Trade Advice please!

[Zammers]

I'm loaded at RB (Forte, Chris Johnson, Spiller, Demarco Murray, R Mathews)

My WR are (Josh Gordon, Colston, Roddy, and Steve Smith)

My TE are (Heath Miller, Brent Celek)


Obviously I need some production at WR and TE

I've been offered two deals:

#1. Demaryius Thomas and Jordan Reed for Demarco Murray and Brent Celek

#2. Julius Thomas and Marvin Jones for Demarco Murray and Brent Celek

Would you do this deal? Which one would you do? Would you offer some up different players?

 

[SmokingMonkey]

deal #1 - TAKE IT TO THE BANK!

DT is better than all of your WRs, Reed is better than all of your TEs, not losing much in Murray, who was probably only starting while Spiller healed up these first 8weeks of the season or so

 

[jdwills126]

#1 easy.

Can't see to much of a down side in that deal.

 

[Johnnydollaz89]

I'm loaded at RB (Forte, Chris Johnson, Spiller, Demarco Murray, R Mathews)

My WR are (Josh Gordon, Colston, Roddy, and Steve Smith)

My TE are (Heath Miller, Brent Celek)


Obviously I need some production at WR and TE

I've been offered two deals:

#1. Demaryius Thomas and Jordan Reed for Demarco Murray and Brent Celek

#2. Julius Thomas and Marvin Jones for Demarco Murray and Brent Celek

Would you do this deal? Which one would you do? Would you offer some up different players?

Deal 1, take it and runnnnnnnnn

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Dont need to respond since i agree with everyone else... But deal 1 is a no brainer...

 

[Money]

 

[Zammers]

Now I've been offered:

Julius Thomas for Demarco Murray straight up

Thoughts? Do I try and see if I can get Demaryius for Demarco straight up?

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Id still try to land that DThomas/Reed combo if I were you.
JThomas for Murray straight up? I'd pass.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Now I've been offered:

Julius Thomas for Demarco Murray straight up

Thoughts? Do I try and see if I can get Demaryius for Demarco straight up?

With your RB depth i would take the thomas trade as well...

But it is nowhere as good as the reed deal...

 

[JDM]

Demaryius. Easy.

I don't know I take the rest without that on the table, but with it there it's a no brainer.

 

[Zammers]

How about Roddy White and Demarco Murray for Demaryius Thomas?

 

[SmokingMonkey]

insist on getting Reed if that owner wants you to add Roddy - as an every down back, I value Murray over DThomas in a straight up deal. Since you are stacked at RB, not a big deal to lose a little value at that position in your case.

Not a whole lot of backs out there that play on running and passing downs, and Murray is one of them, even if he is injury prone

 

[Bandit]

I'm with the rest of the group in saying that deal #1 is the best one.

 

[Sam Sportboy]

deal #1 - TAKE IT TO THE BANK!

DT is better than all of your WRs, Reed is better than all of your TEs, not losing much in Murray, who was probably only starting while Spiller healed up these first 8weeks of the season or so

 

[HizzleRocker]

Dear Lord, take deal #1. I literally stopped reading after that. Not sure how many choices you have, but still feel certain you can do no better than deal 1.

You are giving up a bench player to get 2 starters where you need them.

 

[Barilko]

im way behind and now catching up on todays threads...

hey no doubt great and easy advice above

NUMBER ONE !!!!!!

 

[Zammers]

I've been countered

Julius Thomas and Marvin Jones for Demarco Murray and Brent Celek

Thoughts?