When assessing the ability of an athlete to be accepted to the university (any university) the question should be asked, does a 5ft 7in fat kid with the same grades and colleges test scores from the same high school get accepted.
No scholarship, just accepted. If the answer is no, then neither should the athlete be accepted. Acceptance into the university may be the fat kid's only chance in life. If that is the criteria for the athlete then the same should hold true for all.