Annual "Brady is overrated" thread

[megalodon30]

Then maybe you should post an image of him holding up a stat sheet instead of the Lombardi?

Why? He had the best statistical season a QB has ever had and followed it up with a SB. They both happened.

 

[WayfaringStranger]

Why? He had the best statistical season a QB has ever had and followed it up with a SB. They both happened.

Sure. But he had a great statistical season followed up by a mediocre one in which the team carried him to a SB in spite of him.

 

[megalodon30]

Sure. But he had a great statistical season followed up by a mediocre one in which the team carried him to a SB in spite of him.

And?

 

[WayfaringStranger]

And?

Annual "Brady is overrated" thread

 

[redseat]

Tom Brady is now statistically the worst QB in the NFL with a 30 QBR 44% comp%

welp, he sucks then... worthless piece of trash

 

[SeizeTheCarp]

Brady actually needs one more ring to be the GOAT. Right now he's tied with Charles Haley with five rings. Since Charles did it in an eight season span and led two different franchises to rings, he clearly has the edge over Brady as the GOAT right now.

 

[redseat]

Brady actually needs one more ring to be the GOAT. Right now he's tied with Charles Haley with five rings. Since Charles did it in an eight season span and led two different franchises to rings, he clearly has the edge over Brady as the GOAT right now.

Did you seriously compare a QB to a DE-LB?

 

[SeizeTheCarp]

Did you seriously compare a QB to a DE-LB?

I'm counting rings, just like Patriots fans do. Charles Haley left SF and they stopped winning Super Bowls. He joins the Cowboys and they start winning Super Bowls. That can't be coincidence.

 

[redseat]

I'm counting rings, just like Patriots fans do. Charles Haley left SF and they stopped winning Super Bowls. He joins the Cowboys and they start winning Super Bowls. That can't be coincidence.

only moron Patriots fans do.... Even the ball boy on a team usually gets a Super Bowl ring... Should we start saying they are in the GOAT conversation too?

 

[SeizeTheCarp]

only moron Patriots fans do.... Even the ball boy on a team usually gets a Super Bowl ring... Should we start saying they are in the GOAT conversation too?

So you're comparing an NFL All Pro to a ball boy? And you're calling me out?

 

[redseat]

So you're comparing an NFL All Pro to a waterboy? And you're calling me out?

Really? You don't get what I am getting at? Are you dense? How can you NOT see that I am saying how stupid it is to say RINGS make you the GOAT

 

[SeizeTheCarp]

Really? You don't get what I am getting at? Are you dense? How can you NOT see that I am saying how stupid it is to say RINGS make you the GOAT

Well you're one of the few Patriots fans who don't think Brady is the GOAT because of his five rings, then.

 

[redseat]

Well you're one of the few Patriots fans who don't think Brady is the GOAT because of his five rings, then.

I do not... It is a TEAM game... However the QB always gets more credit... I look at his stats (football stats).

 

[redseat]

and my bad for "calling you out" @SeizeTheCarp

 

[SeizeTheCarp]

I do not... It is a TEAM game... However the QB always gets more credit... I look at his stats (football stats).

Fair enough. But you ought to know well as I how many Patriots bring up five rings as the only reason why they think Brady is the GOAT. I mean, it's all over these boards.

 

[redseat]

Fair enough. But you ought to know well as I how many Patriots bring up five rings as the only reason why they think Brady is the GOAT. I mean, it's all over these boards.

Yes very good point. They do. I think I might have at one point too... But I shouldn't have... I think I did that when we were talking with Giants fans... Most likely after they threw those two games (that shall not be mentioned) in our faces

 

[SeizeTheCarp]

Yes very good point. They do. I think I might have at one point too... But I shouldn't have... I think I did that when we were talking with Giants fans... Most likely after they threw those two games (that shall not be mentioned) in our faces

I was just casting a net to see what I'd catch. Obviously, Brady is more integral to the Patriots success than Haley was to his teams.

 

[redseat]

I was just casting a net to see what I'd catch. Obviously, Brady is more integral to the Patriots success than Haley was to his teams.

well I think Haley had a big impact too but not as much as Brady

 

[Rex Racer]

remember when NE was going 19-0?

The only people who suggested NE would go 19-0 was the USA Today queers and fans of teams that haven't won a SB since Nixon was in office.

 

[Rex Racer]

This was a much more enjoyable game than last year's opener

But not as enjoyable as SB 50.