POLL Andrew Luck: HOF?

[thedddd]

Who were to two yes votes?

Two people voted yes???

 

[thedddd]

it happens to the best of us, no worries.

LOL...just like the two people that voted yes.
Heck I bet those two people would vote for Bubby Brister to enter the Hall of Fame.

 

[Manster7588]

Who were to two yes votes?

• StanMarsh51
• knowyourenemy

Authorities are on the way with straight jackets in hand.

 

[megalodon30]

its funny, when elway retired he had 31 4th quarter comebacks. 3rd place. part of his mistique. (unitas had 34, marino 33)

vinny had 29.

He also went to 5 Super Bowls.

How many did Vinny play in, again?

For better or worse, a QB is judged by the SB. Marino is the only HOF QB without a ring, but he still made it to the SB once. It may not be fair, but QBs are judged by winning. Want to be recognized as an all-time great, Hall of Fame QB? You better win a Super Bowl or two.

 

[Rock Strongo]

He also went to 5 Super Bowls.

How many did Vinny play in, again?

For better or worse, a QB is judged by the SB. Marino is the only HOF QB without a ring, but he still made it to the SB once. It may not be fair, but QBs are judged by winning. Want to be recognized as an all-time great QB? You better win a Super Bowl or two.

yup, im with ya on the superbowls. his best shot was 2002, but the defense didnt help him in the playoffs (268 yards, 3 TD's). his 1995 win vs my pats still haunts me.

 

[megalodon30]

LOL...just like the two people that voted yes.
Heck I bet those two people would vote for Bubby Brister to enter the Hall of Fame.

Heck yes. Go Broncos!

 

[Rock Strongo]

i wanna know who these 2 yes votes are

 

[mrschaney]

If you vote yes, Andy has better stats! And "Rocket" is still a' slingin'


Andrew Luck Stats | Pro-Football-Reference.com

Andy Dalton Stats | Pro-Football-Reference.com

 

[megalodon30]

If you vote yes, Andy has better stats! And "Rocket" is still a' slingin'


Andrew Luck Stats | Pro-Football-Reference.com

Andy Dalton Stats | Pro-Football-Reference.com

That should seal the Luck HOF debate, right there. Not even as good as Dalton.

 

[knowyourenemy]

If you vote yes, Andy has better stats! And "Rocket" is still a' slingin'


Andrew Luck Stats | Pro-Football-Reference.com

Andy Dalton Stats | Pro-Football-Reference.com

Andy Dalton is on his way!

 

[Oldschool739]

Answer the poll. Feel free to debate.

Not unless he comes back and actually wins something....Nice guy, very classy, great role model and full of talent...It's a shame he didn't get a SB, but there is a saying I use, "you have to keep on keeping on if you want to win the battle, it's for sure quitters just can't win".
I know he has his reasons and life is more important than football, but you have to adhere to the game if you expect to be in the HOF.....

 

[rmilia1]

He also went to 5 Super Bowls.

How many did Vinny play in, again?

For better or worse, a QB is judged by the SB. Marino is the only HOF QB without a ring, but he still made it to the SB once. It may not be fair, but QBs are judged by winning. Want to be recognized as an all-time great, Hall of Fame QB? You better win a Super Bowl or two.

Uh .... No he's not . 33% of HoF QBs don't have a ring and many never even made the SB. Moon , Fouts , Kelly, Tarkenton and many more

 

[Montalban]

Answer the poll. Feel free to debate.

I couldn't find the "fuck, no!" button.

 

[Rock Strongo]

If you vote yes, Andy has better stats! And "Rocket" is still a' slingin'


Andrew Luck Stats | Pro-Football-Reference.com

Andy Dalton Stats | Pro-Football-Reference.com

so we have 4 idiots.

 

[Cedrique]

There's been so many qbs with long successful careers that I think you need some longevity to make it. I could see a running back having a few great years and getting to the hall of fame. I think if OJ retired at age 29 he would still be in the hall of fame. It also would have altered the time-space continuum and we would have missed out on that fascinating trial in the late 90's

 

[Black Adam]

Andy Dalton is on his way!

ho-kaayyy, let's hear it for the Red Rocket...

 

[Schmoopy1000]

I think there is a rule on if a QB plays on 7 different teams he cant be considered great at anything but travel planning.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

We are up to 3 yes votes. I can't believe the "yes" contingent is keeping pace with the "tater salad" faction. It'll be a helluva race. Photo finish.