- Thread starter
- #941
Draft Crazy
Supporting Member
Daurice Fountain
Interesting prospect. Was getting some good buzz even before his great proday.
Daurice Fountain
I picked Lazard Iowa St
Now that we are only a month out from the draft, where do you see Dallas Goedert going? I have seen him in the 1st round a while back, but Walter has him as a 3-4 round on him now. Thoughts?
Thanks DC and cdulmer7.
I hope we take the chance and draft him.
That was a great breakdown on a Qb evaluation and I'm serious. Let me try and help you from getting carpal tunnel syndrome in future. A franchise Qb needs to have decent arm, throw with anticipation and accuracy, pocket awareness and / or escape ability, leadership , the " football smarts " to absorb and retain what he learns and most importantly the will and dedication to be great. The wins and SBs are achievable then. A strong D and good offensive supporting cast is also recommended. Just trying to keep ya healthy DocFrom my time evaluating players, and specifically quarterbacks, from the college ranks to the NFL, I have come to five main traits I seek from the tape when evaluating throwers of the football
Kendell’s QB Evaluators
1) Ability to Process and Go Through Progressions
2) Pocket Maneuverability and Feel
3) Accuracy and Precision
4) Arm Talent
5) Physical Ability/Athleticism
You ABSOLUTELY need to have 1-3 to succeed in the NFL. It’s non-negotiable.
Going through progressions quickly and correctly is number one to me. The speed and effectiveness a player is able to make their reads against different defenses as the play unfolds and make the correct decision is crucial. It’s one reason Air Raid and Spread quarterbacks have been red flags in the NFL, for the most part, they aren’t asked to develop that skill set. Reading what the defense provides and making the right read in a timely matter is an absolute necessity. This also goes hand in hand with their ability on the whiteboard and ability to make presnap checks and reads (ala the king at that Peyton Manning) but even the smartest guys on the board don’t always have that intelligence translate once the bullets are flying.
Pocket Maneuverability has as much to do with movement within the pocket as it does ability to continue going through progressions and deliver the proper throw even with chaos going on around the QB and defenders breathing down his neck. How a quarterback is able to remain consistent in his technique and progressions despite 300lb+ men around him is crucial for success in today’s game. Look at Siemian as the antithesis to this skill set. Not only did he crumble with any sort of pressure, but he had no spatial awareness or feel to slide in the pocket to help his offensive line and buy time as a thrower. You just aren’t going to get a consistent pocket in today’s NFL, so the ability to move and hang tough is imperative.
Accuracy to me is both tape based as well as mechanical based. A QBs ability to be consistent in his throwing motion and his repeatable footwork in his drop are important. Of course a QB needs to be able to throw off of different platforms and different arm slots, but in classic drop backs which should be 90% of the tape, it must look like the same motion (dependent on 3/5/7 step drops). Accuracy deep is awesome, but it is accuracy on the short and intermediate routes that matter most. How many times a game does a quarterback have to throw the ball 60 yards down the field? Not often. Instead, there must be touch (proper speed and path) in the short and intermediate part of the field so that the playmakers have a chance to create YAC.
As for Arm Talent and Physical ability, they are things that is not ‘more is better’ but rather, ‘if you don’t reach this threshold, it’s an issue.’ Take for instance Jamarcus Russell and Cardale Jones. Two of the best arms I have ever seen scouting the game of football. Amazing raw strength and zip and down the field ability. Put on the highlights from those players in college and you will see 60+ yard bomb after 60+ yard bomb with tremendous mustard and touch on the ball down the field, all delivered in a monster frame to boot. These are secondary skills to me though. The best quarterbacks of the last decade didn’t have the best arm or the best frame or the most athleticism. No, but instead they had accuracy, the ability to go through progressions quickly and correctly, and amazing pocket maneuverability and feel.
There is of course the human factor as well, from work ethic to leadership that I do not have true access to, only hearsay from sources in the league and blips from teammates and coaches, and that of course is absolutely important as well. However, to claim to know for sure about leadership is something that I see as a stretch. You have to go off of coaches, teammates, and those that are closest to the player, but what we all should hang our hats on as evaluators is analyzing the tape.
Big arms and athletes make better highlights, but accuracy/touch, ability to go through progressions correctly, and movement from within the pocket to increase the opportunity to find the right read and deliver the ball to a playmaker with a chance to make a play is the name of the game. Moving the chains and maintaining consistent drives is what runs an offense and wins championships.
Is he a C\GShowing a lot of interest in Iowa C James Daniels.
I’d be really surprised if someone sent us a 2nd round pick for Paradise, especially with the back issues he has consistently had to deal with.Is he a C\G
Maybe someone signs Paradis to an offer sheet
I’d be really surprised if someone sent us a 2nd round pick for Paradise, especially with the back issues he has consistently had to deal with.
Is he a C\G
Maybe someone signs Paradis to an offer sheet