MLB NL QF Game 2 : Hockey vs Milk

[Nosferatu]

HOCKEY

LINEUP
1. Ken Griffey Sr. (L) - LF
2. Todd Helton (L) - 1B
3. Hank Aaron (R) - RF
4. Eddie Mathews (L) - DH
5. Nolan Arenado (R) - 3B
6. Jim Edmonds (L) - CF
7. Yadier Molina (R) - C
8. Red Schoendienst (B) - 2B
9. Ozzie Smith (B) - SS

BENCH
Daniel Murphy (L) - 2B/1B
Manny Sanguillen (R) - C
Justin Upton (R) - LF/RF
Tom Brown (L) - OF
Corey Seager (L) - SS

ROTATION
1. Warren Spahn (L)
2. Don Sutton (R)
3. Phil Niekro (R)
4. John Tudor (L)
5. Adam Wainwright (R)

BULLPEN
Mark Melancon (R)
Mitch Williams (L)
Mike Marshall (R)
Javier Lopez (L)
Rod Beck (R)

VS

MILK

LINEUP
1. Joe Morgan (L) - 2B
2. Arky Vaughan (L) - SS
3. Lance Berkman (B) - 1B/OF
4. Will Clark (L) - 1B
5. Bobby Bonds (R) - RF
6. Jack Clark (R) - RF
7. Brian McCann (L) - C
8. David Wright (R) - 3B
9. Brett Butler (L) - CF

BENCH
Vince Coleman (B) - LF
Dave Kingman (R) - PH
Rabbit Maranville (R) - SS/2B
Del Crandall (R) - C
Aramis Ramirez (R) - 3B

ROTATION
1. Grover Cleveland Alexander (R)
2. Gaylord Perry (R)
3. Juan Marichal (R)
4. Jerry Koosman (L)
5. Eppa Rixey (L)

BULLPEN
John Franco (L)
Kenley Jansen (R)
Gary Lavelle (L)
Lindy McDaniel (R)
Todd Worrell (R)

 

[Nosferatu]

Hockey - 6
Milk - 3

Voted - Mebert, Nos, Hockey, Johnny, Milk, EHB, 500, Shane, Femur

 

[Mebert]

Milk, by the slimmest of margins

 

[Nosferatu]

Hockey's defense up the middle is outstanding, his lineup is a bit better IMO as well, I do like Milks rotation better but I think Hockey's is good enough to get him through this tough one.

I lean Hockey

 

[mr.hockey4242]

I got me. This is a close one but my defense and lineup edge this out. Another team that beats my rotation but not by much.

Good luck getting a grounder through the hole into left field.

 

[Johnnydollaz89]

Hockey

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I got me. This is a close one but my defense and lineup edge this out. Another team that beats my rotation but not by much.

Good luck getting a grounder through the hole into left field.

Your 3-4 in the lineup sure is better(not close). But I would say that is all. My top is much better. I think my offense is deeper than yours.

My rotation is better and my bullpen is better too. I got me.

 

[Pack 500]

Hockey

 

[ehb5]

Milk

 

[mr.hockey4242]

Your 3-4 in the lineup sure is better(not close). But I would say that is all. My top is much better. I think my offense is deeper than yours.

My rotation is better and my bullpen is better too. I got me.

Gotta ask...how is your top "much" better. I'm ok with you saying better but much???

No take on bench and defense??

 

[mr.hockey4242]

Dammit EHB showed up this round.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Gotta ask...how is your top "much" better. I'm ok with you saying better but much???

No take on bench and defense??

Your bench has too many current players so it is hard to evaluate. My bench is all righties which is not a great thing either. So I don't think either of us have a game changing bench.

Both out infields are very strong defensively. My OF is not great defensively. So your defense is better but again I don't see it to be a game changer.

As to how my top is much better, do I have to go past ken Griffey vs joe Morgan?? Come on man!!!

Todd Helton is a great OBP guy but Colorado factors weaken it IMO. And I have arky Vaughan. I just don't see why you think that is close. Especially when I give you that your 3-4 is much better. If you want to consider your 1-2 close then I can argue my 3-4 is closer than you would think.

 

[mr.hockey4242]

Your bench has too many current players so it is hard to evaluate. My bench is all righties which is not a great thing either. So I don't think either of us have a game changing bench.

Both out infields are very strong defensively. My OF is not great defensively. So your defense is better but again I don't see it to be a game changer.

As to how my top is much better, do I have to go past ken Griffey vs joe Morgan?? Come on man!!!

Todd Helton is a great OBP guy but Colorado factors weaken it IMO. And I have arky Vaughan. I just don't see why you think that is close. Especially when I give you that your 3-4 is much better. If you want to consider your 1-2 close then I can argue my 3-4 is closer than you would think.

Griffey hit .290 with a .359 OBP you act like he was special Ed at the plate.

Then you use Coors to discredit Helton lol.

Please stop.

 

[Shanemansj13]

Hockey

 

[femurov]

I got hockey, but I would be interested to see how Milk's defense works with 2 RFers

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Griffey hit .290 with a .359 OBP you act like he was special Ed at the plate.

Then you use Coors to discredit Helton lol.

Please stop.

Really?? Compare them. I can't believe you are even making the argument that they are close. If you want to say they are close then I can use similar logic to make my 3-4 sound like they are close to your 3-4. In fact I think my 3-4 is closer to your 3-4 than your 1-2 is to my 1-2. But really if you want to consider Griffey anywhere close to Morgan then I think we will never agree

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I got hockey, but I would be interested to see how Milk's defense works with 2 RFers

If I had to I could use Berkman as my LF. As he played there for lots of his career. But I don't have a problem playing a rf at LF

 

[femurov]

If I had to I could use Berkman as my LF. As he played there for lots of his career. But I don't have a problem playing a rf at LF

You have 2 players actually listed as RF. Also, you have 2 1B and no DH. I know it's probably just Nos doing the old cut n paste, but I thought it was a good opportunity to make a joke, so I went with it.