juliansteed
Well-Known Member
So I thought this one was pretty good until I thought about it. The cast does not even know who was killed so the end of the guys video does not make a whole lot of sense, but the rest of it does...
Exactly! People are reading way too much into the wrong things. Maybe if this were real life and an actual case, there might be a point to overanalyzing the background, angles, which way his head turns, how many syllables in the nursery rhyme etc. But this is a show that doesn't always pay a lot of attention to those types of details. I think if anything they went out of their way to avoid people trying to figure it out by use of such methods.
Remember, this is the show that brought us this scene (skip to the van falling part).
Also I wouldn't even take Rick or Carl off the table just because of Negan's last line before the beating began. I doubt it was either of them for completely different reasons though. It very well could have been Carl he had lined up and the threat still would have been valid. If Carl's a goner either way, would his friends really want to see him painfully get his eye cut out before he gets killed? No reason it couldn't be Rick either.