Trade offer - see a counter?

[SmokingMonkey]

12tm half ppr

I give: David Johnson
I get: Fournette + Jeudy

not really in a depth position to move a RB slated for a decent workload in this one, as I drafted Rojo a couple days before the Fournette signing. Team with Fournette was hoping he'd land somewhere else besides TB.

my team:
Brady/Rodgers
Jacobs/D Johnson/Rojo/Lat Murray/Michel
Devante/DJ Moore/Thelien/Preston/Perriman
Engram

his team:
LJax/Cam
Howard/Fournette/Dobbins/D Harris/Darrynton Evans
Mike Thomas/Golladay/Hollywood/Jeudy/Deebo/Golden Tate
Fant

hard to make a move with a team that didn't get RBs early when I didn't either, but I could lock up the TB backfield.

leaning NO to his initial offer, see any counters that make sense?

 

[Trudem]

12tm half ppr

I give: David Johnson
I get: Fournette + Jeudy

not really in a depth position to move a RB slated for a decent workload in this one, as I drafted Rojo a couple days before the Fournette signing. Team with Fournette was hoping he'd land somewhere else besides TB.

my team:
Brady/Rodgers
Jacobs/D Johnson/Rojo/Lat Murray/Michel
Devante/DJ Moore/Thelien/Preston/Perriman
Engram

his team:
LJax/Cam
Howard/Fournette/Dobbins/D Harris/Darrynton Evans
Mike Thomas/Golladay/Hollywood/Jeudy/Deebo/Golden Tate
Fant

hard to make a move with a team that didn't get RBs early when I didn't either, but I could lock up the TB backfield.

leaning NO to his initial offer, see any counters that make sense?

Honestly I think I would stay put if I were you. If not maybe flip RoJo to him to lock up the TB RBs for Harris or Dobbins.

 

[SteelersPride]

yeah, id maybe try and move rojo, u cripple yourself at RB if the tampa backs by some chance dont take control

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I don't know... Johnson and Fournette have very similar downsides... Johnson's downsize has a little more injury risk...

with fournette in TB, I think his upside is actually higher than Johnson's...


this is all about how high you on on Jeudy… if you think he is or will be a startable WR, then I would do this deal...

But if you think Jeudy is just a throw in, then sure... don't do it...

I don't think there is such thing as a counter here...

 

[Shanemansj13]

How many WR's do you start? Do you have a flex?

 

[huskers1217]

12tm half ppr

I give: David Johnson
I get: Fournette + Jeudy

not really in a depth position to move a RB slated for a decent workload in this one, as I drafted Rojo a couple days before the Fournette signing. Team with Fournette was hoping he'd land somewhere else besides TB.

my team:
Brady/Rodgers
Jacobs/D Johnson/Rojo/Lat Murray/Michel
Devante/DJ Moore/Thelien/Preston/Perriman
Engram

his team:
LJax/Cam
Howard/Fournette/Dobbins/D Harris/Darrynton Evans
Mike Thomas/Golladay/Hollywood/Jeudy/Deebo/Golden Tate
Fant

hard to make a move with a team that didn't get RBs early when I didn't either, but I could lock up the TB backfield.

leaning NO to his initial offer, see any counters that make sense?

add
give away brady
add cam

by week 3, I think Fournette is a stud. Brady needs a good running game that keeps the defense on its heels.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

add
give away brady
add cam

by week 3, I think Fournette is a stud. Brady needs a good running game that keeps the defense on its heels.

I'm out on Cam, happy to have him prove me wrong, but I don't want anything to do with him for fantasy.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

How many WR's do you start? Do you have a flex?

QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, TE, 1 flex, K, DST

rolling with Adams/DJM/Thelien then Jacobs/D Johnson right now

 

[SmokingMonkey]

I don't know... Johnson and Fournette have very similar downsides... Johnson's downsize has a little more injury risk...

with fournette in TB, I think his upside is actually higher than Johnson's...


this is all about how high you on on Jeudy… if you think he is or will be a startable WR, then I would do this deal...

But if you think Jeudy is just a throw in, then sure... don't do it...

I don't think there is such thing as a counter here...

I have 0 rookie WRs on my teams in redraft, and always wait to see who pops/looks like the real deal before picking any up. Too much volatility in whether or not they actually do a damn things their rookie year, and even so, it is very rare for them to perform right out the gates.

Jeudy isn't even the WR1 on his team, another mark against him in my book for redraft leagues

 

[Shanemansj13]

I don't know... Johnson and Fournette have very similar downsides... Johnson's downsize has a little more injury risk...

with fournette in TB, I think his upside is actually higher than Johnson's...


this is all about how high you on on Jeudy… if you think he is or will be a startable WR, then I would do this deal...

But if you think Jeudy is just a throw in, then sure... don't do it...

I don't think there is such thing as a counter here...

Yeah I feel the same way...both have risk but Djohnson's is injuries. Fournette could be Ronald starting but honestly, not too worried about that bc we've seen Fournette's product on the field...he's better than Ronald. You would have another option at WR but I like your top 4 enough...I have the same take.

Either take the trade or decline and don't counter.

 

[leftypower]

Seasonal - decline, Dynasty - worth a shot. ...

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Seasonal - decline, Dynasty - worth a shot. ...

pretty much where my head was at as well

declined and said we could revisit. Thinking the Bucs have a tough time on the ground vs Saints, as damn near every team has had the last couple yrs. If I'm interested next week can't imagine the price tag shifting much. Where as David Johnson should find some space in the Chiefs D while houston tries to keep up with chiefs O tonight (at least that's how i think it'll go down!)