Sportshoopla top 25 week 13 discussion thread

[Chewbaccer]

Voting thread coming up shortly.

Discuss polls here.

 

[dennis580]

Here's my current top 25. Do I need to make any changes.

1.(4) OU 11-1
2.(5) Clemson 11-1
3.(3) Wisconsin 12-0
4.(8) Auburn 10-2
5.(6) Georgia 11-1
6.(7) UCF 11-0
7. (1) Alabama 11-1
8.(2) Miami 10-1
9.(10) Ohio St. 10-2
10.(15) Washington 10-2
11.(12) Penn St. 10-2
12.(11) USC 10-2
13. (13) TCU 10-2
14.(16) Memphis 10-1
15.(19) Stanford 9-3
16.(9) Notre Dame 9-3
18.(20) LSU 9-3
19.(21) Oklahoma St. 9-3
20.(22) Northwestern 9-3
21(23) Mich St. 9-3
22.(14) Washington St. 9-3
23(24) V. Tech 9-3
24(NR) San Deigo St. 10-2
25.(17) South Florida 9-2

Drop Out- 18 Miss St. 25 Michigan

 

[MarkOU]

Here's my current top 25. Do I need to make any changes.

1.(4) OU 11-1
2.(5) Clemson 11-1
3.(3) Wisconsin 12-0
4.(8) Auburn 10-2
5.(6) Georgia 11-1
6.(7) UCF 11-0
7. (1) Alabama 11-1
8.(2) Miami 10-1
9.(10) Ohio St. 10-2
10.(15) Washington 10-2
11.(12) Penn St. 10-2
12.(11) USC 10-2
13. (13) TCU 10-2
14.(16) Memphis 10-1
15.(19) Stanford 9-3
16.(9) Notre Dame 9-3
18.(20) LSU 9-3
19.(21) Oklahoma St. 9-3
20.(22) Northwestern 9-3
21(23) Mich St. 9-3
22.(14) Washington St. 9-3
23(24) V. Tech 9-3
24(NR) San Deigo St. 10-2
25.(17) South Florida 9-2

Drop Out- 18 Miss St. 25 Michigan

UCF is 12-0

 

[dennis580]

UCF is 12-0

No they are not they had the G. Tech game canceled.

 

[MarkOU]

No they are not they had the G. Tech game canceled.

Ooh

 

[Chewbaccer]

Here's my current top 25. Do I need to make any changes.

1.(4) OU 11-1
2.(5) Clemson 11-1
3.(3) Wisconsin 12-0
4.(8) Auburn 10-2
5.(6) Georgia 11-1
6.(7) UCF 11-0
7. (1) Alabama 11-1
8.(2) Miami 10-1
9.(10) Ohio St. 10-2
10.(15) Washington 10-2
11.(12) Penn St. 10-2
12.(11) USC 10-2
13. (13) TCU 10-2
14.(16) Memphis 10-1
15.(19) Stanford 9-3
16.(9) Notre Dame 9-3
18.(20) LSU 9-3
19.(21) Oklahoma St. 9-3
20.(22) Northwestern 9-3
21(23) Mich St. 9-3
22.(14) Washington St. 9-3
23(24) V. Tech 9-3
24(NR) San Deigo St. 10-2
25.(17) South Florida 9-2

Drop Out- 18 Miss St. 25 Michigan

Do you honestly think SDSU or South Florida would beat a team like Louisville?

4 G5 teams is way too many for my liking.

 

[Chewbaccer]

Had Nick Fitzgerald not got hurt, it's safe to assume Miss State would have beaten Ole Miss, but Fitzgerald was Miss State's offense. Normally I would have let them hang on at the end of the top 25, but without Fitzgerald, they won't be able to move the ball.

 

[dennis580]

Do you honestly think SDSU or South Florida would beat a team like Louisville?

4 G5 teams is way too many for my liking.

They have the ability to win. San Deigo St has a high quality win over Stanford, and South Florida is a pretty talented team and gave UCF all they wanted. Anyway I just can't put a 4 loss team in at this point. At some point records have to matter.

 

[tnapucco]

Mr. Sagarin (don't include in the poll...please, just wanted to stick it in here rather than create a thread for it)

1 Alabama
2 Clemson
3 Auburn
4 Penn State
5 Wisconsin
6 Ohio State
7 Oklahoma
8 Georgia
9 Washington
10 TCU
11 Notre Dame
12 Miami-Florida
13 Stanford
14 Oklahoma State
15 USC
16 UCF
17 Virginia Tech
18 LSU
19 Northwestern
20 Mississippi State
21 Michigan
22 Iowa
23 Louisville
24 NC State
25 Iowa State

 

[4down20]

Interesting that people are putting Georgia directly above Alabama. It doesn't really matter, but with Notre Dame losing to Stanford last night, and Alabama playing Auburn better than Georgia did, I expected it to be more mixed.

I'm also ranking Auburn higher than Wisconsin.

 

[4down20]

Do you honestly think SDSU or South Florida would beat a team like Louisville?

4 G5 teams is way too many for my liking.

He has UCF ranked above Alabama.

 

[dennis580]

Interesting that people are putting Georgia directly above Alabama. It doesn't really matter, but with Notre Dame losing to Stanford last night, and Alabama playing Auburn better than Georgia did, I expected it to be more mixed.

I'm also ranking Auburn higher than Wisconsin.

The road win over N. Dame is still a high quality win. I have N. Dame ranked #16. Also Bama did not play any of the top 4 teams in the SEC East that had winning records. The schedule just is not there for Bama.

 

[tnapucco]

Mr. Massey (don't include in the poll...please, just wanted to stick it in here rather than create a thread for it)

1 Wisconsin
2 Clemson
3 Oklahoma
4 Auburn
5 Georgia
6 Alabama
7 Penn St
8 Ohio St
9 TCU
10 Miami FL
11 Notre Dame
12 UCF
13 Oklahoma St
14 Virginia Tech
15 Michigan St
16 Northwestern
17 USC
18 Washington
19 Michigan
20 NC State
21 LSU
22 Louisville
23 Iowa
24 Stanford
25 Iowa St

 

[4down20]

The road win over N. Dame is still a high quality win. I have N. Dame ranked #16.

I know it's close, but Alabama has LSU and whatever FSU is worth OOC, which seems to be improved as of late.

It's not wrong or anything for Georiga to be above, I just expected a bigger mix but so far it seems a consensus for Georgia right above Alabama.

It doesn't really matter, other than it affecting what I feel is the best method for determining conference champion and I'm interested in the order for curiosity sake. I think conferences should get rid of divisions and take the top2 teams to play in the championship. So I am curious where Georgia/Alabama shake out in the CFP to see what it would be hypothetically.

 

[tnapucco]

Mr. Wolfe (don't include in the poll...please, just wanted to stick it in here rather than create a thread for it)

1 Central Florida
2 Wisconsin
3 Clemson
4 Georgia
5 Alabama
6 Auburn
7 Oklahoma
8 Miami FL
9 Memphis
10 Notre Dame
11 Ohio State
12 Penn State
13 Southern Cal
14 Michigan St
15 TCU
16 Stanford
17 Washington
18 Northwestern
19 LSU
20 Washington St
21 Virginia Tech
22 Michigan
23 North Carolina St
24 Oklahoma St
25 Mississippi St

 

[DJ]

Knew Auburn would be higher than Wisky.

 

[DJ]

He has UCF ranked above Alabama.

Has to be a joke.

 

[podsox]

Bama ahead of Georgia is bullshit. Committee posturing

 

[Chewbaccer]

Bama ahead of Georgia is bullshit. Committee posturing

Not really, I mean they did put up a better fight against Auburn, and it doesn't matter. Georgia wins and they're in.

 

[BoiseStateFan27]

Do you honestly think SDSU or South Florida would beat a team like Louisville?

4 G5 teams is way too many for my liking.

Absolutely, Louisville's defense is a heaping pile of trash...San Diego State would be able to control the ball and keep it from Lamar Jackson

South Florida would outscore them because their defense is at least somewhat capable of getting stops.