Pick 'em!!

[KennyBanyeah]

Player comparisons, who would you take from these two sets of players. Make it for fantasy, real or video game, whatever you want.

Enstrom v. Hedman
L. Eriksson v. B. Ryan
Getzlaf v. E. Staal
Semin v. Franzen
M. Green v. Suter
Rinne v. Price

I go:

Enstrom
Eriksson
Getzlaf
Franzen
Suter
Rinne

 

[flyersfan4706]

Hedman
Ryan
Getzlaf
Semin
Green
Rinne

 

[DaBoltsNIsles]

Hedman
Ryan
Getzlaf
Franzen
Suter
Price

 

[ritari330]

Hedman
Ryan
Staal
Franzen
Suter
Rinne

 

[mattola]

Hedman
B. Ryan
Getzlaf
Franzen
Suter
Rinne

 

[puckhead]

Enstrom (I don't see these two often, so this was a coin toss)
B. Ryan (Fuck dallas)
Getzlaf (Stall is a finisher, Getzlaf creates chances)
Franzen (playoffs > reg season)
M. Green (I still hate Suter for what his uncle did)
Rinne (this was close)

 

[DaBoltsNIsles]

Enstrom (I don't see these two often, so this was a coin toss)
B. Ryan (Fuck dallas)
Getzlaf (Stall is a finisher, Getzlaf creates chances)
Franzen (playoffs > reg season)
M. Green (I still hate Suter for what his uncle did)
Rinne (this was close)

I went with Price because of age & the fact he plays in Montreal. It doesn't get any tougher than that.

 

[Eddie_Shack]

Player comparisons, who would you take from these two sets of players. Make it for fantasy, real or video game, whatever you want.

Enstrom v. Hedman Enstrom: Solid, solid all-around game
L. Eriksson v. B. Ryan Ryan: Not as good of a two-way player, but a beast with unlocked potential
Getzlaf v. E. Staal Getzlaf: This one is close, but I just think Getzlaf is a hair better
Semin v. Franzen I only watch playoff hockey, never the regular season. Who is Semin? What team does he play for? Is this a trick question?
M. Green v. Suter Suter: My man-crush continues
Rinne v. Price Price: Just plain scary good, and at such a young age. Nashville's system benefits goalies, even if I do think Rinne is one of the best in the league

I like turtles

 

[xalbox]

Hedman
B. Ryan
Getzlaf
Franzen
M. Green
Rinne

Boom goes the dynamite

 

[DevilishWon]

Hedman
B. Ryan
Getzlaf
Franzen
Suter
Rinne

 

[Slimpikins]

Enstrom v. Hedman
L. Eriksson v. B. Ryan
Getzlaf v. E. Staal
Semin v. Franzen
M. Green v. Suter
Rinne v. Price


And that's the way it is 'cuz Stone Cold said so.

 

[maddogmark25]

Enstrom v. Hedman
L. Eriksson v. B. Ryan
Getzlaf v. E. Staal
Semin v. Franzen
M. Green v. Suter
Rinne v. Price

 

[Destroydacre]

Enstrom v. Hedman
L. Eriksson v. B. Ryan
Getzlaf v. E. Staal
Semin v. Franzen
M. Green v. Suter
Rinne v. Price

 

[4thstreet]

Enstrom
B.Ryan
Getzlaf
Franzen
Suter
Rinne

 

[KennyBanyeah]

Only consensus pick so far (outside of me) is for B. Ryan.

Interesting.

 

[Eddie_Shack]

Kind of surprised only one person picked Semin... the kid does have sick talent.

 

[ritari330]

I don't know about everyone else, but I did mine based off of who I'd rather be on my team. Talent wise, Semin wins, but he rarely shows the talent he has.

 

[Darkstone42]

Cool topic.

Enstrom (He's better right now, but Hedman could replace him as early as the end of this year)
L. Eriksson (I think he's got a slightly better set of tools, though both players are very similar in most respects.)
E. Staal (I think Getzlaf is more talented, but Staal's just so steady.)
Franzen (Hard to argue with his playoff track record.)
Suter (Better defensively. That's all.)
Rinne (Just barely.)

 

[Slimpikins]

Kind of surprised only one person picked Semin... the kid does have sick talent.

Yeah but if you look at the playoff performances of Franzen it's hard not to choose him. God he pisses me off.

 

[DChero]

Hedman
B. Ryan
Getzlaf
Franzen
Suter
Rinne

Dido.