Current +4 MLB Draft Semi-Final 2 : Mebert vs Jeffro

[MilkSpiller22]

Neither starting rotation is holding these offenses down so I will go by the better offense

Rickey > Kipnis
Carew > Machado
A-Rod < Babe
Ott < Hank
Teix < Yogi
Davis < Bautista
Posey > Jones
Arenado < Gordon
Hunter > Xander

5-4 Jeffro so basically a wash. I do like the middle of Mebert's middle of the order a lot even though Jeffro's is better. I think the difference comes down to the bullpen. I can't see Mebert holding any leads with that pen and the starters won't be going long these games while Jeffro has Betances and Davis.

Jeffro

your analysis is a little bit off... first off bautista and davis were swapped so it was 5-4 Mebert(by your ranking)

2nd of all Mebert has the better bullpen... Huston Street is actually one of the better closers of all time... His 2 lefty RP are ELITE setup men...