1880-2000 MLB Playoff Game 4

[Ritzarmy]

WLK

LINEUP
1. Brett Butler (L) - LF - NL Cent
2. Johnny Damon (L) - DH - AL Central
3. Frank Thomas (R) - 1B - AL Cent (HOF)
4. Ken Griffey Jr. (L) - CF - AL West (HOF)
5. Vladimir Guerrero (R) - RF - NL East
6. Jorge Posada (B) - C - AL East
7. Dick Allen (R) - 3B - NL East
8. Chuck Knoblauch (R) - 2B - AL Cent
9. Maury Wills (B) - SS - NL West

ROTATION
1. (R) Roger Clemens - SP - AL East (HOF)
2. (L) Randy Johnson - SP - NL West (HOF)
3. (R) Pedro Martinez - SP - NL East (HOF)
4. (R) Bob Gibson - SP - NL Central (HOF)
5. (L) Jim Kaat - SP - NL Central

BULLPEN
1. (R) Trevor Hoffman - CL - NL West
2. (R) Troy Percival - RP (Set-up) - AL West
3. (L) Arthur Rhodes - RP (Middle Reliever) - AL West
4. (R) Mark Eichhorn - RP (Middle Reliever) - AL East

VS

MILK

LINEUP
1. (B) Tim Raines - LF - NL East
2. (L) Shoeless Joe Jackson - RF - AL Central
3. (R) Roger Hornsby - 2B - AL East (HOF)
4. (L) Stan Musial - 1B - NL Central (HOF)
5. (R) Mike Schmidt - 3B - NL East (HOF)
6. (L) Jim Thome - DH - NL East
7. (B) Carlos Beltran - CF - AL East
8. (R) Bill Freehan - C - AL Central
9. (B) Omar Vizquel - SS -AL West

ROTATION
1. (R) Gaylord Perry - AL West (HOF)
2. (L) Hal Newhouser - AL Central (HOF)
3. (R) Juan Marichal - NL West (HOF)
4. (L) Vida Blue - SP - AL West
5. (R) Luis Tiant - SP - AL East

BULLPEN
1. (L) John Franco - CL - NL Central
2. (R) Joe Nathan - RP - NL West
3. (L) Jesse Orosco - RP - NL West
4. (R) Doug Jones - RP - NL Central

 

[Ritzarmy]

WLK – 5
MILK – 1

VOTED - UK, Femur, Milk, Shane, Ritz, Stoke

 

[UK Cowboy]

Milk has a much better lineup, WLK has really outstanding pitching. I think WLKs lineup would scratch out enough to win

WLK

 

[femurov]

WLK's rotation is just sick. I vote for him.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

this is one of those where the offenses are not close at all, but neither is the rotations...

Generally when this happens, i will look at the bullpens and see if the pitching first team has a good bullpen, and i would say it is nothing special of a bullpen... Which hurts a pitching first team...

So Milk for the win...

 

[Shanemansj13]

I like Milk's lineup better but Wlk has the best pitching staff other than mine lol.

WLK in a close one

 

[Ritzarmy]

I like Milk's lineup better but Wlk has the best pitching staff other than mine lol.

WLK in a close one

Exact same feelings. Milk has a great team but ran into a very nasty rotation one of the best I've seen drafted. Very bad draw for Milk who I felt to a excellent job drafting.

 

[blstoker]

WLK, milk just doesn't have the firepower

That's not really the reason - WLK's rotation is just filthy, and I like his bullpen too. Milk has the slightly better line up - but I think the pitching isn't close.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

WLK, milk just doesn't have the firepower

That's not really the reason - WLK's rotation is just filthy, and I like his bullpen too. Milk has the slightly better line up - but I think the pitching isn't close.

I am fine with voting WLK, he does have an amazing rotation... But how can you say his offense even compares to mine??

 

[Nosferatu]

Easily the closest of the 4 games, I love Milk's lineup but that rotation of WLK is crazy, I think there will be a bunch of 2 - 1 games in this series I would lean WLK barely... Milk did much better than I thought he would when I did the rankings earlier, too bad he had to play WLK first round.

 

[Shanemansj13]

WLK wins