56-05 NFL Partner Draft Semi-Final 1 : UK/WLK vs Shane/Milk

[MilkSpiller22]

@MilkSpiller22

Lol what happened to Centers in the second half... after looking again I can see the first half going either way but Milk your belief that not having a guy taller than 6'2" in a lineup is asinine... short yardage is what our first unit would thrive on with Keith Byars and the most dangerous running back as a dual threat in NFL history... the dline you have is absolutely great, and I believe it makes it tough on Warner... but there is no way you can get to him in less than 1 second... he's going to get his passes off, we can also run as our oline excels in the run game, your dline which is impressive is more of a pass rushing group... all I can say is it's close... I can go either way on group 1, neither team has more than a 1 TD advantage...

@Shanemansj13

Switching players after the discussion has begun and it's pointed out you misplayed someone is kinda weak... second, you're looking at our WR vs your WR and saying that you have more talent... however you view that which I can see it may be slightly in your favor but our secondary is by far better than yours... we have no need to double any of your receivers and Gonzo is really your only mismatch imo... he's in the first group though and that being the case he is really the only guy we have to treat as a threat... the second units is wear the huge mismatch is... either you sit there and watch Campbell eat up the yardage or Brady kills you... you guys do have a great team though...

so basically you disagree with my 100-23 over-exaggeration??

 

[wlk3]

so basically you disagree with my 100-23 over-exaggeration??

A little, but seriously... I've seen you say that a lot and I know we all have our own hang ups, yours being you hate short receivers... but players make plays, we also have a running back on our bench that weighs in at close to 250 if we want to pound it in... also with height being such an issue 5'10" 184 vs 6'5" 241 should make you completely lose it... that's 7" and 60 pounds... pointless at this point but I just had to bring it up was all...

 

[wlk3]

Also @Nosferatu why did we need to draft a bench when clearly it was unnecessary other than for us to use $6 on a HOF back up QB and for them to have a guy $1 who I didn't even know plays in the NFL until I looked it up...

 

[MilkSpiller22]

A little, but seriously... I've seen you say that a lot and I know we all have our own hang ups, yours being you hate short receivers... but players make plays, we also have a running back on our bench that weighs in at close to 250 if we want to pound it in... also with height being such an issue 5'10" 184 vs 6'5" 241 should make you completely lose it... that's 7" and 60 pounds... pointless at this point but I just had to bring it up was all...

Never said i hate short receivers... i have said that i hate ONLY having short receivers... I think a great offense is a balance of speed and BIGness... I mean, who are generally better in the goal line?? you throw the ball high and let the giants grab the ball...

 

[Shanemansj13]

@MilkSpiller22

Lol what happened to Centers in the second half... after looking again I can see the first half going either way but Milk your belief that not having a guy taller than 6'2" in a lineup is asinine... short yardage is what our first unit would thrive on with Keith Byars and the most dangerous running back as a dual threat in NFL history... the dline you have is absolutely great, and I believe it makes it tough on Warner... but there is no way you can get to him in less than 1 second... he's going to get his passes off, we can also run as our oline excels in the run game, your dline which is impressive is more of a pass rushing group... all I can say is it's close... I can go either way on group 1, neither team has more than a 1 TD advantage...

@Shanemansj13

Switching players after the discussion has begun and it's pointed out you misplayed someone is kinda weak... second, you're looking at our WR vs your WR and saying that you have more talent... however you view that which I can see it may be slightly in your favor but our secondary is by far better than yours... we have no need to double any of your receivers and Gonzo is really your only mismatch imo... he's in the first group though and that being the case he is really the only guy we have to treat as a threat... the second units is wear the huge mismatch is... either you sit there and watch Campbell eat up the yardage or Brady kills you... you guys do have a great team though...

If you think 1 second is doing it I dont know what to tell you lol. Warners' slow ass is not dropping back that quick. The dump and dink stuff is only working so long bc we all know both these teams and all these teams can tackle well and are very well disciplined, so I really dont see it as a huge advantage. I understand trying to talk it up bc honestly we have some of the major advantages, no homerism. Something you cant control is your offensive line getting pummeled and having to bring that fullback or RB to block, well there goes your main advantage on offense. And our mismatches are all about size, well TO it's just athleticism and stronger and a physical body to control. I also feel good about big Teddy in the middle for Earl, our LB's can do enough for Earl to be a huge factor but on the other side we have the BEST RB of all-time, pretty good dual threat as well I say.

Great team guys, just think the major mismatches are in our favor

 

[Shanemansj13]

Maybe we should just cut benches out out of every draft and just the 1st and 2nd half thing if we want to expand a draft. IMO

 

[UK Cowboy]

Also @Nosferatu why did we need to draft a bench when clearly it was unnecessary other than for us to use $6 on a HOF back up QB and for them to have a guy $1 who I didn't even know plays in the NFL until I looked it up...

100% the only bench players that matter are QB and CB

 

[Nosferatu]

100% the only bench players that matter are QB and CB

I actually think WR backups matter a bit as well... I don't think QB backup matters at all unless we are assuming injuries... So to me CB and WR are the only ones that matter...

 

[Nosferatu]

Do I have to go back and look through this thread to find a winner or can someone tell me who won?

 

[UK Cowboy]

Do I have to go back and look through this thread to find a winner or can someone tell me who won?

It's 4-3

 

[Nosferatu]

It's 4-3

Wait that means its up to me? I have to be honest here, I don't know who has 4 and who has 3

Let me look at this closely...

 

[Nosferatu]

I find it interesting that people seem to be voting now without actually looking at matchups...

1st half

Shane/Milk - 13
UK/WLK - 3

2nd half

Shane/Milk - 7
UK/WLK - 20

Final
Shane/Milk - 20
UK/WLK - 23

 

[Nosferatu]

So I still haven't looked did I just make it 5-3 or 4-4??

 

[Shanemansj13]

Branch as a backup WR

Lebeau and Riley as backup CB's..not bad

 

[Shanemansj13]

So I still haven't looked did I just make it 5-3 or 4-4??

Yes. Not sure how we do a tiebreaker. I guess that's the good thing about having 9 and would have been good if we had 10 in this one...too late now lol

 

[Shanemansj13]

Best team nickname gets tiebreaker...we win

 

[Nosferatu]

Yes. Not sure how we do a tiebreaker. I guess that's the good thing about having 9 and would have been good if we had 10 in this one...too late now lol

I already found our tiebreaker.

 

[Nosferatu]

Best team nickname gets tiebreaker...we win

Man Milk?

 

[Nosferatu]

Mebert will be deciding ties...

 

[UK Cowboy]

Man Milk?

BrokebackWLK?