2015 Overrated/Underrated predictions

[BoiseMike19]

Ya, pretty sure I completely fucked this up!

 

[4down20]

4down20 overrated: Ohio St underrated: Alabama

 

[bamabear82]

I had awwbun as overrated. So that's nice.

 

[jwolt92]

underrated: #16 GT, that offense is the real deal and could lead them to an ACC championship
overrated: #18 Arkansas

Yeah this was bad

 

[TigerBait1971]

Texas a&m is overrated.

Boom shakalaka

 

[4down20]

I had awwbun as overrated. So that's nice.

Good call, I was a dumbass and ranked them like #3 preseason.

 

[Cowboyinexile]

@Cowboyinexile

Overrated: #4 Baylor
Underrated: #26 Oklahoma State

On paper Baylor is pretty stout and a week ago anyone 5-9 would have been a better choice. I think their recent issues will be a distraction though.

I went homer with OKST but the sunshine pumping on our boards is almost making me nervous. We lost a DT but otherwise are clean from an injury standpoint. The defense is reportedly the best of the Gundy era and offensively we should be back to where we were a couple of years ago.

Plus the schedule helps. TCU, Baylor, and OU are at home. TCU has had a terrible camp, Baylor has otf issues to deal with and OU's qb race is a dumpster fire. We get Texas (another qb dumpster fire) and WVU on the road but with an ooc schedule that is weak it's hard to see how we don't end up with 9-10 wins and maybe better if fortune shines on us.

If I didn't go with the Alma Mater I'd take ATM here. Their QB is the real deal and with Chavis their defense should be improved. I don't think they take the SEC but if they end up 3rd in the West or so they will be top 15 easy by the end of the year.

Labeling this a miss. Baylor ended up technically being overrated but unless someone called Ohio State 2014 type qb injuries it's hard to call that legit.

Oklahoma State-again technically right but woof on the last three games. Can a team be both underrated and overrated at the same time?

I had ATM as my alternative underrated team. Kyle Allen could be the next Manning. I hope he has a killer season at Houston before going first overall but the aggie experience has hurt his career trajectory. I banked their season on him and he got so fed up with the bullshit he didn't even make the bowl game

 

[BoiseMike19]

I had BSU under rated at #22. Prolly finished somewhere somewhere in the ghetto of teams 15 or so below even the list of additional 12 teams listed in the "Also receiving votes" section at the bottom of the poll.

Definitely in the top half of 64 though.......so there is that.

 

[WestEndVol]

Overrated: #18 Arkansas (8-5)
Underrated: N/R Texas A&M (8-5)

Meh. Arkansas was slightly overrated...not sure about A&M. Guess they finished about where they were expected to. Thought that A&M was going to be better, after their clobbering of #15 Arizona State (which was another team that was way overrated).

 

[Across The Field]

Across The Field

Underrated: Boise State
Overrated: UCLA

I misspelled "Clemson" for underrated.

 

[BoiseStateFan27]

I had BSU under rated at #22. Prolly finished somewhere somewhere in the ghetto of teams 15 or so below even the list of additional 12 teams listed in the "Also receiving votes" section at the bottom of the poll.

Definitely in the top half of 64 though.......so there is that.

Definitely was the most disappointing team in our program's history

we had a lot of talent too but only occasionally put it together

 

[uncfan103]

Overrated: Clemson - 108th in the nation according to Phil steeles returning experience chart. Only 4 defensive starters and 2 OL starters, and lost their OC.

Underrated: North Carolina - 8th in the nation according to Phil steeles returning experience chart. Brings in a great defensive coordinator, they can only improve. Offense lost a grand total of 16 catches, will be better than they already were. Strong enough to compete for an acc title. Whether or not they will is another question.

Alabama and Ohio State are well coached, I'm not sure Clemson is. Michigan was bad and stayed bad. UNC was good and will get better. UNC also progressed throughout the year last year.

Half right. Clearly Dabo is a great head coach, and I didn't believe that until this year. Venables is also probably one of the top DCs and I didn't give him enough credit either

 

[xpuctaqpGT]

Pre-Season AP Rankings
1) Ohio State (61): 1,525 Finished 4th. Overrated by 3.
2) TCU: 1,428 Finished 7th. Overrated by 5.
3) Alabama: 1,322 Finished 1st. Underrated by 2
4) Baylor: 1,263 Finished 13th. Overrated by 9.
5) Michigan State: 1,256 Finished 6th. Overrated by 1.
6) Auburn: 1,192 Finished unranked (26th) Overrated by 20.
7) Oregon: 1,156 Finished 19th. Overrated by 12
8) USC: 1,085 Finished unranked (26th) Overrated by 18
9) Georgia: 991 Finished unranked (26th) Overrated by 17
10) Florida State: 959 Finished 14th. Overrated by 4.
11) Notre Dame: 873 Finished 11th. Rated exactly correct.
12) Clemson: 862 Finished 2nd. Underrated by 10.
13) UCLA: 698 Finished unranked (26th) Overrated by 13.
14) LSU: 675 Finished 16th. Overrated by 2.
15) Arizona State: 605 Finished unranked (26th) Overrated by 11
16) Georgia Tech: 588 Finished unranked (26th) Overrated by 10
17) Ole Miss: 563 Finished 10th. Underrated by 7
18) Arkansas: 410 Finished unranked (26th) Overrated by 8.
19) Oklahoma: 394 Finished 5th. Underrated by 14.
20) Wisconsin: 393 Finished 21st. Overrated by 1.
21) Stanford: 347 Finished 3rd. Underrated by 18.
22) Arizona: 311 Finished unranked (26th). Overrated by 4.
23) Boise State: 240 Finished unranked (26th). Overrated by 3.
24) Missouri: 219 Finished unranked (26th). Overrated by 2.
25) Tennessee: 114 Finished 22nd. Underrated by 3.
(The unranked preseason teams that finished in the top 25)
Houston. Finished 8th. Underrated by 18.
Iowa. Finished 9th. Underrated by 17.
Michigan. Finished 12th. Underrated by 14.
North Carolina. Finished 15th. Underrated by 11.
Utah. Finished 17th. Underrated by 9.
Navy. Finished 18th. Underrated by 8.
Ok State. Finished 20th. Underrated by 6.
Northwester. Finished 23rd. Underrated by 3.
Western Kentucky. Finished 24th. Underrated by 2.
Florida. Finished 25th. Underrated by 1.

(The contestants and their scores)
xpuctaqpGT overrated :#4 Baylor underrated: #26 Texas A&M (+9) + (0) = 9pts
KnightAndDay Overrated: #9 Georgia Underrated: #22 Arizona (+17) + (-4) = 13 pts
outofyourmind overrated: #1 Ohio State underrated: #19 Oklahoma (+3) + (+14) = 17pts
Across The Field Overrated: #13 UCLA Underrated: #23Boise State (+13) + (-3) = 10pts
VFL1995 Overrated: #9 Georgia Underrated:#26 Oklahoma State (+17) + (+6) = 23pts
Mistaken4193 Overrated: #6 Auburn Underrated: #26 aTm (+20) +(0) = 20pts
SeeYouNT overrated: USC #8 underrated: Oklahoma #19 (+18) + (+14) = 32pts
Bamafan4evr12 overrated: #8 USC underrated: #18 Arkansas (+18) + (-8) = 10pts
Rolltide14-0 Overrated - #2TCU Underrated - #14 Lsu (+5) + (-2) = 3 pts
Edisto_Tiger Overrated: #2 TCU Underrated: #26 Louisville (+5) + (0) = 5pts
texas jefe overrated: Ole Miss #17 underrated: Texas #26 (-7) + (0) = -7pts
occupant overrated: USC #8 underrated: BSU #23 (+18) + (-3) = 15pts
cowboyinexile Overrated: #4 Baylor Underrated: #26 Oklahoma State (+9) + (+6) = 15pts
jwolt92 overrated: #18 Arkansas underrated: #16 GT (+8) + (-10) = -2 pts
nddulac overrated: Louisiana State (14) underrated: Northern Illinois (26) (+2) + (0) = 2pts
HuskerinBig10 overrated: OREGON #7 underrated: NEBRASKA #26 (+12) + (0) = 12pts
TigerBait1971 overrated :#4 Baylor underrated: #24 Misssouri (+9) + (-2) = 7pts
Mutiger Overrated: #11 Notre Dame Underrated: #24 Mizzou (0) + (-2) = -2pts
The Derski Overrated: #9 Georgia Underrated: #23 Boise St (+17) + (-3) = 14pts
KingKoolKat75 overrated Baylor #4 underrated Oklahoma #19 (+9) + (+14) = 23pts
theSabanator20 Overrated: #8 USC Underrated: #13 UCLA (+18) + (-13) = 5pts
Rebel Overrated- #25 Tennessee Underrated- #26 Mississippi State (-3) + (0) = -3pts
BoiseMike19 Over rated: #4 Baylor Under rated: #23 Boise State (+9) + (-3) = 6pts
Boise4life overrated #8 USC underrated #24 Missouri (+18) + (-2) = 16pts
Iowajerms Overrated: #6 - Auburn Underrated: UR – Marshal (+20) + (0) = 20pts
uncfan103 Overrated: #12 Clemson Underrated: #26 North Carolina (-10) + (+11) = 1pt
WestEndVol Overrated: #18 Arkansas Underrated: #26 Texas A&M (+8) + (0) = 8pts
USCDoom Overrated - #22 Arizona Underrated – Cincinnati (+4) + (0) = 4pts
The Crimson King Overrated: #10 Florida State Underrated: #26 Penn State (+4) + (0) = 4pts
michaeljordan_fan Overrated: #11 Notre Dame Underrated: #23 Boise State (+0) + (-3) = -3pts
Tin Man Overrated: #9 UGA Underrated: *#26 Miss State (+17) + (0) = 17pts
FredMccallyRTR overrated #4 Baylor underrated #14 LSU (+9) + (-2) = 7pts
VTSparks Overrated - # 6 Auburn Underrated - #26 Virginia Tech (+20) + (0) = 20pts
TROJAN-MAN OVERRATED- #6 AUBURN UNDERRATED -#22 AZ (+20) + (-4) = 16pts
cwalke3408 Overrated: USC #8 Underrated: Louisville #26 (+18) + (0) = 18pts
raidadave Overrated: #4 Baylor Underrated: #22 Arizona (+9) + (-4) = 5pts
(BoiseStateFan27) overrated: (#11 Notre Dame) underrated: (#26 Penn State) (0) + (0) = 0pts
Big_Blue_72 overrated: #6 Auburn underrated: #26 aTm (+20) + (0) = 20pts
raidadave Overrated: #8 USC Underrated: #22 Arizona (+18) + (-4) = 14pts
Cobrabit overrated :#4 Baylor underrated: #26 Virginia Tech (+9) + (0) = 9pts
963BUSC Overrated: #4 Baylor Underrated: #23 BSU (+9) + (-3) = 6pts
sooner78wakeboard Overrated: #4 Baylor Underrated: #16 Georgia Tech (+9) + (-10) = -1pt
ElTexan Over: #4 BAYLOR Under: #26 Okie State (+9) + (+6) = 15pts
bamabear82 Overrated: #6 Awwbun Underrated: #16 GT (+20) + (-10) = 10pts
7samurai13 OVERRATED #3 Alabama UNDERRATED #23 Boise State (-2) + (-3) = -5pts
Irish7478 - overrated: #25 Tennessee underrated: #11 Notre Dame (-3) + (0) = -3pts
4down20 overrated: #1 Ohio St underrated: #3 Alabama (+3) + (+2) = 5 pts

(The winners)
#1 SeeYouNT overrated: USC #8 underrated: Oklahoma #19 (+18) + (+14) = 32pts
#2 (tie) VFL1995 Overrated: #9 Georgia Underrated:#26 Oklahoma State (+17) + (+6) = 23pts
#2 (tie) KingKoolKat75 overrated Baylor #4 underrated Oklahoma #19 (+9) + (+14) = 23pts
#4 (tie) Iowajerms Overrated: #6 - Auburn Underrated: UR – Marshal (+20) + (0) = 20pts
#4 (tie) VTSparks Overrated - # 6 Auburn Underrated - #26 Virginia Tech (+20) + (0) = 20pts
#4 (tie) Big_Blue_72 overrated: #6 Auburn underrated: #26 aTm (+20) + (0) = 20pts
#4 (tie) Mistaken4193 Overrated: #6 Auburn Underrated: #26 aTm (+20) +(0) = 20pts

Lowest score: texas jefe with -7pts.

 

[xpuctaqpGT]

(Full Leaderboard)
#1 SeeYouNT overrated: USC #8 underrated: Oklahoma #19 (+18) + (+14) = 32pts
#2 (tie) VFL1995 Overrated: #9 Georgia Underrated:#26 Oklahoma State (+17) + (+6) = 23pts
#2 (tie) KingKoolKat75 overrated Baylor #4 underrated Oklahoma #19 (+9) + (+14) = 23pts
#4 (tie) Iowajerms Overrated: #6 - Auburn Underrated: UR – Marshal (+20) + (0) = 20pts
#4 (tie) VTSparks Overrated - # 6 Auburn Underrated - #26 Virginia Tech (+20) + (0) = 20pts
#4 (tie) Big_Blue_72 overrated: #6 Auburn underrated: #26 aTm (+20) + (0) = 20pts
#4 (tie)Mistaken4193 Overrated: #6 Auburn Underrated: #26 aTm (+20) +(0) = 20pts
#8 cwalke3408 Overrated: USC #8 Underrated: Louisville #26 (+18) + (0) = 18pts
#9 (tie) outofyourmind overrated: #1 Ohio State underrated: #19 Oklahoma (+3) + (+14) = 17pts
#9 (tie) Tin Man Overrated: #9 UGA Underrated: *#26 Miss State (+17) + (0) = 17pts
#11 (tie) Boise4life overrated #8 USC underrated #24 Missouri (+18) + (-2) = 16pts
#11 (tie) TROJAN-MAN OVERRATED- #6 AUBURN UNDERRATED -#22 AZ (+20) + (-4) = 16pts
#13 (tie) cowboyinexile Overrated: #4 Baylor Underrated: #26 Oklahoma State (+9) + (+6) = 15pts
#13 (tie) ElTexan Over: #4 BAYLOR Under: #26 Okie State (+9) + (+6) = 15pts
#13 (tie) occupant overrated: USC #8 underrated: BSU #23 (+18) + (-3) = 15pts
#16 (tie) The Derski Overrated: #9 Georgia Underrated: #23 Boise St (+17) + (-3) = 14pts
#16 (tie) raidadave Overrated: #8 USC Underrated: #22 Arizona (+18) + (-4) = 14pts
#18 KnightAndDay Overrated: #9 Georgia Underrated: #22 Arizona (+17) + (-4) = 13 pts
#19 HuskerinBig10 overrated: OREGON #7 underrated: NEBRASKA #26 (+12) + (0) = 12pts
#20 (tie) Across The Field Overrated: #13 UCLA Underrated: #23Boise State (+13) + (-3) = 10pts
#20 (tie) Bamafan4evr12 overrated: #8 USC underrated: #18 Arkansas (+18) + (-8) = 10pts
#20 (tie) bamabear82 Overrated: #6 Awwbun Underrated: #16 GT (+20) + (-10) = 10pts
#23 (tie) xpuctaqpGT overrated :#4 Baylor underrated: #26 Texas A&M (+9) + (0) = 9pts
#23 (tie) Cobrabit overrated :#4 Baylor underrated: #26 Virginia Tech (+9) + (0) = 9pts
#25 WestEndVol Overrated: #18 Arkansas Underrated: #26 Texas A&M (+8) + (0) = 8pts
#26 (tie) TigerBait1971 overrated :#4 Baylor underrated: #24 Misssouri (+9) + (-2) = 7pts
#26 (tie) FredMccallyRTR overrated #4 Baylor underrated #14 LSU (+9) + (-2) = 7pts
#28 (tie) BoiseMike19 Over rated: #4 Baylor Under rated: #23 Boise State (+9) + (-3) = 6pts
#28 (tie) 963BUSC Overrated: #4 Baylor Underrated: #23 BSU (+9) + (-3) = 6pts
#30 (tie) Edisto_Tiger Overrated: #2 TCU Underrated: #26 Louisville (+5) + (0) = 5pts
#30 (tie) raidadave Overrated: #4 Baylor Underrated: #22 Arizona (+9) + (-4) = 5pts
#30 (tie) theSabanator20 Overrated: #8 USC Underrated: #13 UCLA (+18) + (-13) = 5pts
#30 (tie) 4down20 overrated: #1 Ohio St underrated: #3 Alabama (+3) + (+2) = 5 pts
#34 (tie) USCDoom Overrated - #22 Arizona Underrated – Cincinnati (+4) + (0) = 4pts
#34 (tie) The Crimson King Overrated: #10 Florida State Underrated: #26 Penn State (+4) + (0) = 4pts
#36 Rolltide14-0 Overrated - #2TCU Underrated - #14 Lsu (+5) + (-2) = 3 pts
#37 nddulac overrated: Louisiana State (14) underrated: Northern Illinois (26) (+2) + (0) = 2pts
#38 uncfan103 Overrated: #12 Clemson Underrated: #26 North Carolina (-10) + (+11) = 1pt
#39 (BoiseStateFan27) overrated: (#11 Notre Dame) underrated: (#26 Penn State) (0) + (0) = 0pts
#40 sooner78wakeboard Overrated: #4 Baylor Underrated: #16 Georgia Tech (+9) + (-10) = -1pt
#41 (tie) jwolt92 overrated: #18 Arkansas underrated: #16 GT (+8) + (-10) = -2 pts
#41 (tie) Mutiger Overrated: #11 Notre Dame Underrated: #24 Mizzou (0) + (-2) = -2pts
#43 (tie) Rebel Overrated- #25 Tennessee Underrated- #26 Mississippi State (-3) + (0) = -3pts
#43 (tie) michaeljordan_fan Overrated: #11 Notre Dame Underrated: #23 Boise State (+0) + (-3) = -3pts
#43 (tie) Irish7478 - overrated: #25 Tennessee underrated: #11 Notre Dame (-3) + (0) = -3pts
#46 7samurai13 OVERRATED #3 Alabama UNDERRATED #23 Boise State (-2) + (-3) = -5pts
#47 texas jefe overrated: Ole Miss #17 underrated: Texas #26 (-7) + (0) = -7pts

 

[xpuctaqpGT]

raidadave managed to sneak in 2 entries on me, btw. Whoops.

 

[outofyourmind]

Lowest score: texas jefe with -7pts.

(Full Leaderboard)
#1 SeeYouNT overrated: USC #8 underrated: Oklahoma #19 (+18) + (+14) = 32pts
#2 (tie) VFL1995 Overrated: #9 Georgia Underrated:#26 Oklahoma State (+17) + (+6) = 23pts
#2 (tie) KingKoolKat75 overrated Baylor #4 underrated Oklahoma #19 (+9) + (+14) = 23pts
#4 (tie) Iowajerms Overrated: #6 - Auburn Underrated: UR – Marshal (+20) + (0) = 20pts
#4 (tie) VTSparks Overrated - # 6 Auburn Underrated - #26 Virginia Tech (+20) + (0) = 20pts
#4 (tie) Big_Blue_72 overrated: #6 Auburn underrated: #26 aTm (+20) + (0) = 20pts
#4 (tie)Mistaken4193 Overrated: #6 Auburn Underrated: #26 aTm (+20) +(0) = 20pts
#8 cwalke3408 Overrated: USC #8 Underrated: Louisville #26 (+18) + (0) = 18pts
#9 (tie) outofyourmind overrated: #1 Ohio State underrated: #19 Oklahoma (+3) + (+14) = 17pts
#9 (tie) Tin Man Overrated: #9 UGA Underrated: *#26 Miss State (+17) + (0) = 17pts

Top 10 Bitches


Thanks @xpuctaqpGT for putting this together.
Good Job.

 

[Wild Turkey]

That guy with Hawt takes:

Overrated Sparty

Underrated ASU/ GT

Blew everyone of these.