Vance trade advice

[averagejoe]

PPR 12-team dynasty league.
Negotiating a trade for TE Vance McDonald. Owners says he would take any of my WR I don't want.

My bottom feeders are:
Kenny Stills
Sterling Shepherd
Dante Pettis

 

[Sam Sportboy]

PPR 12-team dynasty league.
Negotiating a trade for TE Vance McDonald. Owners says he would take any of my WR I don't want.

My bottom feeders are:
Kenny Stills
Sterling Shepherd
Dante Pettis

Well if I'm him I'd only consider Pettis out of those 3

 

[HaroldSeattle]

PPR 12-team dynasty league.
Negotiating a trade for TE Vance McDonald. Owners says he would take any of my WR I don't want.

My bottom feeders are:
Kenny Stills
Sterling Shepherd
Dante Pettis

I’d give him Stills

 

[femurov]

Well if I'm him I'd only consider Pettis out of those 3

I’d give him Stills

Pretty much exactly what I was going to say...

I like Cook and Njoku better, as far as TEs ranked in that range. I think Stills for McDonald is a pretty good deal for you, though.

 

[SteelersPride]

I’d be wanting shepherd. Tate is our only have Barkley n engram. Jones can play.hell get targets

 

[eaglesnut]

Isn't Shepard hurt?

I'd give him Stills. He'll prob be the #1 there after Parker gets hurt but so what.

Definitely keep Pettis.

 

[Chef99]

Fer cryin' out loud, not even a debate here. Give up Stills for a TE that at least has the chance to be in the top 8.

 

[SteelersPride]

Isn't Shepard hurt?

I'd give him Stills. He'll prob be the #1 there after Parker gets hurt but so what.

Definitely keep Pettis.

It’s a finger yeah, he’s out most of camp but will be good for the start of the season

 

[SteelersPride]

Pettit has made no noise
Out
Of 49ers camp, Hurd and deebo have there’s bodies there....

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Another vote for Stills

 

[TREFF]

Stills..and it ain't close

 

[tlance]

Stills by a lot.

 

[tlance]

Well if I'm him I'd only consider Pettis out of those 3

Agreed.

He should not trade Vance for the other 2.

You should trade the other 2 for Vance.

Stills especially.

 

[leftypower]

Stills for me in a heart-beat. Hell, the dulphins don't even know who will throw the ball there. ...

 

[averagejoe]

Really, didn't think this would drag on. He rejected the Stills offer with no counter. (He has OJ Howard and seems to view McDonald as a wasted roster spot based on his texts.)

Should I offer Sterling Shepherd? Or Pettis?

Personally, I like Shepherd. I think he's the beneficiary in the Giants passing game. Pettis has the hype but Shanny will spread the ball around in that offense IMO.

 

[averagejoe]

Rejected the Stills offer.
Rejected the Pettis offer.
Waiting on the Shepherd offer.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Wow, can't believe he'd turn down Pettis, he needs a WR, right?

 

[averagejoe]

Wow, can't believe he'd turn down Pettis, he needs a WR, right?

That was what he said in our pre-trade discussion.

If he rejects Shepherd, I'm done.
Not breaking the bank for Vance.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

That was what he said in our pre-trade discussion.

If he rejects Shepherd, I'm done.
Not breaking the bank for Vance.

Kinda feel like you already did by offering 2 different young WRs in what most view as breakout candidates, both returning to same team/coach, both stepping into expanded roles.

At least warrants a counter or discussion of one, lol

 

[Yellow Fuzzies]

PPR 12-team dynasty league.
Negotiating a trade for TE Vance McDonald. Owners says he would take any of my WR I don't want.

My bottom feeders are:
Kenny Stills
Sterling Shepherd
Dante Pettis

He must have meant any of your WRs that are in your starting lineup that you don't want.