Would you trade CMac for Fournette and Mahomes

[romeo212000]

Guys sent me a garbage offer for CMac where he sends Mahomes and Duke Johnson. Obviously I declined but he does have Fournette. Would it be worth countering with Fournette and Mahomes?

 

[TrustMeIamRight]

Guys sent me a garbage offer for CMac where he sends Mahomes and Duke Johnson. Obviously I declined but he does have Fournette. Would it be worth countering with Fournette and Mahomes?

PPR? Standard Scoring?

I doubt you’d get Mahomes and Fournette for CMac, but can’t hurt to try?

 

[TREFF]

Worth countering? Sure. A pipe dream though, much like his offer, although I do think Mahommes and Duke is closer to fair value than Fournette and Mahhomes would be. Both are non starters in my book

 

[TREFF]

BTW, if this is a dynasty format, Duke and Mahommes actually isnt a terrible offer. You might get 6-8 really good years out of CMac, MIGHT, you'll almost assuredly get 15 out of Mahommes

 

[Red_Chaos]

wait... granted it i don't do FF but how the heck is Mahomes a non starter? Guy is throwing 3-4 touchdowns a game? isn't that what you want?

 

[romeo212000]

It’s a redraft PPR. CMac is the only surefire starter at RB I have. My second RB is Collins. I can’t be rolling with Collins and Duke Johnson.

 

[TREFF]

wait... granted it i don't do FF but how the heck is Mahomes a non starter? Guy is throwing 3-4 touchdowns a game? isn't that what you want?

12 other QB's are throwing for nearly that too, and every team only needs one, there aren't 12 other RB's that can legitimately get penciled in to touch the ball 20 times every week, and ever teams needs a minimum of two every week. Thus CMac is substantially more valuable than any QB...in a redraft

 

[romeo212000]

12 other QB's are throwing for nearly that too, and every team only needs one, there aren't 12 other RB's that can legitimately get penciled in to touch the ball 20 times every week, and ever teams needs a minimum of two every week. Thus CMac is substantially more valuable than any QB...in a redraft

My thoughts exactly. I can stream qb’s and average 25 points a week.

 

[romeo212000]

What if I countered with Michael Thomas and Duke Johnson?

 

[SteelersPride]

Worth countering? Sure. A pipe dream though, much like his offer, although I do think Mahommes and Duke is closer to fair value than Fournette and Mahhomes would be. Both are non starters in my book

agree, zero chance he takes that deal. qhy do u feel fournette is a non-starter?

 

[romeo212000]

agree, zero chance he takes that deal. qhy do u feel fournette is a non-starter?

What about CMac for Johnson and Michael Thomas?

 

[SteelersPride]

which johnson on ur end

 

[romeo212000]

which johnson on ur end

I get Duke Johnson and Michael Thomas.

 

[SteelersPride]

nah

 

[TREFF]

agree, zero chance he takes that deal. qhy do u feel fournette is a non-starter?

If I were on the other side...its a non starter

 

[SteelersPride]

If I were on the other side...its a non starter

wow, fair enough...i couldnt sit him

 

[TREFF]

wow, fair enough...i couldnt sit him

non starter as in beginning trade negotiations

 

[SteelersPride]

non starter as in beginning trade negotiations

Ohhh lol

 

[leftypower]

Guys sent me a garbage offer for CMac where he sends Mahomes and Duke Johnson. Obviously I declined but he does have Fournette. Would it be worth countering with Fournette and Mahomes?

This may sound harsh, but I wouldn't do that unless he included Fournette's backup as well - since that will be the guy starting in a couple of wks. ..... (he not gonna do it anyway)