NFL Fix the Franchise Playoff 2 : Milk vs Ritz

[Nosferatu]

MILK

Philadelphia/Buffalo

OFFENSE
QB - Kurt Warner - Cardinals
RB - O.J. Simpson - Bills
FB - James Wilder - Buccaneers
WR - Andre Reed - Bills
WR - Jimmy Smith - Jaguars
WR - Harold Carmichael - Eagles
TE - Dave Casper - Titans
LT - Jim Lachey - Chargers
LG - Steve Wisniewski - Raiders
C - Jay Hilgenberg - Bears
RG - Jahri Evans - Saints
RT - Willie Anderson - Bengals

DEFENSE
DE - Reggie White (FP) Eagles
DT - Cortez Kennedy - Seahawks
DT - Randy White - Cowboys
DE - Bruce Smith - Bills
LLB - Chuck Bednarik - Eagles
MLB - Zach Thomas - Dolphins
RLB - Isiah Robertson - Bills
CB - Mike Haynes - CB - Patriots
CB - Eric Allen - Eagles
CB - Troy Vincent - Eagles
SS - Troy Polamalu - Steelers
SS - LeRoy Butler - Packers

VS

RITZ

N.Y. Giants/Cincinnati

OFFENSE
QB - Joe Montana - 49ers
RB - Emmitt Smith - Cowboys
FB - Lorenzo Neal - Chargers
WR - Chad Johnson - Bengals
WR - A.J. Green - Bengals
WR - Odell Beckham - Giants
TE - Mark Bavaro - Giants
LT - Anthony Munoz - Bengals
LG - Randall McDaniel - Vikings
C - Jeff Saturday - Colts
RG - Russ Grimm - Redskins
LT - Mike Kenn - Falcons

DEFENSE
DE - Haloti Ngata - Ravens
NT - Ted Washington - Bills
DE - Justin Smith - Bengals
OLB - Lawrence Taylor (FP) Giants
ILB - Mike Singletary - Bears
ILB - Sam Huff - Giants
OLB - Demarcus Ware - Broncos
CB - Ty Law - Patriots
CB - DeAngelo Hall - Falcons
CB - Johnathan Joseph - Bengals
SS - Adrian Wilson - Cardinals
FS - Bob Sanders - Colts

 

[Nosferatu]

MILK - 1
RITZ - 3

VOTED - Shane, WLK, Nos, Ritz

 

[Shanemansj13]

Milk has the best d-line in this draft but I got Ritz in a close one.

 

[wlk3]

Milk I understand your critique of the hieght in my WR but I think you're ignoring the totality of the team strength... Manning reads the defense and his WR have to adjust routes according to those reads, sometimes on the run which is why he was great using shifty athletes more than hieght... Warner uses explosive receivers to his advantage, you have guys who were more possession guys IMO... The offense doesn't mesh and while you have an elite defense, I think Ritz gets enough points to win as his defense is going to make you work as well... I'll say that Casey Hampton > Ted Washington by the way, Ritz pulls out a tough one...

 

[Nosferatu]

Possession receivers? Everytime they showed a highlight of Jimmy Smith it was him racing down the sidelines catching a 45 yard TD from Mark Brunell. I need a minute on this one.

 

[Nosferatu]

I gotta lean Milk here. He has probably the best front 7 in the draft and I think Carmichael was a good pick at least in this game he is, he's got about 8 inches on anyone whos gonna be trying to cover him a great outlet for Warner.

Ritz has probably the weakest secondary in the draft and Emmitt isn't likely to see huge holes running into that front 7. I do like the 3-4 D-line Ritz put together though. I just like what Milk did a bit more.

 

[Ritzarmy]

I got myself. I feel I do have a weaker secondary but my front 7 is sooo nasty that any CB will have a career year.

 

[UK Cowboy]

Twp of the better defenses, but I think Ritz offense is the difference. Better QB and I'd take little Emmitt to control the clock over the Head Lopper

Ritz

 

[Mebert]

Milk

 

[femurov]

Ritz

 

[wlk3]

Possession receivers? Everytime they showed a highlight of Jimmy Smith it was him racing down the sidelines catching a 45 yard TD from Mark Brunell. I need a minute on this one.

Career 14.3ypr, never over 16.1 and that's the highest and only 16 once... Maybe he's a little more than a possession receiver but not explosive by any means IMO, same for Reed, and Carmichael is only height IMO... Not a huge fan of his but to each...

 

[Nosferatu]

Career 14.3ypr, never over 16.1 and that's the highest and only 16 once... Maybe he's a little more than a possession receiver but not explosive by any means IMO, same for Reed, and Carmichael is only height IMO... Not a huge fan of his but to each...

Isaac Bruce 14.9
Jerry Rice 14.8
Randy Moss 15.6
Marvin Harrison 13.2
Terrell Owens 14.8
Torry Holt 14.5


Moss 1.3 yards per reception more than Smith, point is when you catch a lot of passes the YPC is gonna come down, nobody, not even Moss just caught bombs

 

[Pack 500]

Milky

 

[wlk3]

Isaac Bruce 14.9
Jerry Rice 14.8
Randy Moss 15.6
Marvin Harrison 13.2
Terrell Owens 14.8
Torry Holt 14.5


Moss 1.3 yards per reception more than Smith, point is when you catch a lot of passes the YPC is gonna come down, nobody, not even Moss just caught bombs

All those names you posted had multiple games over 16ypr and all had 19 some 20+ypr years... I don't see him as homerun guy, he makes plays but I'm talking explosive... He isn't on my list... I respect him, I'd even draft him... But he can't be the most explosive WR on your team with Warner as your QB... You have Warner, Moon or Marino I don't think you need a bunch of tall guys... Give me Odell Beckham, Randy, Bruce, Holt...

 

[Nosferatu]

All those names you posted had multiple games over 16ypr and all had 19 some 20+ypr years... I don't see him as homerun guy, he makes plays but I'm talking explosive... He isn't on my list... I respect him, I'd even draft him... But he can't be the most explosive WR on your team with Warner as your QB... You have Warner, Moon or Marino I don't think you need a bunch of tall guys... Give me Odell Beckham, Randy, Bruce, Holt...

Yeah, well I think you are a bad skier!