Who Should I pick up? Josh Harrison or Scooter Gennett

[redseat]

Welp, it is now appearing that Brandon Phillips is going to go on the DL and miss about 8-12 weeks. Who should I pick up to replace him for now?

Josh Harrison

or

Scooter Gennett

 

[tlance]

Tough.

I own Harrison everywhere for his multi-position eligibility and now have him filling in for Encarnacion.

Neither player is going to be in the lineup everyday, but both will put up pretty solid numbers when they are. I think it comes down to what you need more. If you need steals, go with Harrison. If you need HRs, Gennett is the better bet. Both players are capable of producing a little in each category though.

 

[redseat]

Right now I am in more need of steals. Home Runs are going to be slightly lacking a little bit since basically my entire hitting is either DTD or DL but I always lose on Steals.. SO I guess Harrison is the way to go