What is Christian McCaffrey worth?

[HaroldSeattle]

Always tough to gauge worth with a injured player. I'm in a league where the McCaffrey owner is tied for 5th, but is favored to lose this week end. What the feeling of offering Jonathan Taylor and a 2021 first? I highly doubt this owner would accept that. He's in several leagues with me and I've done several trades with him and he's a extremely tough horse trader. So if he declines would you add to the offer? My roster:






I'm just mulling the idea for the moment. I've got a bunch of promising young players and maybe do nothing is best.

 

[SteelersPride]

I’d tack on any vet .or a mid round pick...watkins? Ertz.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

I’d tack on any vet .or a mid round pick...watkins? Ertz.

I"d love to tack on Watkins and will do so if I make a offer.

 

[SteelersPride]

I"d love to tack on Watkins and will do so if I make a offer.

lolol, just may be semi intriguing.......may be on "ok" idea to see if watkins plays and has a nice game this week

 

[HaroldSeattle]

I’d tack on any vet .or a mid round pick...watkins? Ertz.

Good idea SP. Right now I have Watkins as part of a package deal for Tee Higgins, but the owner is not the trading type so I'm sure I'll still own Watkins after this weekend.

 

[SteelersPride]

Good idea SP. Right now I have Watkins as part of a package deal for Tee Higgins, but the owner is not the trading type so I'm sure I'll still own Watkins after this weekend.

yeah, watkins is spotty, we all know that, is hardman off the covid list:? even more reason for him to have a good game.....dunno if he is.....but first game back, get him involved,..........looks good and trade him off......watkins is a guy that even if he has a great second half of the year, your not gonna be upset about it

 

[Sam Sportboy]

Always tough to gauge worth with a injured player. I'm in a league where the McCaffrey owner is tied for 5th, but is favored to lose this week end. What the feeling of offering Jonathan Taylor and a 2021 first? I highly doubt this owner would accept that. He's in several leagues with me and I've done several trades with him and he's a extremely tough horse trader. So if he declines would you add to the offer? My roster:

View attachment 258759
View attachment 258760
View attachment 258761
View attachment 258762

I'm just mulling the idea for the moment. I've got a bunch of promising young players and maybe do nothing is best.

Not sure what I would take, but in my keeper where I have CMac that just isn't gonna move me. Let's say they do shut CMac down, I see it as saved touches fer the future...............

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Not sure what I would take, but in my keeper where I have CMac that just isn't gonna move me. Let's say they do shut CMac down, I see it as saved touches fer the future...............

Well if it's a no go, nothing lost. I'm making the playoffs it look like and just looking around for ideas to improve the roster, either short or long term. I added Reagor just yesterday and trying to see if I can land Higgins now. CMC is just an idea for now.

 

[TKOSpikes]

Always tough to gauge worth with a injured player. I'm in a league where the McCaffrey owner is tied for 5th, but is favored to lose this week end. What the feeling of offering Jonathan Taylor and a 2021 first? I highly doubt this owner would accept that. He's in several leagues with me and I've done several trades with him and he's a extremely tough horse trader. So if he declines would you add to the offer? My roster:

View attachment 258759
View attachment 258760
View attachment 258761
View attachment 258762

I'm just mulling the idea for the moment. I've got a bunch of promising young players and maybe do nothing is best.

I'd use anyone not named Chubb or Tyreek.

Does Ertz interest him?

 

[HaroldSeattle]

I'd use anyone not named Chubb or Tyreek.

Does Ertz interest him?

IDK. I went ahead and went with SP suggestion of adding Watkin to J. Taylor and a first. If he counters or sends a PM I’ll ask him. If he just declines, I’ll take that as he won’t consider moving CMac. Some folks just can’t bring themselves to part with a player like CMac.

 

[TKOSpikes]

IDK. I went ahead and went with SP suggestion of adding Watkin to J. Taylor and a first. If he counters or sends a PM I’ll ask him. If he just declines, I’ll take that as he won’t consider moving CMac. Some folks just can’t bring themselves to part with a player like CMac.

and I ended up getting Hill anyway

 

[HaroldSeattle]

IDK. I went ahead and went with SP suggestion of adding Watkin to J. Taylor and a first. If he counters or sends a PM I’ll ask him. If he just declines, I’ll take that as he won’t consider moving CMac. Some folks just can’t bring themselves to part with a player like CMac.

Offer declined. No surprise.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Offer declined. No surprise.

Im more interested in his team than yours.... I mean, you say he is in 5th place and I assume the playoffs is top 6?? but you can be a playoff team without much confidence in competing... If he is looking more into the future than the present, then it doesn't matter what you send, he is going to be looking at it as if McCaffrey is not hurt....

 

[Trudem]

Here is my deal in a dynasty league in which I acquired him:

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Im more interested in his team than yours.... I mean, you say he is in 5th place and I assume the playoffs is top 6?? but you can be a playoff team without much confidence in competing... If he is looking more into the future than the present, then it doesn't matter what you send, he is going to be looking at it as if McCaffrey is not hurt....

He actually has a very good team. It's McCaffery injury that has hurt him. He's going with Dobbins , Gibson at RB and Mixon ( who he may have to sub out) in the flex.. He's actually in a tie for 5th-6th and he's up against the #1 team this week. He does have Mahomes and Kelce so who knows maybe he pulls off a upset. Unfortunately Taylor doesn't help his chances much so it was just a fantasy to think he's do the deal. It would likely take Chubb plus plus and I don't want to do that.