Mark reynolds or Adam dunn

[MilkSpiller22]

Who would you rather have this season... Both are pretty similar players...

Also why is Trumbo ADP so much higher than Dunn and Reynolds?? Is there that much of a difference??

 

[TDs3nOut]

Dunn plays more often, so he can drag your team's BA down more. Dunn has hit a lot more HRs the past couple of seasons, but I think that Milwaukee is a good place to hit HRs, so perhaps Reynolds hits more HRs this year than he has in recent years. I think I would choose Dunn, simply because he's a lefty and more pitchers are right handed than left handed.

 

[obxyankeefan]

Dunn plays more often, so he can drag your team's BA down more. Dunn has hit a lot more HRs the past couple of seasons, but I think that Milwaukee is a good place to hit HRs, so perhaps Reynolds hits more HRs this year than he has in recent years. I think I would choose Dunn, simply because he's a lefty and more pitchers are right handed than left handed.

Reynolds is playing for Milwaukees AAA club this year. Take Dunn.

 

[Reverend Jim]

Who would you rather have this season... Both are pretty similar players...

Also why is Trumbo ADP so much higher than Dunn and Reynolds?? Is there that much of a difference??

Dunn or Reynolds?? Dunn if forced to pick one, but I'd rather go with option C.

 

[Driaz]

Who would you rather have this season... Both are pretty similar players...

Also why is Trumbo ADP so much higher than Dunn and Reynolds?? Is there that much of a difference??

Trumbo's crappy BA of .250 is about .100 points higher than Dunn and Reynolds? LOL

Seriously though, I can't see a whole bunch of difference.....Dunn and Reynolds will draw walks if playing OBP instead of BA....

 

[tlance]

Trumbo's crappy BA of .250 is about .100 points higher than Dunn and Reynolds? LOL

Seriously though, I can't see a whole bunch of difference.....Dunn and Reynolds will draw walks if playing OBP instead of BA....

Neither?

 

[HammerDown]

There is no place in the big leagues for garbage like Mark Reynolds.