Dez or Aaron Rodgers?

[The Foot]

Let me break this down a little further.

Let's assume no needs are a factor. On strait value, who would you rather own this year?

Rodgers

or

Dez

 

[Barilko]

well hard to compare qb to wr

however ill weigh in by saying both top 3 at their position in my book

so ... i guess i cant weigh in... i like it better when u had the other factors (players)involved

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I would always go QB, only because QBs can carry your fantasy team on any given week better than any other position.. Try having the best week in the league without having your QB having the most points that week... its very hard...

 

[Davis_Mike]

Rodgers for me. Rodgers is top 5 in points for his position while Dez is only top 10 at his position. It really depends on where or when you are drafting.

 

[Barilko]

i do not agree

if you take a stud qb in round one you will not get a rb1 or you may get a borderline rb 1 in round 2 and you will not get a wr1 in round 3 and i believe you will not win without having both a rb1 and a wr1...

if you hold off on a qb until later rounds you will definitely get a rb1 in 1 and a wr1 in 2 and still have a good enough Qb to win

i do agree that it does depend where you draft

I also believe Dez is way better than top 10 and he may even end up at 1 if he and Romo stay heathy

 

[HammerDown]

 

[SteelersPride]

Dez, the drop off in wr's is greater than the drop off in qb;s

 

[ZepTepi]

Let me break this down a little further.

Let's assume no needs are a factor. On strait value, who would you rather own this year?

Rodgers

or

Dez

PPR = Dez

Non-PPR = Rodgers

 

[tlance]

Shocked so many are saying Rodgers.

Rodgers is the 2nd or 3rd QB. Dez is the 2nd or 3rd WR. Taking Rodgers over Dez is a mistake. QBs are easy to find.

 

[GNG]

Shocked so many are saying Rodgers.

Rodgers is the 2nd or 3rd QB. Dez is the 2nd or 3rd WR. Taking Rodgers over Dez is a mistake. QBs are easy to find.

Rodgers. This guy is elite.

 

[Beengay fudgepackers]

I like getting two pretty good QBs, then playing match ups. If done correctly you can match elite QBs. I'd go des. I think AR gets hurt again.

 

[TxHeat]

DEZ!!!!

 

[dblakejr7]

Des as well.. Qb pool is deeper then the wr pool at least tier wise

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I am beginning to be hesitant on Rodgers being a top 3 QB... I do think he has the talent, and his lack of interceptions is an amazing skill... But Lacy is the best RB that Rodgers has ever had, and will likely steal the show more often... Unless The packers score Broncos amount of TDs, having a top 10 RB and a top 3 QB is very tough...