Your teams ALL TIME Squad.

[TonyTheGator]

For the Gators......................
HC---Steve Spurrier

QB--Tim Tebow
QB--Danny Wuerffel


RB--Emmitt Smith, Neal Anderson, Errict Rhett

OL---Maurkice Pouncey, Lomas Brown, Jeff Zimmerman, Jason Odom, and "Ironman" Mike Degory

WR--Percy Harvin, Cris Collinsworth, Wes Chandler, Carlos Alvarez

TE--Aaron "the Killer" Hernandez, Jim Yarbrough


DE---Jack Youngblood, Alex Brown, Kevin Carter

DT---Brad Culpepper, Ellis Johnson

LB---Wilbur Marshall, Jevon Kearse, Brandon Spikes, Scot Brantley

CB--Lito Sheppard, Joe Haden, Jarvis Williams

S---Reggie Nelson, Louis Oliver, Tony Lilly

PK---Jeff Chandler

p---Ray Criswell

 

[Brasky]

Nebraska beating Georgia in the voting right now pretty handily.

 

[GreenNickle]

I feel like tOSU has had some better QBs that Krenzel. He was a winner and a smart smart guy but I think they had better.



Joe Germaine was friggin sweet.

It does amaze me that Ohio State has never had an elite QB ever, like an Elway, Luck, Marino etc.
They have had good and even great QB's but none that could even be considered in the top 10 of all-time

 

[charlie42s]

-
its last 25 yrs, so Earl is out.

Stupid ESPN, last 25 years is not All-Time.

 

[Smart]

QB: Russell Wilson
QB: Scott Tolzien
RB: Ron Dayne
RB: Montee Ball
RB: John Clay
FB: Al Ameche
WR: Lee Evans
WR: Al Toon
WR: Chris Chambers
TE: Lance Kendricks
TE: Owen Daniels
OL: Joe Thomas
OL: Gabe Carimi
OL: John Moffit
OL: Kevin Zeitler
OL: Peter Konz

DE: O'brien Schofield
DT: J.J. Watt
DT: Matt Shaughnessy
DE: Erasmus James
LB: Jonathan Casillas
LB: DeAndre Levy
LB: Jamar Fletcher
CB: Troy Vincent
CB: Allen Langford
S: Jim Leonhard
S: Jay Valai

K: Taylor Melhaff
P: Brad Nortman

Coach: Barry Alvarez

Good team, but I think you have to add:
Richter as the starting TE
Gruber and Gibson for OL depth
The safeties also need to be changed up. I can't think of good starters there, but I think several recent safeties have been better than that pair. Going back, i'm sure there were some exceptional choices.

Also, Fletcher is a CB. His replacement (who should be the #1 linebacker period) should be Chris Borland. And Fletcher should be starting at CB with Langford to the bench.

 

[TexasExes98]

-

Tom Brady?? How does a guy that splits his time as a senior make the list? Grbac and Henne were both more productive as QBs.

Actually, Brian Griese is greater than all 3 of those guys. I guess championships mean nothing today....

 

[charlie42s]

Stupid ESPN, last 25 years is not All-Time.

Stupid me, we're doing All-Time, they are doing "Ultimate".

 

[Tomhusker]

This was fucking tough.

Since 1914, Nebraska has produced 94 players who have collected a total of 108 first-team All-American awards. According to the NCAA, the Huskers' total of 53 consensus All-Americans ranks sixth among NCAA Division I-A schools and second among conference schools.

Probably gonna be some backlash from a couple Husker fans because this list is so ridiculously debatable.

HC: Tom Osborne

QB: Tommy Frazier
QB: Eric Crouch
QB: Turner Gill
RB: Lawrence Phillips
RB: Mike Rozier
RB: Ahman Green
FB: Joel Makovicka, Tom Rathman
WR: Johnny Rodgers
WR: Irving Fryar
TE: Junior Miller
OT: Zach Weigert
OT: Bob Newton
OG: Dean Steinkuhler
OG: Will Shields
C: Dave Rimington


DE: Grant Wistrom
DT: Ndamukong Suh
DT: Jason Peter Neil Smith
DE: Kyle Vanden Bosch
MG: Rich Glover
LB: Trev Alberts
LB: Lavonte David
LB: Broderick Thomas
S: Mike Brown
S: Josh Bullocks
CB: Ralph Brown
CB: Michael Booker
Rover: Mike Minter
KR: Johnny Rodgers
PR: Johnny Rodgers
K: Alex Henery
P: Kyle Larson

Just a couple of additions. Not sure if I would have Crouch on there.

 

[Smart]

-

Tom Brady?? How does a guy that splits his time as a senior make the list? Grbac and Henne were both more productive as QBs.

Tom Brady didn't "split time" unless your definition of "split time" is get taken out in blowouts and have to outplay your backup in spring camp. He started every game his Junior and Senior seasons (after Griese left). He threw about six times as many passes as Henson did. Brady was a solid college QB in a system where the QB wasn't supposed to thrive.

 

[Edisto_Tiger]

FSU Offense

QB -- Charlie Ward, Chris Weinke
RB -- Warrick Dunn, Greg Allen
FB -- William Floyd, "Pooh Bear" Williams
TE -- Pat Carter
WR -- Fred Biletnikoff, Peter Warrick, Anquan Boldin, Lawrence Dawsey
OL -- Alex Barron, Walter Jones, Clay Shiver, James Dukes, Jason Whitaker

FSU Defense

CB -- Deion Sanders, Terrell Buckley, Leroy Butler, Xavier Rhodes
S -- Derrick Gibson, Pat Watkins
LB -- Derrick Brooks, Marvin Jones, Sam Cowart
DL -- Ron Simmons, Derrick Alexander, Andre Wadsworth, Peter Boulware, Jamal Reynolds, Tank Carridine, Bjeorn Werner


K -- Sebastian Janikowski, Dustin Hopkins
P -- Ron Stark


KR -- Peter Warrick, Greg Reid
PR -- Peter Warrick, Greg Reid

I went to high school with one of those Boulwares. I can never remember which one. We won the state championship that year too.

 

[Smart]

Also, Wisconsin's All-Star team from the last 25 years is better than most of these choices from ESPN. We also might have the single best All-Star offense over that period. We have the top QB, two top 5 RBs, and a top 3 O-Line. Even our receivers were All-Americans.

 

[Edisto_Tiger]

 

[pabartl787]

WOW, 7 pages and no PSU list, I guess we are a rare breed on here. Ok, I'll give it a shot. I will add a RB and a few LBs to this list cause we a DEEP at those positions. I haven't seen ESPiN's list and I won't see it cause they're idiots. Here goes.....

Offense
QB1: Kerry Collins
QB2: Todd Blackledge
RB1: Larry Johnson
RB2: Curt Warner
RB3: Ki-Jana Carter
WR1: Bobby Engram
WR2: Kenny Jackson
WR3: OJ McDuffie
TE1: Kyle Brady
OT1: Chris Conlin
OT2: Tom Rafferty
OG1: Steve Wisniewski
OG2: Steve Suhey
C: Jeff Hartings

Defense (Here's where it gets tough)
DE1: Tamba Hali
DE2: Michael Haynes
DT1: Jimmy Kennedy
DT2: Mike Reid
LB1: Jack Ham
LB2: Matt Millen
LB3: LaVar Arrington
LB4: Paul Posluszny
LB5: Dan Connor
LB6: Sean Lee (There's more but you get the idea....We're Linebacker U.)
CB1: Alan Zemaitis
CB2: Justin King
S1: Darren Perry
S2: Michael Zordich

Kicker: Matt Bahr



Ok, there it is.

 

[john01992]

Syracuse:
QB: Mcnabb
FB: Jim brown, Daryl Johnston
HB: ernie davis, csonka
WR: art monk, marvin harrison
TE: Mackey
C: Jim Ringo
G: Wolfey, Flannery
T: Sweeny, Walters

i challenge someone to produce an all-time defense capable of stopping this offense or a better all-time offense from their team

good luck.....

 

[pabartl787]

Syracuse:
QB: Mcnabb
FB: Jim brown, Daryl Johnston
HB: ernie davis, csonka
WR: art monk, marvin harrison
TE: Mackey
C: Jim Ringo
G: Wolfey, Flannery
T: Sweeny, Walters

i challenge someone to produce an all-time defense capable of stopping this offense or a better all-time offense from their team

good luck.....

Shouldnt be too hard when you have McChoke at QB

 

[FSUmanager]

Syracuse:
QB: Mcnabb
FB: Jim brown, Daryl Johnston
HB: ernie davis, csonka
WR: art monk, marvin harrison
TE: Mackey
C: Jim Ringo
G: Wolfey, Flannery
T: Sweeny, Walters

i challenge someone to produce an all-time defense capable of stopping this offense or a better all-time offense from their team

good luck.....

Right here. I would put these guys up in their prime against any offense. A little homerism, but look at the names on that list.

CB -- Deion Sanders, Terrell Buckley, Leroy Butler, Xavier Rhodes
S -- Derrick Gibson, Pat Watkins
LB -- Derrick Brooks, Marvin Jones, Sam Cowart
DL -- Ron Simmons, Derrick Alexander, Andre Wadsworth, Peter Boulware, Jamal Reynolds, Tank Carridine, Bjeorn Werner

 

[rolltide14_0]

Also, Wisconsin's All-Star team from the last 25 years is better than most of these choices from ESPN. We also might have the single best All-Star offense over that period. We have the top QB, two top 5 RBs, and a top 3 O-Line. Even our receivers were All-Americans.

Who's the top QB?

 

[john01992]

Shouldnt be too hard when you have McChoke at QB

thats a run first offense, and if mcnabb starts sucking just put in mcpherson

 

[Edisto_Tiger]

Syracuse:
QB: Mcnabb
FB: Jim brown, Daryl Johnston
HB: ernie davis, csonka
WR: art monk, marvin harrison
TE: Mackey
C: Jim Ringo
G: Wolfey, Flannery
T: Sweeny, Walters

i challenge someone to produce an all-time defense capable of stopping this offense or a better all-time offense from their team

good luck.....

done.

 

[john01992]

Right here. I would put these guys up in their prime against any offense. A little homerism, but look at the names on that list.

CB -- Deion Sanders, Terrell Buckley, Leroy Butler, Xavier Rhodes
S -- Derrick Gibson, Pat Watkins
LB -- Derrick Brooks, Marvin Jones, Sam Cowart
DL -- Ron Simmons, Derrick Alexander, Andre Wadsworth, Peter Boulware, Jamal Reynolds, Tank Carridine, Bjeorn Werner

it would be a good matchup, but cuse has way too much starpower.
6 NFL hall of famers + 1 future first ballot + mcnabb (whose on the bubble) + a heisman winner who never played in the NFL