Is there really a DH GOAT controversy?

[ulmax]

Rotation..

1castillo.
2.kerby..
3.gilbert
5.ray..(miller.).
6.hancock..

6.miller.
7.dollard....out t.j.
8 woo..
The Tampa trade.also.included.
Askew.and.galue...starting.pitchers

Askew .LHP..AA..
Galue...rhp...high.A. but ready for.AA.

Gotta remember..mariners are.
Giving.up.a top.100..prospect.here..in.
Harry Ford ..witch I use.
For a high minor.s..
Attrition...Patch.

 

[ulmax]

If ya want an excuse call..it a root.
T.v. trade .
Lololo

 

[ulmax]

Yeah its Tampa one stop.shopping.
You can get.
A bull pen guy even...
But Tampa's Achilles heel..is.
Catchers..
Mariners have..Dan Wilson..making..
Sure.
Mariners.always.have...good catchers.

 

[ulmax]

Yeah .hit. um ..in the weak..spot.

 

[ulmax]

In an over.all..a .collage catcher.
Could.make it to MLB..
In a couple years..ford.maybe at least that..far away..
And would be a backup.
When he got there.

 

[ulmax]

2024.mariners...mlb draft..

1#15.Montgomery..RF/rhp.
#2.collage.pitcher..
#3.hs.pitcher..
(.they have jeter Martinez..I'll.count him.hs)..
#4..catcher ..collage..
#5..cf..
#6..collage...catch..
#7.LF..
Mariners..have not traded ..

Mike arroyo..
Or any .
Other .minor leaguers...so good...so.far.
Means...they won't..need replace.

 

[ulmax]

You could..xxxxxx.out..collage..
Pitcher if..
They got 2 from Tampa.

 

[wazzu31]

Plus this also a direct argument. Edgar was the better player, or Ortiz would’ve stayed a Mariner.

 

[BigKen]

When you only see one logo as "THE" logo and one team as "THE" team, logic goes out of the conversation.

Example.

'Carlton Fisk hit the most memorable Home Run in MLB history.'

Caveat to above:

Unless you were born after 1967.


When you have a bias toward YOUR team, you have biases against all others.

Failure to recognize it and admit it, makes an argument pointless to anyone less as committed as you.

 

[PolarVortex]

When you only see one logo as "THE" logo and one team as "THE" team, logic goes out of the conversation.

Example.

'Carlton Fisk hit the most memorable Home Run in MLB history.'

Caveat to above:

Unless you were born after 1967.


When you have a bias toward YOUR team, you have biases against all others.

Failure to recognize it and admit it, makes an argument pointless to anyone less as committed as you.

You could have just said Edgar > Papi. Would have been much easier.

Like this:
ARod > Nomar
Randy Johnson > Roger Clemens

But Dewey beats out Bone, so you got that going for you.

 

[black francis]

Weird how a guy can go from league average to one of the best dhs in history with a simple change in teams.

Something else must have been in play. I wonder what that could have been.