MBBRL Dynasty roster thread

[TREFF]

do not start more than 9 or you are changing the game

as for deep rosters that is what makes it Dynasty

I keep hearing people say that, but have yet to have a rational, real reason as to why. I can build a dynasty with 18, just as easily as I can with 20. A deeper roster might make it more difficult. .but then say that, say you want a higher level of difficulty if that's what you mean (you as in anyone with this thought process. Not you specifically Bar). .deeper rosters don't make it a dynasty, building a team and keeping that team together makes it a dynasty, regardless of roster size

 

[Yellow Fuzzies]

When you guys figure out the rules let us know- Fuzzy and Lefty have agreed to co-manage a team. We hope with two MBBRL owners we can overcome our lack of dynasty experience.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

MY vote as always is the more the merrier... But i think the more we OWN the MORE we should start...

 

[Trudem]

I keep hearing people say that, but have yet to have a rational, real reason as to why. I can build a dynasty with 18, just as easily as I can with 20. A deeper roster might make it more difficult. .but then say that, say you want a higher level of difficulty if that's what you mean (you as in anyone with this thought process. Not you specifically Bar). .deeper rosters don't make it a dynasty, building a team and keeping that team together makes it a dynasty, regardless of roster size

My current modified dynasty league has 20 but we play with 2 IDPs so its 18 regular positions. Thats with 12 teams. The RB situation is already pretty scarce but I am ok with 18 or 20.

 

[Ram Tough]

I'd prefer 18-20 rounds... just like the real NFL you will be able to take guys late and stash them for the future.

 

[Barilko]

18 to 20. But start 9 Keep it simple

 

[Barilko]

I keep hearing people say that, but have yet to have a rational, real reason as to why. I can build a dynasty with 18, just as easily as I can with 20. A deeper roster might make it more difficult. .but then say that, say you want a higher level of difficulty if that's what you mean (you as in anyone with this thought process. Not you specifically Bar). .deeper rosters don't make it a dynasty, building a team and keeping that team together makes it a dynasty, regardless of roster size

Good point Treff and I'm cool with 18 also

Just trying to get attention as we are all over the place

We need some one to take charge.

I sent pms to who I thought was in charge and didn't even get a reply

Now maybe he is busy and by stating this publicly I may have created an adversary. But......

I think we need to settle stuff because there will be lots of questions that need answers

 

[obxyankeefan]

I would suggest having everyone vote, just wright your choices on this thread.

Lineup 1
QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, TE, FLEX, K, D

Lineup 2
QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, WR, TE, K, D


Second vote is bench size

5, 7, 9, or 11




@Microwahevo, is this good with you?

 

[Trudem]

I vote for lineup #1

Bench I am fine with either 9 or 11

 

[Microwahevo]

Good point Treff and I'm cool with 18 also

Just trying to get attention as we are all over the place

We need some one to take charge.

I sent pms to who I thought was in charge and didn't even get a reply

Now maybe he is busy and by stating this publicly I may have created an adversary. But......

I think we need to settle stuff because there will be lots of questions that need answers

I got ur PM. And I had been taking charge, but I'm not about to create this league based on only things I want. We have 14 people that are going to be playing and it seems that most would like their input as to how it gets set up. That's why I'm creating threads for each topic were discussing. Everything can get lost and off track on the main dynasty thread.

We have already decided on the amount of owners and are nearing a decision on roster size. I have no plans of making a draft this month or even in June so we have plenty of time to hash this out.

You haven't created an adversary, I'm just trying to let people discuss their opinions. Answers are coming along to the questions being posed.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

The one thing I really want with roster size is for us to START at least half of our roster... I don't like the idea of having more bench players than starters...

 

[TREFF]

I got ur PM. And I had been taking charge, but I'm not about to create this league based on only things I want. We have 14 people that are going to be playing and it seems that most would like their input as to how it gets set up. That's why I'm creating threads for each topic were discussing. Everything can get lost and off track on the main dynasty thread.

We have already decided on the amount of owners and are nearing a decision on roster size. I have no plans of making a draft this month or even in June so we have plenty of time to hash this out.

You haven't created an adversary, I'm just trying to let people discuss their opinions. Answers are coming along to the questions being posed.

Well said Micro, plenty of time, these discussions need to be had to ensure everyone is fully on board. Same thing id be doing as well. Keep it up

 

[leftypower]

I vote for lineup #1

Bench I am fine with either 9 or 11

Same with me. .....

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Line up #1

9 or 11 is fine with me.

 

[broncosmitty]

The one thing I really want with roster size is for us to START at least half of our roster... I don't like the idea of having more bench players than starters...

I agree on starting at least half the roster.

 

[Ram Tough]

#1 and 9 or 11

 

[Barilko]

I got ur PM. And I had been taking charge, but I'm not about to create this league based on only things I want. We have 14 people that are going to be playing and it seems that most would like their input as to how it gets set up. That's why I'm creating threads for each topic were discussing. Everything can get lost and off track on the main dynasty thread.

We have already decided on the amount of owners and are nearing a decision on roster size. I have no plans of making a draft this month or even in June so we have plenty of time to hash this out.

You haven't created an adversary, I'm just trying to let people discuss their opinions. Answers are coming along to the questions being posed.

cool that is exactly what i suggested in the PM

 

[Barilko]

1 and 9 or 11 also

 

[Barilko]

but I'm not about to create this league based on only things I want

i never asked you to do that...

We have 14 people that are going to be playing and it seems that most would like their input as to how it gets set up. That's why I'm creating threads for each topic were discussing. Everything can get lost and off track on the main dynasty thread.

which is exactly what i suggested in the PM

I have no plans of making a draft this month or even in June so we have plenty of time to hash this out.

Perfect

You haven't created an adversary,

Glad to hear



Micro the only reason i wrote the message i did is because i was surprised that i didnt hear back from you after having taken the time to send a pm with basically all that you are doing

im not looking for credit im glad to see we are on the same page

Well said Micro, plenty of time, these discussions need to be had to ensure everyone is fully on board. Same thing id be doing as well. Keep it up

and ditto to this quote from Treff

 

[Chef99]

Easy boys, we got through the hardest part, it's all gravy from here.