So what do you think of this trade?

[Sam Sportboy]

So I'll start by saying I just made a trade in this league. I traded Justice Hill, Kenny Stills and a 4th round pick fer Jimmy G, Mike Evans and a 16th rounder. IMO, with the pick this is an even trade. Now, I would say that it might be a bit early to be trading players fer picks, but as the season goes on the value goes down. So IMO, Tatonka: Good Trade. So now we just had another trade in this league and I won't tell you whether I like it or not. I just want yer opinion on it. Goff and RFreeman fer JHill and Michel. Thoughts?

 

[Sam Sportboy]

@TREFF @TKOSpikes @tlance @averagejoe @HaroldSeattle @Barilko @leftypower @Bandit @yellowfuzzies @TheFoot @SteelersPride

 

[SteelersPride]

ppr? i assume this is dynasty?

 

[Sam Sportboy]

ppr? i assume this is dynasty?

No PPR, and not a dynasty. We keep 2 and they count fer our first 2 picks.

 

[averagejoe]

traded Justice Hill, Kenny Stills and a 4th round pick fer Jimmy G, Mike Evans and a 16th rounder. IMO, with the pick this is an even trade.

Even. I agree. But you still win IMO.

we just had another trade in this league and I won't tell you whether I like it or not. I just want yer opinion on it. Goff and RFreeman fer JHill and Michel. Thoughts?

Seems even to me. Goff is underperforming. So is Michel, and Hill may have a better future to some, but not sure I like playing the waiting game on a player's potential. Half the season could be lost waiting.

 

[SteelersPride]

No PPR, and not a dynasty. We keep 2 and they count fer our first 2 picks.

well just my personal opinon but unless this is a 16 team league. justice hill and kenny stills shouldnt be on rosters. So they hold no value to me.

It would obviously depend on one teams QB situation........if they just lost someone, or heck had cam........

Freeman still is in a timeshare, and goff is a fringe QB.......but freeman has upside, appears poised to take a larger role, and has weekly flex appeal.

Michel has big upside with that pats Offense and him being the goal line, rushing back......lot of blowouts too....

i can argue for both sides. so to me im ok with it.....

 

[femurov]

I think the Evans side won the first trade.

Not sure how I feel about the 2nd one. I agree with SP that the QB situation matters in that one. To me, it just looks like a bunch of ?s changing hands.

 

[Sam Sportboy]

So the team that traded fer Goff has Winston at QB now. He (obviously) is the guy that traded Evans to me. He likes having the QB/WR hook up and he does have Kupp. I think it's even but there are a few owners that are grumbling. Pretty sure the Michel end could have gotten a pick, but he's a Ram fan so there is that. Thanks guise, I figured you would all see it as pretty even depending on rosters. @SteelersPride
We are a 12 teamer with 19 man rosters..............all teams have a shit load of dart throws. I originally had Stills. Something happens to Fuller I'd expect Stills to do just fine in that role.

 

[SteelersPride]

So the team that traded fer Goff has Winston at QB now. He (obviously) is the guy that traded Evans to me. He likes having the QB/WR hook up and he does have Kupp. I think it's even but there are a few owners that are grumbling. Pretty sure the Michel end could have gotten a pick, but he's a Ram fan so there is that. Thanks guise, I figured you would all see it as pretty even depending on rosters. @SteelersPride
We are a 12 teamer with 19 man rosters..............all teams have a shit load of dart throws. I originally had Stills. Something happens to Fuller I'd expect Stills to do just fine in that role.

well shit yeah if its that large i get it, totally get it. makes sense.........

still......i consider the trade fair.........if theres grumblings over that. I think i would personally like the michel end But if your a team struggling. I cant say i wouldnt take that shot, high powered offense for the rams, and a RB taking on more work. Michel has his downside too in the hoodie with RB's........heck he did crap week 1.

 

[TREFF]

Having a hard time following %100, but I think I got it.

Like others mentioned, without it being dynasty, I don't hold Justice Hill in high regard, probably needs two injuries to get any kind of real weekly value. As far as Michel, meh...somewhat slow start, Rexy getting more carries than I think anyone expected, and how long before his knees act up?

I don't see any problem, personal preferences win that deal in my eyes

 

[Barilko]

So the team that traded fer Goff has Winston at QB now. He (obviously) is the guy that traded Evans to me. He likes having the QB/WR hook up and he does have Kupp. I think it's even but there are a few owners that are grumbling. Pretty sure the Michel end could have gotten a pick, but he's a Ram fan so there is that. Thanks guise, I figured you would all see it as pretty even depending on rosters. @SteelersPride
We are a 12 teamer with 19 man rosters..............all teams have a shit load of dart throws. I originally had Stills. Something happens to Fuller I'd expect Stills to do just fine in that role.

trades look good to me

and i think that Stills may make it but in the slot at Coutee's expense

lets see what dictator Obrien has in mind

my 1st instinct when the acquired Stills was that he would go outside if Fuller went down(again) and im certain he will go there if that crap happens to Fuller again..

but i do believe if they all stay healthy then he may steal the slot receiver spot from Keke

and that is a big Fn Obrien "May"

 

[leftypower]

Having a hard time following %100, but I think I got it.
Like others mentioned, without it being dynasty, I don't hold Justice Hill in high regard, probably needs two injuries to get any kind of real weekly value. As far as Michel, meh...somewhat slow start, Rexy getting more carries than I think anyone expected, and how long before his knees act up?
I don't see any problem, personal preferences win that deal in my eyes

I approve this message. ....