- Thread starter
- #1
I remember how many Bronco fans were hoping we'd land him in FA a few years back too. Talk about dodging a bullet. a $100 million bullet.
The guy had HOF type skills ...
LOL Yep, guilty as charged here! Then again, not only did I favor getting Haynesworth, but I was also elated by the acquisitions of players like Travis Henry and Javon Walker! Also guilty of having been a big fan of Cutler, Marshall, and others who could play, but who also brought unwanted baggage to the field.
As a fan, I am certainly aware of the tension between wanting the team to win and possibly having to hold my nose while rooting for that to happen. I obviously don't have to write the checks to pay players, but I certainly understand the incentives faced by those who do to sometimes error (ex post) in their assessment of the risk v. reward associated with signing certain players. Much easier to make mistakes than to avoid them when trying to achieve more than mediocrity.
I would love for some people to show the actual success Shanahan has had with QBs and how he turned their careers around, or how certain QBs never did better with out him.
Starts with Steve Young. Young has often credited Shanahan for the success he became with the 49ers. Elway, obviously. Brian Griese made a pro bowl with Shanahan. Plummer's career became respectable, and his numbers turned completely around. He also made a pro bowl. Cutler never had better numbers away from Shanahan and he also made a pro bowl. RGIII won ROY under Shanahan.
The issue with McNabb. Everything I am gathering from Mcnabb is he is very disillusioned.
Here is a clue folks. When a divisional rival is willing to trade you a QB.......BUYER BEWARE. Now, Shanahan's personnel moves have not always been great. He is an ego maniac. I am sure he was cocky enough to ignore the fact that a divisional rival was trading them a "starting QB."
Well, IF Mcnabb was really decent, no way AND I MEAN NO WAY do the EAGLES trade him to the Redskins. It is beyond obvious that they knew they giving them a sack of crap.
Anyone remember when the Pats traded Bledsoe to the Bills. Remember, when a divisional rival trades you ANYTHING.......BUYER BEWARE.
Haynesworth is not even worth me typing his name. I just did it. He has no credibility what so ever.
Not sure I'd lump the Bledsoe deal with the McNabb deal. McNabb was completely finished, while Bledsoe was still a capable QB.
In fact he posted 4300 yards, and 24 TD's his first season as a Buffalo Bill. Pro Bowl season. I think the big knock on Bledsoe is he seems to lack the ability to handle adversity, and had some accuracy issues (especially compared to Brady). However, he still had tred on the tires when he was sent to Buffalo, unlike McNabb. NE definitely knew it was keeping the better QB though, and the salary relief they got also helped NE out. However, NE had to take less compensation than they wanted, and Bledsoe put people in the seats in Buffalo.
They had $103 MM reasons to get rid of him. Better to trade that to Buffalo and hamstring their salary cap a bit then keeping him as a backup. And if I remember right, Buffalo was one game out of a first place tie.He may have had a good season there, but the Pats considered him over the hill. If they truly thought he was dynamic enough that he would be a serious threat to them in their own division, they would not have traded him to the Bills. That year (2002) I believe the Bills finished last. That was his real last decent season, but that really is not the point.
If any team trades a player to another team within the same division, it is more likely that it is type of "trojan horse." I mean, why on earth would they trade a player that they truly believed would make that team better. It is totally illogical.
I would love for some people to show the actual success Shanahan has had with QBs and how he turned their careers around, or how certain QBs never did better with out him.
Starts with Steve Young. Young has often credited Shanahan for the success he became with the 49ers. Elway, obviously. Brian Griese made a pro bowl with Shanahan. Plummer's career became respectable, and his numbers turned completely around. He also made a pro bowl. Cutler never had better numbers away from Shanahan and he also made a pro bowl. RGIII won ROY under Shanahan.
The issue with McNabb. Everything I am gathering from Mcnabb is he is very disillusioned.
Here is a clue folks. When a divisional rival is willing to trade you a QB.......BUYER BEWARE. Now, Shanahan's personnel moves have not always been great. He is an ego maniac. I am sure he was cocky enough to ignore the fact that a divisional rival was trading them a "starting QB."
Well, IF Mcnabb was really decent, no way AND I MEAN NO WAY do the EAGLES trade him to the Redskins. It is beyond obvious that they knew they giving them a sack of crap.
Anyone remember when the Pats traded Bledsoe to the Bills. Remember, when a divisional rival trades you ANYTHING.......BUYER BEWARE.
Haynesworth is not even worth me typing his name. I just did it. He has no credibility what so ever.
So many Shanahan apologists here. RatFace is the most overrated coach in HISTORY. He would be nothing if it wasn't for Elway. And You're wrong when you say Cutler played his best under Shanahan. He never had a passer rating higher than the 80s under Shanahan, even in his pro bowl season. This season Cutler has a 91.7 rating under Marc Trestman. It's too bad he suffered the groin injury (hopefully he'll only miss the Green Bay game), but there's no question he was playing the best football of his career before the injury. God Bless...
So many Shanahan apologists here. RatFace is the most overrated coach in HISTORY. He would be nothing if it wasn't for Elway. And You're wrong when you say Cutler played his best under Shanahan. He never had a passer rating higher than the 80s under Shanahan, even in his pro bowl season. This season Cutler has a 91.7 rating under Marc Trestman. It's too bad he suffered the groin injury (hopefully he'll only miss the Green Bay game), but there's no question he was playing the best football of his career before the injury. God Bless...