Which QB Would You Sign?

[Yo Tee]

QB A - 133 starts, 70-61-2, 31,705 passing yards, 204 TDs, 118 INTs, 0-4 in the playoffs
QB B - 127 starts, 70-56-1, 29,755 passing yards, 184 TDs, 110 INTs, 3-4 in the playoffs
QB C - 153 starts, 70-82-1, 42,042 passing yards, 264 TDs, 137 INTs, 0-3 in the playoffs

Which QB would you rather have if these were the only 3 options you had when picking a starting QB to build a franchise around?


Names will be revealed later if they aren't figured out already lol

 

[Shanemansj13]

Ages?

 

[rmilia1]

Right now ?? B or C. Depends on my skill guys. Prettt sure I know all 3 .

 

[rmilia1]

Ages?

C is oldest then A then B. All within 3 years though

 

[Yo Tee]

Ages?

QB A is 34
QB B is 32
QB C is 33

 

[broncosmitty]

I'll take Stafford.

 

[broncosmitty]

QB A is 34
QB B is 32
QB C is 33

C is 32

 

[DJ]

Cam.

 

[rmilia1]

QB A is 34
QB B is 32
QB C is 33

Shit really ? Lol. I still think i know all 3 but maybe A waa older when he came in the league since C has been playing longer ( if im right anyway lol )

 

[Yo Tee]

C is 32

I added a year onto their ages because this would be next year, in theory.

 

[Yo Tee]

Shit really ? Lol. I still think i know all 3 but maybe A waa older when he came in the league since C has been playing longer ( if im right anyway lol )

I did add a year to their current ages because in theory this would be a next year signing but I do think you're probably right. C came into the league first, A and B at the same time.

 

[rmilia1]

I did add a year to their current ages because in theory this would be a next year signing but I do think you're probably right. C came into the league first, A and B at the same time.

Ok cool. Personally I'd go with C for my team

 

[HaroldSeattle]

QB A - 133 starts, 70-61-2, 31,705 passing yards, 204 TDs, 118 INTs, 0-4 in the playoffs
QB B - 127 starts, 70-56-1, 29,755 passing yards, 184 TDs, 110 INTs, 3-4 in the playoffs
QB C - 153 starts, 70-82-1, 42,042 passing yards, 264 TDs, 137 INTs, 0-3 in the playoffs

Which QB would you rather have if these were the only 3 options you had when picking a starting QB to build a franchise around?


Names will be revealed later if they aren't figured out already lol

I'd go
Stafford
Cam
Dalton

 

[TheLonestarDUCK]

I like the playoff experience with QB - B

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

I went with Cam but none of them will win you a SB.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

I went with Cam but none of them will win you a SB.

Stafford and Cam could on elite teams. I don't think the Pats are that and the Lions very obviously are not; though Stafford will put up some pretty stats with their skill position talent there.

 

[cwalke3408]

C looks like a player that can make things happen. A is probably my 2nd choice

 

[ducky]

This is a great example of how past stats mean almost nothing.

I wouldn’t touch Dalton for anything more than a backup. He has PTSD still from his final years in Cinci. Cam’s arm has never come back. Stanford can still sling it.

 

[Edonidd]

Cam seems like kind of a prick, but gingers have noo soul. So I would be ok signing either one of them into Detroit. Get Stafford the hell out of here though. He's been through enough, let him go somewhere else and have a chance at winning.


Ideally though Detroit doesn't sign anybody. We need to draft a QB. That girl QB from Clemson would be my first choice, ruin her life for a bit. But Fields could come here too, I'm always ready to ruin a buckeyes career.

 

[Balljim55]

This scenario is meaningless to me. much of a QB's success or failure hinges on who you surround him with, who's calling the plays, do you play outdoors in bad weather etc.