NFC Decade Draft : QF3 Milk vs 500

[Nosferatu]

MILK

NFC-OFFENSE
QB - Bart Starr - Packers
RB - Tiki Barber - Giants
FB - Roger Craig - 80's
WR - Randy Moss - 90's
WR - Terrell Owens - 90's
WR - Bob Hayes - Cowboys
TE - Jimmie Giles - 70's
LT - Mike Kenn - Falcons
LG - Randall McDaniel - 80's
C - Ryan Kalil - Panthers
RG - Jahri Evans - 00's
RT - Jim Lachey - Redskins

NFC-DEFENSE
LDE - Dan Hampton - 70's
LDT - Merlin Olsen - Rams
RDT - Alan Page - Vikings
RDE - Richard Dent - Bears
LOLB - Rickey Jackson - Saints
MLB - Patrick Willis - 00's
RLB - Derrick Brooks - Buccaneers
CB - Lem Barney - Lions
CB - Jimmy Johnson - 49ers
CB - Roger Wehrli - Cardinals
FS - Brian Dawkins - Eagles
FS - Eugene Robinson - Seahawks

VS

500

NFC-OFFENSE
QB - Aaron Rodgers - 00's
RB - Emmitt Smith - 90's
FB - Tom Rathman - 49ers
WR - Cris Carter - Vikings
WR - Sterling Sharpe - Packers
WR - Herman Moore - Lions
TE - Mark Bavaro - Giants
LT - Walter Jones - 90's
LG - Tom Mack - Rams
C - John Sullivan - 00's
RG - Davin Joseph - Buccaneers
RT - Jackie Slater - 70's

NFC-DEFENSE
LDE - Jack Youngblood - 70's
LDT - La'Roi Glover - Saints
RDT - Bob Lilly - Cowboys
RDE - Chris Doleman - 80's
LLB - Thomas Davis - Panthers
MLB - Mike Singletary - Bears
RLB - Lance Briggs - 00's
CB - Deion Sanders - Falcons
CB - Troy Vincent - Eagles
CB - Shawn Springs - Seahawks
SS - Ken Houston - Redskins
FS - Tyrann Mathieu - Cardinals

 

[Nosferatu]

MILK -
500 - 4

VOTED - Femur, Shane, Ritz, Nos

Race to 4

 

[femurov]

500

 

[Shanemansj13]

I need time on this one. Thought Milk could have went with different QB options

 

[Ritzarmy]

I need time on this one. Thought Milk could have went with different QB options

Choosing his QB at the very end was very risky especially when he has stud receivers. I don’t think he could have gotten a better QB that late in the draft but it’s not the reason I feel he loses this matchup. 500’s team just seems to flow well together. Not sure how to describe it. They all fit his system and I like his D (yes I said I like his D). The way Milks team was posted he has Rickey Jackson as ROLB in a 4-3 D, and he has 2 free safeties. Yes Jackson can play in 4-3 and yes one of his safeties could play SS but that’s why I mentioned how 500’s team flowed better. So I got 500 winning.

 

[Shanemansj13]

I’ll take 500 in a very close one

 

[Nosferatu]

Two excellent defensive lines in this one. I may be wrong but it kinda feels like Milk stopped caring. Bart Starr was a great QB so I don't feel that should be seen as a negative because he was drafted so late. 500 doesn't have a lot of speed in his skill positions but play action will be a killer for him with these guys.

I got 500 in a pretty damn close game...

 

[Nosferatu]

Congrats 500

 

[Shanemansj13]

Choosing his QB at the very end was very risky especially when he has stud receivers. I don’t think he could have gotten a better QB that late in the draft but it’s not the reason I feel he loses this matchup. 500’s team just seems to flow well together. Not sure how to describe it. They all fit his system and I like his D (yes I said I like his D). The way Milks team was posted he has Rickey Jackson as ROLB in a 4-3 D, and he has 2 free safeties. Yes Jackson can play in 4-3 and yes one of his safeties could play SS but that’s why I mentioned how 500’s team flowed better. So I got 500 winning.

Yeah QB doesnt ultimately decide this for me bc Starr was a great. I really like both defense so it’s close, I just think 500 is a tad more balanced but it’s almost even

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I knew I would lose with my QB choice... but like I said in the basketball draft we had last time, I find it funny how we give some players respect from an era and disrespect others from the same era... Bart Starr is seen to be a top 20 all time QB, for him to be the REASON for me to lose is a bit of a joke...

500 had a great team, but his running game is one dimensional, and his receiving game has little speed...

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Two excellent defensive lines in this one. I may be wrong but it kinda feels like Milk stopped caring. Bart Starr was a great QB so I don't feel that should be seen as a negative because he was drafted so late. 500 doesn't have a lot of speed in his skill positions but play action will be a killer for him with these guys.

I got 500 in a pretty damn close game...

where did I stop caring... sure I messed up at TE, but I planned on Bart Starr from the beginning, and once I lost edge, I was planning on Tiki with Rogers... I think they compliment eachother well... And both had multiple seasons of 2000+ scrimmage yards...


this is why voting sucks, if you cant separate your personal feelings about me and my team... then whats the point...

 

[Nosferatu]

where did I stop caring... sure I messed up at TE, but I planned on Bart Starr from the beginning, and once I lost edge, I was planning on Tiki with Rogers... I think they compliment eachother well... And both had multiple seasons of 2000+ scrimmage yards...

Letting people pick while you had two picks on the clock, that's when it seemed like you stopped caring.

I just defended Starr and after you there is probably nobody in the drafts that likes Tiki more than I do.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Letting people pick while you had two picks on the clock, that's when it seemed like you stopped caring.

I just defended Starr and after you there is probably nobody in the drafts that likes Tiki more than I do.

like I said, I fucked up with TE... the reason I kept on waiting was because the players I wanted I thought I could get later, and I THOUGHT I could trade those picks... which I tried doing wit RITZ.... Also, Like I have told you many times, weekends I am not by my computer much, and I HATE doing research on my phone... the AFC picks I made were much less research for me because they were glaring players I wanted...

and by telling people to skip me, at least I let you guys not go crazy on me for taking too long... but yea, I quit...

 

[Nosferatu]

like I said, I fucked up with TE... the reason I kept on waiting was because the players I wanted I thought I could get later, and I THOUGHT I could trade those picks... which I tried doing wit RITZ.... Also, Like I have told you many times, weekends I am not by my computer much, and I HATE doing research on my phone... the AFC picks I made were much less research for me because they were glaring players I wanted...

and by telling people to skip me, at least I let you guys not go crazy on me for taking too long... but yea, I quit...

Okay

 

[Pack 500]

Two excellent defensive lines in this one. I may be wrong but it kinda feels like Milk stopped caring. Bart Starr was a great QB so I don't feel that should be seen as a negative because he was drafted so late. 500 doesn't have a lot of speed in his skill positions but play action will be a killer for him with these guys.

I got 500 in a pretty damn close game...

While it's true nobody has great speed, these are the kinds of receivers Rodgers loves to work with. He's never played with a dynamic speed threat.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

500