Roster size for MBBRL Dynasty League

[HaroldSeattle]

Please only team owners in this league, vote in this poll!

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Been going back and forth with my vote. Right now I've got my RB2 as a committee, and the guys on my bench are about as good as I can expect to have. So makes more sense for my team to have a larger roster. A team set at starters, but lacking in depth will be wanting smaller rosters so they can find those depth players on waivers. Smaller rosters could be a advantage for them.

 

[leftypower]

I voted to keep it as it is - - but will still vote for a 5 rd draft including rookies and vets. ....

 

[Barilko]

Lefty if we / you or anyone draft 5 then they need come in with 13 unless we max out over 18
At least that is how I see it

I voted 18

I was sold by Treff's statement that we need some FA available especially for a playoff team that may run into too many injuries

 

[leftypower]

Dynasty vote guys. ....

@TREFF , @Barilko , @Ram Tough , @Microwahevo , @Yellow Fuzzies , @Chef99 , @obxyankeefan , @MilkSpiller22 , @Trudem , @SteelersPride , @The Foot , @TKOSpikes

 

[The Foot]

I just voted lefty @leftypower

 

[leftypower]

Lefty if we / you or anyone draft 5 then they need come in with 13 unless we max out over 18
At least that is how I see it

I voted 18

I was sold by Treff's statement that we need some FA available especially for a playoff team that may run into too many injuries

Not sold on that. .... during draft someone may drop an upgrade over what you have. ... 5 rds doesn't mean you have to draft in all 5. .... just gives you the option to. On the other side, someone may have 16 they wish to keep and just pass on drafting the final 1 or 3 (depending on what we decide) - others may need a makeover and draft in all 5. Treff suggested a drop then draft format - which sounds good to me - easy to do if we slow draft here.

 

[TREFF]

Voted, everyone knows my reasoning, I won't be opening that can of worms again

 

[Barilko]

Not sold on that. .... during draft someone may drop an upgrade over what you have. ... 5 rds doesn't mean you have to draft in all 5. .... just gives you the option to. On the other side, someone may have 16 they wish to keep and just pass on drafting the final 1 or 3 (depending on what we decide) - others may need a makeover and draft in all 5. Treff suggested a drop then draft format - which sounds good to me - easy to do if we slow draft here.

Yepper Lefty I think that you may not have understood what I meant. Or what I may have unintentionally described I think we are on the same page

If we roster 18. You draft 3 if you didn't drop below 15

Draft 4 if dropping 1 below 15.

Draft 5 if dropping to below 15. Etc etc.

Also I think we did settle on max kept is 15. Did we not?

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Yepper Lefty I think that you may not have understood what I meant. Or what I may have unintentionally described I think we are on the same page

If we roster 18. You draft 3 if you didn't drop below 15

Draft 4 if dropping 1 below 15.

Draft 5 if dropping to below 15. Etc etc.

Also I think we did settle on max kept is 15. Did we not?

We can only keep 15, but after drafting 3 rookies, couldn't you drop another player when your pick came due?

 

[Barilko]

We can only keep 15, but after drafting 3 rookies, couldn't you drop another player when your pick came due?

I would say certainly

 

[obxyankeefan]

I thought we decided on the Mac you can keep is 15 and if you needed more than the three rounds of the draft it had to be done on the WW. Also FA are available in the draft.

But I have been wrong before, and could be wrong about this.

three is bolded because nobody knows how many rounds it is.


somebody needs to sit down and go through all these threads and write down all the rules we decided on. So we can have a bible to go to when there is a question.

 

[TREFF]

I thought we decided on the Mac you can keep is 15 and if you needed more than the three rounds of the draft it had to be done on the WW. Also FA are available in the draft.

But I have been wrong before, and could be wrong about this.

three is bolded because nobody knows how many rounds it is.


somebody needs to sit down and go through all these threads and write down all the rules we decided on. So we can have a bible to go to when there is a question.

Yep we do. .thus the need for about 4-5 polls, and again, the need for our commish to be on this board and active

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Won't take many more votes for 18 being the size of rosters to have a majority. Then we can vote on how many rounds for the rookie draft.

 

[SteelersPride]

18 wins

 

[HaroldSeattle]

18 wins

Yup.

 

[TREFF]

Hooray..now on to the next item up for bids

 

[Chef99]

Just saw this and voted 20, not that it matters.

 

[Chef99]

Of course, I was also under the impression we were keeping 18...

 

[TREFF]

Of course, I was also under the impression we were keeping 18...

Yeah this one was done a couple weeks back, since then it's been official, we are keeping 18..or at least, can keep 18..highly doubt anyone actually will, but now we know we can