Ethical fantasy football question

[SteelersPride]

What round would Gordon be?

It is not so much about which player is better, but more about who makes the better value. I would take whichever player is the later pick. Their situations are both very similar.

Remember that Cleveland threw more than any team in the NFL last year. This season, they are running as much as anyone. Gordon's is unlikely to produce elite WR numbers in the current system.

both would be round 7, watkins and gordon

 

[SteelersPride]

im just torn, everyones saying watkins and hilton arent worth keeping, no they arent top guys, but 5th and 7th round value??!?! in a ppr league

in my league with the scoring hilton is the 8th highest scoring receiver........

watkins is 16th

watkins also was banged up a bit

 

[SteelersPride]

overall of rb/wr hilton is 13th

watkins is 25

 

[SteelersPride]

what am i missing..........

benjamin the dude wont trade for anyone, he got him at a 10th round value

 

[Barilko]

as i stated earlier and Tlance has emphatically stated and Treff now chiming in the same way Do It great bang for the buck dont mess too much at worst offer a decent player with Calvin for Watkins and TY or Gordon..and if you sense any doubt pull the trigger Calvin/Watkins straight up

i know i would as would Treff and Tlance

 

[SteelersPride]

the others though stating those two arent worth keepers, you got 1 top ten, in a pass first offense with reggie aging, and a budding star not far behind who was banged up and still up there in scoring

 

[tlance]

the others though stating those two arent worth keepers, you got 1 top ten, in a pass first offense with reggie aging, and a budding star not far behind who was banged up and still up there in scoring

SP, they are not considering the value.

If you could keep 2 players with no draft penalty, then, no Watkins would not be an ideal keeper. If you already had better options though, you would be where you are in the standings. Calvin is not a keeper for you, Watkins is.

Also, if it is same round, I take Watkins. He is much less risky than Gordon, and truthfully I do not think his ceiling is any lower.

 

[Barilko]

TY or Watkins for Calvin no worries choose the 1 you want more both great value...Gordon has lots of risk but if he comes through a steal..

 

[Barilko]

Tlance are you near DC man the phone lines must be ripping...

Skins knocked me out of suicide what a stinker...

 

[SteelersPride]

thing is barilko i get them BOTH now, i trade calvin, mike wallace, alfred morris,

I get

Frank Gore
TY hilton
Sammy waktins

 

[SteelersPride]

SP, they are not considering the value.

If you could keep 2 players with no draft penalty, then, no Watkins would not be an ideal keeper. If you already had better options though, you would be where you are in the standings. Calvin is not a keeper for you, Watkins is.

Also, if it is same round, I take Watkins. He is much less risky than Gordon, and truthfully I do not think his ceiling is any lower.

lets take value out of it and say its straight re-draft, in a ppr league your not taking ty hilton in the top three rounds? i sure would

 

[Barilko]

if Alfie is an expensive keeper do it

but dont blow the trade

 

[SteelersPride]

he offered that........alfie is a 3rd , he offered it so

 

[Barilko]

he offered that........alfie is a 3rd , he offered it so

do it you will have 2 solid Wrs to start the year... very nice

 

[SteelersPride]

i think i am

im stil asking the others, lets throw keepers out........your not drafting hilton in the first three rounds? really? hes had a great year top 10, and waynes only getting older, and lucks only getting better.......

 

[TREFF]

lets take value out of it and say its straight re-draft, in a ppr league your not taking ty hilton in the top three rounds? i sure would

Top 3 round? No probably not... he is still a little TD anemic. But he wouldn't slip past me in the 5th

 

[Barilko]

late 3 early 4 is realistic in PPR however an aging Wayne could mean more coverage on TY
and it all depends on who you draft with however i do not have a valid reason to say he isnt worth a late 3

this started as an ethics thread..and now.....

i gave my input on your info it is a Keeper league so no need to question of the what if it wasnt to judge value..it is what it is

Pull The Trigger...

 

[SteelersPride]

ppr too treff......

 

[TREFF]

Both Watkins and Hilton are young. . Still plenty of improvement to be seen. Why anyone wouldn't at least consider them to be a very good keeper candidate is beyond me

 

[TREFF]

ppr too treff......

Still not top three.. not yet. If he can find the end zine a few more times down the stretch, maybe... but that doesn't mean I don't think he's a great WR.. he is