It's not really an argument that can be won. You've got your reasons for thinking what you think, and I've got my reasons for thinking what I think. We will see what happens going forward
I went to Patrick O'Brien's videos and saw a pro pass QB. Kid looks really good & comfortable in Riley's system, but then again, Johnny Stanton seemed to fizzle once in college. If that new QB comes in and plays lights out, we will be singing the praises of Riley's genius this time next year ~ assuming the DBs get better. We simply have the wrong parts right now.
I'm hoping a redshirt year for Anderson and Lee will help our CB situation. We will get the right guys on offense. This offense will work if we have the right guys...you can see it on film. Some of the route combinations on passing plays are just beautifully designed. There are guys open, we just don't have a QB that can consistently make the throws that need to be made. That's not a knock on Tommy, he wasn't recruited to play that way. However, the coaches have plenty of film to show kids and say, look here, you can come in and be the piece that takes us to the next level.
Bingo. I watched TA and thought that we needed a guy 6'4" or taller to see over the line. It was brought up on BROR that the running backs leaked out and were open on pass plays but Tommie didn't see them. Yes your right it isn't a knock against TA and he is doing the best he can playing in a system that he most likely never dreamed he'd be playing in. If Riley gets 2 QBs in his first real recruiting class here, TA will be done.
Highly doubt we take 2. With as well as O'Brien has done this year, and all the interest he is attracting from other programs, I'd say we stick with one in this class so we can tell him he's the guy. Then hopefully we can grab Gebbia in the 2017 class along with KJJ and the rest of his crew.
