Is Matt stafford a big upgrade over these QBs?

[Hambombs]

Foles, romo and kaep?

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

No, not really. Slightly better, but I would probably put them all in the same group as of right now.

 

[TREFF]

Without Calvin no. .Although he probably would be better than Kaeps most weeks.
With Calvin he's definitely an upgrade on Foles, and dependant on the match ups between he and Romo

 

[Hambombs]

Ok cause this guy claims he's a "big" upgrade over who I have. And is offering him and Ellington to me for McCoy

 

[TREFF]

Ok cause this guy claims he's a "big" upgrade over who I have. And is offering him and Ellington to me for McCoy

His claim might not be accurate, but that isn't a terrible deal. Two fifths of McCoys line are still out and will be for quite awhile.. He might not get much better than he is now

 

[wilwhite]

Ellington's looking pretty solid - pro-rated, he's the 7th-best RB out there and he's already had his bye while McCoy's is still to come. I think you win at both positions with that deal.

 

[Hambombs]

His claim might not be accurate, but that isn't a terrible deal. Two fifths of McCoys line are still out and will be for quite awhile.. He might not get much better than he is now

Now he's offering me ellington, Lamar miller, stafford for McCoy and Ryan Matthews. Thoughts? Should I take it if I can still make the playoffs despite mccoys struggles? I'm in his division also

 

[Hambombs]

If mccoy is truely going to elite again I don't think it's smart

 

[TREFF]

If mccoy is truely going to elite again I don't think it's smart

Pretty big if at this point IMHO.

 

[TREFF]

Now he's offering me ellington, Lamar miller, stafford for McCoy and Ryan Matthews. Thoughts? Should I take it if I can still make the playoffs despite mccoys struggles? I'm in his division also

Like the first deal better. . Don't care for Lamar Miller with Moreno's return looming large

 

[wilwhite]

A sub-3 YPC through five games is pretty scary. No way I'd offer what he's offering for McCoy. I'd take that first deal.

As Tlance said elsewhere, McCoy is having the kind of season that can kill you - a recently elite RB that you don't dare sit but who isn't producing.

 

[Hambombs]

Like the first deal better. . Don't care for Lamar Miller with Moreno's return looming large

Ok. My RBs would be elkington, spiller, Matthews, Thomas after this trade. Might put Pierre Thomas in the trade instead of matthews

 

[Hambombs]

I don't know though I don't feel great about the deal. Is Ellington the real deal? Other than that one game it's been 6.5, 10.2 and 7.2 and last year didn't look that special at all. I could ask for rivers in the deal instead of stafford

 

[TREFF]

I don't know though I don't feel great about the deal. Is Ellington the real deal? Other than that one game it's been 6.5, 10.2 and 7.2 and last year didn't look that special at all. I could ask for rivers in the deal instead of stafford

He's dealing Stafford because he's set his mind to starting Rivers..highly doubtful he'd consider the current #2QB for such an underperforming RB. Ellington might only be slightly above average, might be the next big thing, but that's better than what McCoy has been, or looks like he might have a chance to be the rest of the year.

 

[Hambombs]

A sub-3 YPC through five games is pretty scary. No way I'd offer what he's offering for McCoy. I'd take that first deal.

As Tlance said elsewhere, McCoy is having the kind of season that can kill you - a recently elite RB that you don't dare sit but who isn't producing.

I'm 3-2 right now and it hasn't killed me cause I have walker, and all those receivers, dez, jordy, alshon in my lineup

 

[Hambombs]

He's dealing Stafford because he's set his mind to starting Rivers..highly doubtful he'd consider the current #2QB for such an underperforming RB. Ellington might only be slightly above average, might be the next big thing, but that's better than what McCoy has been, or looks like he might have a chance to be the rest of the year.

I don't know about #2 lol but I get your point

 

[Hambombs]

I'm just getting offers left and right for mccoy... Another guy offered me Alfred morris, Edelman, Doug Martin for McCoy and alshon. I say no way right?