Banner

[moxie]

Added the last pic...

Diggin' the "Buster Hugs" because that is definitely one of our "things".

 

[calsnowskier]

Looks awesome Doobs, great job as always. Another big Congrats to Giants fans, was a great series... How about you give someone else a chance now?

We let everyone else compete in the odd years. That's more than the Yanks ever did in their runs...

 

[Mays-Fan]

I agree on dumping Posey/Wilson IF the Timmeh image works.

I kinda like having the 3 trophies together though. Just my opinion...

Do we want to reference the 5 NY trophies at all?

Don't know about the 5 NY trophies, but someone I think suggested a picture of John McGraw:

You may be right about the 3 SF trophies together, but I'd kinda like to see them alternated with the players to see what it looked like first.

I don't like the SportsHoopla logo unless we have to have it.

 

[Nosferatu]

We let everyone else compete in the odd years. That's more than the Yanks ever did in their runs...

I know, those bastards, my clubs season ended too many times at the hands of the Yanks...

 

[DoobeeDoobeeDoo]

Yea.

That could buy some space, and the crowd just looks kinda weird in this setting.

K, I cropped the sides, still looks funny IMO.

Personal opinion, banner would be better without that pic altogether, but if it's an iconic pic for Giants fans then I'll try to make it work somehow. Just saying, aesthetically speaking, it's probably the biggest challenge on the banner.

 

[HammerDown]

Looks awesome Doobs, great job as always. Another big Congrats to Giants fans, was a great series... How about you give someone else a chance now?

Nos, they have one spot to fill on the banner and I have a perfect idea.

A broom
The Padres logo over top of it with the dates of the sweep. I think it was a 4-game series.

Should be a nice touch, don't you think?

 

[moxie]

K, I cropped the sides, still looks funny IMO.

Personal opinion, banner would be better without that pic altogether, but if it's an iconic pic for Giants fans then I'll try to make it work somehow. Just saying, aesthetically speaking, it's probably the biggest challenge on the banner.

Maybe one that is tighter in so there's less crowd in the existing photo, then move it lower on the banner itself?

 

[Nosferatu]

Nos, they have one spot to fill on the banner and I have a perfect idea.

A broom
The Padres logo over top of it with the dates of the sweep. I think it was a 4-game series.

Should be a nice touch, don't you think?

 

[Mays-Fan]

K, I cropped the sides, still looks funny IMO.

Personal opinion, banner would be better without that pic altogether, but if it's an iconic pic for Giants fans then I'll try to make it work somehow. Just saying, aesthetically speaking, it's probably the biggest challenge on the banner.

Agreed about the Timmy pic. Iconic, yes, but it's dark and too busy.

 

[HammerDown]

Perfect! majority wins. Put it up, Doobs!

 

[DoobeeDoobeeDoo]

Doobster has an idea.

Can you guys come up with a list of current Giant players you would like on the banner? Not moments, but just the players. I think I could put both players and moments on the banner with ought it being all cluttered.

 

[calsnowskier]

One fan base celebrates a regular season sweep.

Another fan base is struggling with how to aesthetically deal with 3 championship season's worth of images.

The call is in the judges hands now...

 

[DoobeeDoobeeDoo]

Perfect! majority wins. Put it up, Doobs!

Hammer, are you trolling these fine people?

 

[HammerDown]

Hammer, are you trolling these fine people?

cal is trying to figure out how to ban me from the board right now.

 

[calsnowskier]

K, I cropped the sides, still looks funny IMO.

Personal opinion, banner would be better without that pic altogether, but if it's an iconic pic for Giants fans then I'll try to make it work somehow. Just saying, aesthetically speaking, it's probably the biggest challenge on the banner.

I was thinking of more a crop around only Timmeh. Not sure if I explained that well. The box crop is definitely a no-go.

 

[Mays-Fan]

Doobster has an idea.

Can you guys come up with a list of current Giant players you would like on the banner? Not moments, but just the players. I think I could put both players and moments on the banner with ought it being all cluttered.

By "list of current Giant players" do you mean a literal list of names, or do you mean photos?

A list would get dated pretty fast, IMHO.

 

[calsnowskier]

cal is trying to figure out how to ban me from the board right now.

I know the owner of this place. One quick message, and...

 

[DoobeeDoobeeDoo]

By "list of current Giant players" do you mean a literal list of names, or do you mean photos?

A list would get dated pretty fast, IMHO.

A list of players you would like to see on the banner, not like the whole roster, but maybe 4 or 5 players that you think deserve to be on the banner more than anyone else.

 

[DoobeeDoobeeDoo]

I was thinking of more a crop around only Timmeh. Not sure if I explained that well. The box crop is definitely a no-go.

I was trying, but there are too many people around him. Hard to cut him out without making it look all goofy.

 

[DoobeeDoobeeDoo]

By "list of current Giant players" do you mean a literal list of names, or do you mean photos?

A list would get dated pretty fast, IMHO.

By "list of current Giant players" do you mean a literal list of names, or do you mean photos?

A list would get dated pretty fast, IMHO.

True about the players getting dated.