2016 Hall of Fame - next year's class...

[steveringo]

Ok... Lets assume we all pick only Griffey from the new list. Which hold-overs would you vote for?

Mike Piazza, 4th - 69.90%
Jeff Bagwell, 6th - 55.70%
Tim Raines, 9th - 55.00%
Curt Schilling , 4th - 39.20%
Roger Clemens, 4th - 37.50%
Barry Bonds, 4th - 36.80%
Lee Smith, 14th - 30.20%
Edgar Martinez, 7th - 27.00%
Alan Trammell, 15th - 25.10%
Mike Mussina, 3rd - 24.60%
Jeff Kent, 3rd - 14.00%
Fred McGriff, 7th - 12.90%
Larry Walker, 6th - 11.80%
Gary Sheffield, 2nd - 11.70%
Mark McGwire, 10th - 10.00%
Sammy Sosa, 4th - 6.60%
Nomar Garciaparra, 2nd - 5.50%

 

[steveringo]

My ballot would be:

Griffey
Piazza
Clemens
Bonds
Mussina
Martinez
Bagwell
Trammell
Schilling
Walker

 

[navamind]

I see Edmonds like Raines and Rice. Someone that stays on the ballot for fifteen years and may or may not make it.

Edmonds was a better player by a pretty good margin.

 

[obxyankeefan]

Edmonds was a better player by a pretty good margin.

I look at all three as the type that are on the fence between HOF and Hall of Very Good. I would have no problems with Edmonds making it.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I look at all three as the type that are on the fence between HOF and Hall of Very Good. I would have no problems with Edmonds making it.

Edmonds is not a HOF, he might be on the fence, but i see him very low on the fence... While Raines IMO is a clear cut HOFer

 

[HammerDown]