Rodgers Camel Toe

[megalodon30]

OK, Trent Dilfer WON a Super Bowl. It doesn't mean squat in the grand scheme of things.


But lets play your game.

Where do you rank Bradshaw and Aikman all time?

Jimmy G is 18 games above .500. Dilfer finished 3 wins above .500. It makes him better than say Eli Manning, but he’s nowhere in Jimmy G’s league.

Bradshaw was a bit before my time, but looking at 4 rings and a career winning percentage of 67.7 says he was an all time great. And that’s why he’s HOF.

Aikman isn’t quite as good at 56.9 winning percentage, but 3 rings are hard to argue against either. They’re both all-time greats and deservedly in the HOF.

 

[Manster7588]

Jimmy G is 18 games above .500. Dilfer finished 3 wins above .500. It makes him better than say Eli Manning, but he’s nowhere in Jimmy G’s league.

Bradshaw was a bit before my time, but looking at 4 rings and a career winning percentage of 67.7 says he was an all time great. And that’s why he’s HOF.

Aikman isn’t quite as good at 56.9 winning percentage, but 3 rings are hard to argue against either. They’re both all-time greats and deservedly in the HOF.

When's the last time you were sober?

Can you remember those 10 minutes?

 

[Podunkparte]

He’s literally been to a Super Bowl and has a winning percentage over 70%, but do go off…

So he's 5% better than Rex Grossman was.

What a legend!

 

[megalodon30]

So he's 5% better than Rex Grossman was.

What a legend!

Grossman is Dilfer-esq. Went to a SB. Retired 3 games over .500. Also better than Eli; nowhere in Jimmy G’s league.

 

[megalodon30]

When's the last time you were sober?

Can you remember those 10 minutes?

I rarely drink. Can’t remember the last time I did drink.

 

[SteelersPride]

PCP is the only explanation for things happening in this thread

 

[Pure Steel]

The HOF awaits Jimmy G…..

 

[Manster7588]

I rarely drink. Can’t remember the last time I did drink.

I suggest you lie then and tell everyone you're 3 sheets to the wind.

 

[megalodon30]

I suggest you lie then and tell everyone you're 3 sheets to the wind.

Nope. I spit facts, stone cold sober.

 

[wilwhite]

Jimmy G career winning percentage .719
Marino winning percentage .613

Give me Jimmy G every day of the week and twice on Sunday.

You can't have him every day of the week because three days he's hurt.

 

[megalodon30]

You can't have him every day of the week because three days he's hurt.

Also true. A big reason why the Niners have played 30 games without him despite him being in SF for only a handful of years…

 

[Moab]

One could make an argument that if SF had a better QB they would've won the game vs KC in the Superbowl, and that was one of the better games in Jimmy G's career.

Basically, to state that San Fran has a bad roster is probably one of the dumbest things I've read on here. You could state that they have a problem with keeping their talent on the field, and availability is the best ability, but in the end that team is talented as hell and is a dangerous team vs any NFL team.

If you believe Jimmy G is so great, watch his 4th quarter play vs the Bengals where he looked like ass and if he didn't have the best TE in the game right now he would be responsible for a loss instead of them coming back to win in OT.

The real moral of the story is don't allow people bagging on Rodgers being a prima donna cloud your judgement of how good he actually is

 

[Southieinnc]

Nope. I spit facts, stone cold sober.

WTF have you done to this thread!!!!!

 

[Scooby-Doo]

Water boys don't miss many games.

You weren't supposed to tell anyone

 

[Manster7588]

You weren't supposed to tell anyone

Sorry, I had one wingman job, and I screwed it up.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

And where’s that D when Jimmy misses games? 7-23 without him. Same players. Same scheme. Vastly different results…

Since they didn't have Nick Foles, chances are the backup QB sucks. Like most backups in the NFL

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

Exactly.

Just like the running game and defense carried Dilfer to a SB.

And the Seahawks defense carrying Russ to the SB against the Broncos.

 

[Ojb81]

Without Jimmy G, the 49ers are 7-23 under Kyle Shanahan. So either the 49ers have a poor roster carried by a very good QB, or Shanahan is just a bad head coach who looks better when he has a very good QB running his offense. Which is it?

are you a retard? you could do that with just about ANY roster under any coach...if you take away the franchise qb, then the team will have a far worse record than with him playing. don't be a simpleton.

 

[Ojb81]

Nope. I spit facts, stone cold sober.

the only thing you spit is diarrhea of the mouth. please stop.

 

[megalodon30]

are you a retard? you could do that with just about ANY roster under any coach...if you take away the franchise qb, then the team will have a far worse record than with him playing. don't be a simpleton.

So we are agreed. Jimmy G is a franchise QB. That’s all I needed anyone to admit.