I feel like the BPI is the best index out there. I know that it is set up to coincide with the considerations of the selection committee puts forth (even if they don't follow their own considerations), but I still like the metrics they use more than the RPI.
Hahaha, in the BPI, AZ's worst performance was their 100-50 drubbing of Fair Dickson U. Well, that sucks, but it was the only way we could get to play Duke. I guess we shouldn't have let our walk-ons get so much PT in that one!
I think I remember Incarnate Word being in Division II. I don't think they've had a lot of success at that level though. I follow D2 basketball pretty closely and I don't remember them having an Elite Eight team.