Heisman Trophy Finalists Officially Announced: Tua Tagovailoa, Kyler Murray, Dwayne Haskins

[CouchOnFire]

It's Murray's... it has to be. Hell he's faster when he's stumbling than others are at full speed and legs under them. He impressed me... but, I don't vote.

 

[bamabear82]

I'll believe Tua isn't going to win when I see it.

You'd have to be a super weak minded crazy conspiracy believing type of person to think such at this point.

 

[carson]

This is very simple: Kyler wins, Saban uses it as bulletin board material, and then Bama murders Oklahoma in the semis.

Oh ... and Haskins isn't in the final 3 if McKenzie didn't lose a leg.

 

[BusSport]

"The Case for Kyler Murray" statistical comparison:

 

[carson]

Simply comparing offensive stats is stupidity. I mean, if we're just going to go with better stats ... then why hold a vote?

Kyler's stats are inflated due to inferior competition. He's also had the ball way more, due to the fact the Oklahoma defense averages about 2 minutes on the field, per drive.

 

[HOGGZ1LLA]

When will we next see a defender win it?

 

[cmc_rebar]

Kyler's stats are inflated due to inferior competition.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

Simply comparing offensive stats is stupidity. I mean, if we're just going to go with better stats ... then why hold a vote?

Kyler's stats are inflated due to inferior competition. He's also had the ball way more, due to the fact the Oklahoma defense averages about 2 minutes on the field, per drive.

Oklahoma has a defense?

This is why it should go to Murray he carried his team. Inferior competition is a fallacy. If we are basing this on comp level Haskins has the edge.......

 

[Wishbone]

Even more reason to give it to Kyler as he was able to beat every team on the schedule despite the horrible defense. He willed his teams to wins. But it's not like he put up those numbers against Louisville, Louisiana, Arkansas St., and The Citadel.

 

[Diego Roll Tide]

Even more reason to give it to Kyler as he was able to beat every team on the schedule despite the horrible defense. He willed his teams to wins. But it's not like he put up those numbers against Louisville, Louisiana, Arkansas St., and The Citadel.

Kyler will win it, but not because of schedule. OU’s schedule was not the tougher one.

 

[ralphiewvu]

This is very simple: Kyler wins, Saban uses it as bulletin board material, and then Bama murders Oklahoma in the semis.

Oh ... and Haskins isn't in the final 3 if McKenzie didn't lose a leg.

@Across The Field

 

[ralphiewvu]

Simply comparing offensive stats is stupidity. I mean, if we're just going to go with better stats ... then why hold a vote?

Kyler's stats are inflated due to inferior competition. He's also had the ball way more, due to the fact the Oklahoma defense averages about 2 minutes on the field, per drive.

Seriously you make a comment like that after saying Milton would be in if not hurt?

 

[fishinabarrel]

Simply comparing offensive stats is stupidity. I mean, if we're just going to go with better stats ... then why hold a vote?

Kyler's stats are inflated due to inferior competition. He's also had the ball way more, due to the fact the Oklahoma defense averages about 2 minutes on the field, per drive.

How in the world can you type this immediately after saying UCFs qb should have gotten in over Haskins?

 

[fishinabarrel]

Seriously you make a comment like that after saying Milton would be in if not hurt?

I immediately thought the same thing

 

[fishinabarrel]

I think Tua could win it still and is an excellent player. Here's the thing though, take Tua off that team and they are probably still SEC champs and going to the playoffs. Take Kyler or Haskins off their teams and it would be disastrous

 

[Diego Roll Tide]

I think Tua could win it still and is an excellent player. Here's the thing though, take Tua off that team and they are probably still SEC champs and going to the playoffs. Take Kyler or Haskins off their teams and it would be disastrous

Murray will win the HT, but how do we know any of that?

Last year all we heard was how without Mayfield OU would be a 4-loss team, yet his backup has been even better.

Murray should win the Heisman for what he did on the field, not for speculation.

 

[Across The Field]

@Across The Field

Isn't that cute?

 

[Deep Creek]

Said this on the other thread. If Murray wins it, there will be back to back Oklahoma Heisman winning QBs that did not begin their college football careers at OU.

 

[PIBuckeye]

Honestly I’d still give the edge to Tua.

Why? Haskins is more deserving looking at the stats......

 

[Yo Tee]

Not like I want another reason for Oklahoma fans to be cocky, but if Kyler Murray doesn't win the Heisman, there's officially a conspiracy going on in the world of College Football. I can see an argument for Haskins, but trying to make an argument for Tua is just not an educated argument in my opinion. In fact, they should've only invited Haskins and Murray to the damn ceremony.