The most exciting I've seen... In no particular order
Darren McFadden - Single handedly beat LSU
Reggie Bush
Mike Vick
Vince Young
Johnny Football
Devin Hester - TD almost anytime he touched the ball
Peter Warrick
Going with a throwback guy here. What about Red Grange. I think I remember hearing he scored like 3 touchdowns in 20 seconds back in the day. Yeah yeah I know there wasn't as much talent back then, but gotta pay respect.
Johnny's freshman season was pretty damn unbelievable. I didn't see that same level of excitement in his 2nd year as he transformed into more of a passing QB. I've got no problem with Sumlin saying that. It's one of his players and obviously he is biased. He is up there even for me though and I am biased too.