if there is a decent RB available on waivers, or perhaps via another trade. Say Cruz for another solid RB.

I am just saying that he has time to counter to see if the other owner is willing to pay more... That is all... Not telling him not to make the trade at all... Sometimes reading into someone elses intentions will get you a better deal, sometimes you get screwed... I am just giving my advice, it is up to Nos to do so... And lets face it, we will not influence his decisions anyway...

 

[HizzleRocker]

With Forte and Murray - I can't see why you would even play Bernard? You are getting a #1 WR for a bench RB. Take it.

I would make him throw in so done like Reggie bush for depth - but I would take it.

 

[Nosferatu]

He has Manning as his QB

 

[Nosferatu]

Ryan Mathews and Ben Tate are available on waivers.


I still don't know what WR I would drop if I accept the deal.
Cruz, VJackson, Roddy, Crabtree

 

[MilkSpiller22]

He has Manning as his QB

would he do a trade like this:

Benard, Forte any WR not name Dez and Matt Ryan

Manning, Thomas and any 2 RB from his team